a********8 发帖数: 73 | 1 Timeline (tsc)
1/13 received date
1/17 notice date
1/27 pp request received
1/30 status changed from "initial review" to "accepted"
2/7 status changed to "decision", approval notice by email
Background:
PhD from top engineering school in US
Postdoc in top ivy school
Field: CS / comp bio
Publication: 13 papers in journals and peer-reviewed conferences
Citation: 120+ (90+ nonself)
Reviews: 20
2 papers were highlighted 3 times by faculty 1000 and top conference
5 reference letter (4 independent)
Claim: contributions, authorship, reviewer
第一次申请时遭遇RFE by #399, 只承认了review,不承认contribution,authorship和
totality。当时版上有两个id也是diy eb1a被rfe, 他们后来都选了找郭律师回复。而
我决定继续diy rfe的回复,因为当时感觉vo没有仔细看,自己再好好写就可以过。最
终他们俩的case都被批了,我的case被拒了。有了这个经历, 我意识到好律师的重要性
。如果你写作很牛,当然可以diy, 否则请好律师帮忙可以更好地包装你。
在被拒后我马上决定请律师帮忙再申请一次。我选的是郭律师,主要是考虑到他成功地
帮同一时期申请的id回复了RFE。事实证明他确实是很不错的选择。在准备的几个月內
我们通了许多封email和电话,每次我有问题无论是Email还是电话,他都很快回复,非
常的认真和负责。在推荐信方面,郭律师帮助我有效地组织内容,条理清晰,重点突出
,比我diy的强多了。最后的PL只有短短的12页就把我所有的qualification清晰的展示
出来。在准备的过程中在这个版上学到很多, 祝所有xdjm都早日通过,拿到绿卡!
站内发信律师的联系 |
b*******e 发帖数: 24532 | 2 cong!
【在 a********8 的大作中提到】 : Timeline (tsc) : 1/13 received date : 1/17 notice date : 1/27 pp request received : 1/30 status changed from "initial review" to "accepted" : 2/7 status changed to "decision", approval notice by email : Background: : PhD from top engineering school in US : Postdoc in top ivy school : Field: CS / comp bio
|
z***b 发帖数: 4667 | 3 cong
【在 a********8 的大作中提到】 : Timeline (tsc) : 1/13 received date : 1/17 notice date : 1/27 pp request received : 1/30 status changed from "initial review" to "accepted" : 2/7 status changed to "decision", approval notice by email : Background: : PhD from top engineering school in US : Postdoc in top ivy school : Field: CS / comp bio
|
c**********n 发帖数: 13712 | |
X***n 发帖数: 105 | |
J***y 发帖数: 133 | 6 an AD.
【在 a********8 的大作中提到】 : Timeline (tsc) : 1/13 received date : 1/17 notice date : 1/27 pp request received : 1/30 status changed from "initial review" to "accepted" : 2/7 status changed to "decision", approval notice by email : Background: : PhD from top engineering school in US : Postdoc in top ivy school : Field: CS / comp bio
|
t********8 发帖数: 67 | |
b**********t 发帖数: 1760 | 8 cong!
【在 a********8 的大作中提到】 : Timeline (tsc) : 1/13 received date : 1/17 notice date : 1/27 pp request received : 1/30 status changed from "initial review" to "accepted" : 2/7 status changed to "decision", approval notice by email : Background: : PhD from top engineering school in US : Postdoc in top ivy school : Field: CS / comp bio
|
I**1 发帖数: 2473 | 9 这个怎么感觉向广告啊!
【在 a********8 的大作中提到】 : Timeline (tsc) : 1/13 received date : 1/17 notice date : 1/27 pp request received : 1/30 status changed from "initial review" to "accepted" : 2/7 status changed to "decision", approval notice by email : Background: : PhD from top engineering school in US : Postdoc in top ivy school : Field: CS / comp bio
|
l********y 发帖数: 328 | |
|
|
e******r 发帖数: 9977 | 11 con!
【在 a********8 的大作中提到】 : Timeline (tsc) : 1/13 received date : 1/17 notice date : 1/27 pp request received : 1/30 status changed from "initial review" to "accepted" : 2/7 status changed to "decision", approval notice by email : Background: : PhD from top engineering school in US : Postdoc in top ivy school : Field: CS / comp bio
|
y9 发帖数: 97 | |
n***p 发帖数: 7668 | 13 实在是像广告,不过如果你能发给大家包子的话,大家也就不介意了。
【在 a********8 的大作中提到】 : Timeline (tsc) : 1/13 received date : 1/17 notice date : 1/27 pp request received : 1/30 status changed from "initial review" to "accepted" : 2/7 status changed to "decision", approval notice by email : Background: : PhD from top engineering school in US : Postdoc in top ivy school : Field: CS / comp bio
|
b*******e 发帖数: 24532 | 14 re
【在 n***p 的大作中提到】 : 实在是像广告,不过如果你能发给大家包子的话,大家也就不介意了。
|
a********8 发帖数: 73 | 15
Sorry, 还不知道怎么发包子呢...
【在 n***p 的大作中提到】 : 实在是像广告,不过如果你能发给大家包子的话,大家也就不介意了。
|
l*******e 发帖数: 1519 | |
g*******3 发帖数: 2520 | |
f*******l 发帖数: 1604 | 18 second
【在 n***p 的大作中提到】 : 实在是像广告,不过如果你能发给大家包子的话,大家也就不介意了。
|
p*******l 发帖数: 2495 | |
l*******1 发帖数: 1298 | 20 cong!
【在 a********8 的大作中提到】 : Timeline (tsc) : 1/13 received date : 1/17 notice date : 1/27 pp request received : 1/30 status changed from "initial review" to "accepted" : 2/7 status changed to "decision", approval notice by email : Background: : PhD from top engineering school in US : Postdoc in top ivy school : Field: CS / comp bio
|
|
|
l**n 发帖数: 1861 | 21 cong
baozi
【在 a********8 的大作中提到】 : Timeline (tsc) : 1/13 received date : 1/17 notice date : 1/27 pp request received : 1/30 status changed from "initial review" to "accepted" : 2/7 status changed to "decision", approval notice by email : Background: : PhD from top engineering school in US : Postdoc in top ivy school : Field: CS / comp bio
|
h*****n 发帖数: 4747 | |
b*********r 发帖数: 7139 | 23 完全是个新ID,的确大有广告嫌疑啊,希望不是~
【在 n***p 的大作中提到】 : 实在是像广告,不过如果你能发给大家包子的话,大家也就不介意了。
|
a**1 发帖数: 1645 | |
h*********7 发帖数: 1352 | |
s***a 发帖数: 7433 | 26 cong
【在 a********8 的大作中提到】 : Timeline (tsc) : 1/13 received date : 1/17 notice date : 1/27 pp request received : 1/30 status changed from "initial review" to "accepted" : 2/7 status changed to "decision", approval notice by email : Background: : PhD from top engineering school in US : Postdoc in top ivy school : Field: CS / comp bio
|
l****t 发帖数: 227 | 27 gx
【在 a********8 的大作中提到】 : Timeline (tsc) : 1/13 received date : 1/17 notice date : 1/27 pp request received : 1/30 status changed from "initial review" to "accepted" : 2/7 status changed to "decision", approval notice by email : Background: : PhD from top engineering school in US : Postdoc in top ivy school : Field: CS / comp bio
|
K*N 发帖数: 7494 | |
l*******y 发帖数: 876 | |
h**********l 发帖数: 6342 | 30 不错
【在 a********8 的大作中提到】 : Timeline (tsc) : 1/13 received date : 1/17 notice date : 1/27 pp request received : 1/30 status changed from "initial review" to "accepted" : 2/7 status changed to "decision", approval notice by email : Background: : PhD from top engineering school in US : Postdoc in top ivy school : Field: CS / comp bio
|
|
|
f*******l 发帖数: 1604 | 31 有一点想不通的是:为什么版上这么多律师,就锅贴时不时地像月经贴一样来裸奔一下
?不会是锅黑吧?
【在 b*********r 的大作中提到】 : 完全是个新ID,的确大有广告嫌疑啊,希望不是~
|
b*******e 发帖数: 24532 | 32 赞想法:)
【在 f*******l 的大作中提到】 : 有一点想不通的是:为什么版上这么多律师,就锅贴时不时地像月经贴一样来裸奔一下 : ?不会是锅黑吧?
|
T*******y 发帖数: 6523 | |
w*****s 发帖数: 2689 | 34 cong
【在 a********8 的大作中提到】 : Timeline (tsc) : 1/13 received date : 1/17 notice date : 1/27 pp request received : 1/30 status changed from "initial review" to "accepted" : 2/7 status changed to "decision", approval notice by email : Background: : PhD from top engineering school in US : Postdoc in top ivy school : Field: CS / comp bio
|
y******1 发帖数: 1167 | |
c****n 发帖数: 15245 | |
y****2 发帖数: 258 | |
s**m 发帖数: 4340 | |
c*********t 发帖数: 592 | |
a*1 发帖数: 4161 | 40 cong
【在 a********8 的大作中提到】 : Timeline (tsc) : 1/13 received date : 1/17 notice date : 1/27 pp request received : 1/30 status changed from "initial review" to "accepted" : 2/7 status changed to "decision", approval notice by email : Background: : PhD from top engineering school in US : Postdoc in top ivy school : Field: CS / comp bio
|
|
|
h********8 发帖数: 7355 | 41 congrats!
【在 a********8 的大作中提到】 : Timeline (tsc) : 1/13 received date : 1/17 notice date : 1/27 pp request received : 1/30 status changed from "initial review" to "accepted" : 2/7 status changed to "decision", approval notice by email : Background: : PhD from top engineering school in US : Postdoc in top ivy school : Field: CS / comp bio
|
w**********8 发帖数: 1755 | |
a******a 发帖数: 313 | 43 恭喜
【在 a********8 的大作中提到】 : Timeline (tsc) : 1/13 received date : 1/17 notice date : 1/27 pp request received : 1/30 status changed from "initial review" to "accepted" : 2/7 status changed to "decision", approval notice by email : Background: : PhD from top engineering school in US : Postdoc in top ivy school : Field: CS / comp bio
|
w**********8 发帖数: 1755 | 44 鉴定完毕,就是广告贴。
从帖子内容看,似乎是个老ID,实际只上站4次。
【在 b*********r 的大作中提到】 : 完全是个新ID,的确大有广告嫌疑啊,希望不是~
|
c******n 发帖数: 1252 | |
B****o 发帖数: 8307 | 46 Cong!
★ Sent from iPhone App: iReader Mitbbs Lite 7.39 |
s********n 发帖数: 2071 | 47 Congrats and bless to all of us |
I1 发帖数: 208 | |
a***n 发帖数: 3951 | |
M******n 发帖数: 134 | |
|
|
w*******d 发帖数: 1123 | |
z********8 发帖数: 1023 | |
m****9 发帖数: 1025 | |
s***a 发帖数: 7433 | 54 cong
【在 a********8 的大作中提到】 : Timeline (tsc) : 1/13 received date : 1/17 notice date : 1/27 pp request received : 1/30 status changed from "initial review" to "accepted" : 2/7 status changed to "decision", approval notice by email : Background: : PhD from top engineering school in US : Postdoc in top ivy school : Field: CS / comp bio
|
h*****j 发帖数: 192 | 55 被399RFE的飘过
★ Sent from iPhone App: iReader Mitbbs Lite 7.39 |
c*****6 发帖数: 2644 | |
s***a 发帖数: 7433 | 57 cong
【在 a********8 的大作中提到】 : Timeline (tsc) : 1/13 received date : 1/17 notice date : 1/27 pp request received : 1/30 status changed from "initial review" to "accepted" : 2/7 status changed to "decision", approval notice by email : Background: : PhD from top engineering school in US : Postdoc in top ivy school : Field: CS / comp bio
|
k******e 发帖数: 8870 | |
p******8 发帖数: 516 | 59 did you get approved by 399?
【在 h*****j 的大作中提到】 : 被399RFE的飘过 : ★ Sent from iPhone App: iReader Mitbbs Lite 7.39
|
w***y 发帖数: 6251 | 60 恭喜恭喜!
我跟lz的条件差不多, citation 稍微多点不过reviews少些. 不知道要不要自己申
eb1a. 另外这个review的次数怎么算呢? 帮会议审稿有时候一次审好多篇, 算几次呢?
哎 实在是不想耗在现在的postion等绿卡了....... |
|
|
a********8 发帖数: 73 | 61
呢?
可以试一试EB1A
review一篇算一次
【在 w***y 的大作中提到】 : 恭喜恭喜! : 我跟lz的条件差不多, citation 稍微多点不过reviews少些. 不知道要不要自己申 : eb1a. 另外这个review的次数怎么算呢? 帮会议审稿有时候一次审好多篇, 算几次呢? : 哎 实在是不想耗在现在的postion等绿卡了.......
|
h**********a 发帖数: 298 | |
w***y 发帖数: 6251 | 63 ic
那怎么证明自己给会议review了好几篇paper呢? 一般会议都是发一个reviewer
invitation, 里面也没写审了几篇paper啊, 囧
【在 a********8 的大作中提到】 : : 呢? : 可以试一试EB1A : review一篇算一次
|
a********8 发帖数: 73 | 64
这我也不清楚。我的review都是journal的...
【在 w***y 的大作中提到】 : ic : 那怎么证明自己给会议review了好几篇paper呢? 一般会议都是发一个reviewer : invitation, 里面也没写审了几篇paper啊, 囧
|