l***i
发帖数: 2542 | 1 这个清华高材生,哈佛薄后 虽然满足3条,但被推荐人的牛背景给毁掉了.唉,可惜!
http://www.uscis.gov/err/B2%20-%20Aliens%20with%20Extraordinary
In this case, the petitioner has submitted evidence that qualifies under three of the evidentiary criteria at 8 C.F.R. 5 204.5(h)(3).
when compared to his esteemed references, it appears that the highest level
of the petitioner's field is far above the level he has attained. In stark
contrast to his references, the petitioner has not established that his
achievements are commensurate with sustained national or international
acclaim in the biomedical research field, or being among that small
percentage at the very top of the field of
endeavor.
这是 他的推荐人背景:
In contrast, d states: "I have written more than 80 papers that have been published in leading peer-reviewed scientific journals. Other publications include 30 reviews, chapters and
editorials and a chapter in the most widely-used textbook for medical students, in ~eura1,Science."
curriculum vitae more than 121 journal articles. The petitioner's research supervisor, he "has published 137 papers in high impact peer-reviewed journals." Moreover, states: "Over the course of my career, I
have published at least 135 peer-reviewed papers in such leading journals as Cell, Science, and
Nature." Finally, states: "I have well over 300 publications to my name, including
research papers, reviews, and book chapters."
这个只是一个判例,继续研读发现好多判例都是和推荐人比较,然后说"好像差别有点大
啊."
看这个:
http://www.uscis.gov/err/B2%20-%20Aliens%20with%20Extraordinary
Many of the petitioner's references' credentials are far more impressive than those of the petitioner
While the petitioner need not demonstrate that there is no one more accomplished than herself to
qualify for the classification sought, it appears that the very top of her field of endeavor is far above
the level she has attained. In this case, the petitioner has not established that her achievements at the
time of filing were commensurate with sustained national or international acclaim as a research
scientist, or being among that small percentage at the very top of the field of endeavor
还有这个:
http://www.uscis.gov/err/B2%20-%20Aliens%20with%20Extraordinary
many of the petitioner's references' credentials are far more impressive than those of the petitioner
这个:
http://www.uscis.gov/err/B2%20-%20Aliens%20with%20Extraordinary
We note that the petitioner's references' credentials are more impressive.
http://www.uscis.gov/err/B2%20-%20Aliens%20with%20Extraordinary
We note that the petitioner's references' credentials are far more impressive. For example
http://www.uscis.gov/err/B2%20-%20Aliens%20with%20Extraordinary
A review of the docurricntary c\itlellc.e rcllccr\
that tlie pc~itioncrs ubmitted 24 scholarly articles that were published at the lime ol' tlic filinz of
the petition. However. when compared to the authorship of the petitioner's rcI'crcncc\. i t ;~l?[?c;~rs
that his rcfcrc~iccsa re lar above the accomplishments of the petitioner. | z****y
发帖数: 6864 | | f*******A
发帖数: 322 | 3 well, I think this totally depends on the IO who reviewed the case. I saw
that his Sigma Xi membership was not recognized as well. That was in 2007,
when this membership was widely used. This is just an exceptional unlucky
case.
Hope all of us here are lucky enough to be handled by a nice IO! | e******r
发帖数: 9977 | 4 case by case。通常被rfe这个的，毕竟还是少数。推荐信里表具体提推荐人有多少引
用，paper等等。。。
看申请人背景，还有io心情了
level
【在 l***i 的大作中提到】
: 这个清华高材生,哈佛薄后 虽然满足3条,但被推荐人的牛背景给毁掉了.唉,可惜!
: http://www.uscis.gov/err/B2%20-%20Aliens%20with%20Extraordinary
: In this case, the petitioner has submitted evidence that qualifies under three of the evidentiary criteria at 8 C.F.R. 5 204.5(h)(3).
: when compared to his esteemed references, it appears that the highest level
: of the petitioner's field is far above the level he has attained. In stark
: contrast to his references, the petitioner has not established that his
: achievements are commensurate with sustained national or international
: acclaim in the biomedical research field, or being among that small
: percentage at the very top of the field of
: endeavor.
| z*****a
发帖数: 1214 | 5 这个比较倒霉，大多数过了的也都有牛推荐人
不过，推荐人真的不需要太牛，creditable就够了。 | l***i
发帖数: 2542 | 6 看了好多悲剧的 都是因为和推荐人比较,然后说推荐人都发了几百paper,几千引用,你
个小虾米 这么点paper,这么点引用,离top 还远着呢,先凉快一下吧,就悲剧了.
【在 e******r 的大作中提到】
: case by case。通常被rfe这个的，毕竟还是少数。推荐信里表具体提推荐人有多少引
: 用，paper等等。。。
: 看申请人背景，还有io心情了
:
: level
| e******r
发帖数: 9977 | 7 哈哈，美女要不要pp，还是死等？
【在 l***i 的大作中提到】
: 看了好多悲剧的 都是因为和推荐人比较,然后说推荐人都发了几百paper,几千引用,你
: 个小虾米 这么点paper,这么点引用,离top 还远着呢,先凉快一下吧,就悲剧了.
| z*****a
发帖数: 1214 | 8 换个io，下次就过了
【在 l***i 的大作中提到】
: 看了好多悲剧的 都是因为和推荐人比较,然后说推荐人都发了几百paper,几千引用,你
: 个小虾米 这么点paper,这么点引用,离top 还远着呢,先凉快一下吧,就悲剧了.
| l***i
发帖数: 2542 | 9 图中那个美女是俺的偶像.
死等 比等死 还强点. 还在犹豫,看看刷瓶的case,希望能给点信心.
月末就3个月了.
case 太弱了, 犹豫 犹豫 犹豫啊. 所以 都在研究判例,准备rfe 材料呢.
RFE 一来 我就要快速进入战斗状态, 准备了好多粮草. 但愿用不到 而回馈给需要的
人们.
【在 e******r 的大作中提到】
: 哈哈，美女要不要pp，还是死等？
| l***i
发帖数: 2542 | 10 你看那些判例里面,在最后优点判定的时候都要和推荐人比,说你不行啊,歇了吧.
【在 z*****a 的大作中提到】
: 换个io，下次就过了
| | | j****t
发帖数: 1663 | 11 看来不管找不找牛人，推荐信里介绍推荐人发了多少牛文，多少专利就是闲着没事找事
啊！ | z*****a
发帖数: 1214 | 12 怕怕，我也提了
【在 j****t 的大作中提到】
: 看来不管找不找牛人，推荐信里介绍推荐人发了多少牛文，多少专利就是闲着没事找事
: 啊！
| z*****a
发帖数: 1214 | 13 就凭你的用心劲儿，一定没问题！
最近批得快多了 - 我的140生等了9个月
【在 l***i 的大作中提到】
: 图中那个美女是俺的偶像.
: 死等 比等死 还强点. 还在犹豫,看看刷瓶的case,希望能给点信心.
: 月末就3个月了.
: case 太弱了, 犹豫 犹豫 犹豫啊. 所以 都在研究判例,准备rfe 材料呢.
: RFE 一来 我就要快速进入战斗状态, 准备了好多粮草. 但愿用不到 而回馈给需要的
: 人们.
| l***i
发帖数: 2542 | 14 是啊, 怕啊, 后背嗖嗖的凉风. 提这干嘛,真是自找不痛快.
【在 z*****a 的大作中提到】
: 怕怕，我也提了
| e******r
发帖数: 9977 | 15 表担心啦，你和刷屏都能过，这么用心准备，会有好运气的！
【在 l***i 的大作中提到】
: 图中那个美女是俺的偶像.
: 死等 比等死 还强点. 还在犹豫,看看刷瓶的case,希望能给点信心.
: 月末就3个月了.
: case 太弱了, 犹豫 犹豫 犹豫啊. 所以 都在研究判例,准备rfe 材料呢.
: RFE 一来 我就要快速进入战斗状态, 准备了好多粮草. 但愿用不到 而回馈给需要的
: 人们.
| l***i
发帖数: 2542 | 16 NIW 是过了, 1A 还在给 移民局最后通牒呢.
借版花mm吉言.
【在 e******r 的大作中提到】
: 表担心啦，你和刷屏都能过，这么用心准备，会有好运气的！
| h*******s
发帖数: 560 | 17 linji你就追随shuaping兄PP了吧，不要犹豫啦，我看着都着急啊，^_^。 | l***i
发帖数: 2542 | 18 要不是太弱了,我早就pp了.
shuaping 名言: PP有风险,小心RFE.
【在 h*******s 的大作中提到】
: linji你就追随shuaping兄PP了吧，不要犹豫啦，我看着都着急啊，^_^。
| w***y
发帖数: 6251 | 19 天哪， 我的律师完全没有避讳这些啊
我的每封推荐信介绍推荐人都说了人家发了多少paper, 当了多少次chair。。。。。。
。 | x*****0
发帖数: 323 | 20 祝你早点通过！！！
level
【在 l***i 的大作中提到】
: 这个清华高材生,哈佛薄后 虽然满足3条,但被推荐人的牛背景给毁掉了.唉,可惜!
: http://www.uscis.gov/err/B2%20-%20Aliens%20with%20Extraordinary
: In this case, the petitioner has submitted evidence that qualifies under three of the evidentiary criteria at 8 C.F.R. 5 204.5(h)(3).
: when compared to his esteemed references, it appears that the highest level
: of the petitioner's field is far above the level he has attained. In stark
: contrast to his references, the petitioner has not established that his
: achievements are commensurate with sustained national or international
: acclaim in the biomedical research field, or being among that small
: percentage at the very top of the field of
: endeavor.
| | | l***i
发帖数: 2542 | 21 借你吉言
【在 x*****0 的大作中提到】
: 祝你早点通过！！！
:
: level
| h*********i
发帖数: 2605 | | p*********d
发帖数: 524 | 23 所以要在推荐信里注意两点：
1。推荐人如果文章特别多，最好注明年龄或在此行混的时间
2。推荐信提及申请人在自己年龄段取得的成就为top. | l***i
发帖数: 2542 | 24 别这样干. 别强调年龄和混的时间.
人家比较的是行业 而不是同龄人.
你是和所有人比较,你是top的,你是顶级的,你是最强的,你是最好的,你是最厉害的.
The evidence demonstrates that I am among a small percentage of scientists
who have risen to the very top of their field and have a
record of sustained national and international acclaim.
【在 p*********d 的大作中提到】
: 所以要在推荐信里注意两点：
: 1。推荐人如果文章特别多，最好注明年龄或在此行混的时间
: 2。推荐信提及申请人在自己年龄段取得的成就为top.
| n*******t
发帖数: 67 | 25 我也提了。我老板的推荐信，专门说了自己的论文被引了几千次……
真是自作孽啊！
【在 l***i 的大作中提到】
: 是啊, 怕啊, 后背嗖嗖的凉风. 提这干嘛,真是自找不痛快.
| l***i
发帖数: 2542 | 26 这个只是一个判例,继续研读发现好多判例都是和推荐人比较,然后说"好像差别有点大
啊."
看这个:
http://www.uscis.gov/err/B2%20-%20Aliens%20with%20Extraordinary
Many of the petitioner's references' credentials are far more impressive than those of the petitioner
While the petitioner need not demonstrate that there is no one more accomplished than herself to
qualify for the classification sought, it appears that the very top of her field of endeavor is far above
the level she has attained. In this case, the petitioner has not established that her achievements at the
time of filing were commensurate with sustained national or international acclaim as a research
scientist, or being among that small percentage at the very top of the field of endeavor
【在 n*******t 的大作中提到】
: 我也提了。我老板的推荐信，专门说了自己的论文被引了几千次……
: 真是自作孽啊！
| f*******A
发帖数: 322 | 27 wow, these cases are actually relatively stronger cases
I think they were just unlucky to have crazy IO for review.... | l**********r
发帖数: 4612 | 28 make sense
[发表自未名空间手机版 - m.mitbbs.com] | l***i
发帖数: 2542 | 29 strong case？
【在 f*******A 的大作中提到】
: wow, these cases are actually relatively stronger cases
: I think they were just unlucky to have crazy IO for review....
| n***p
发帖数: 7668 | 30 其实这些都是一些比较弱的case...
【在 f*******A 的大作中提到】
: wow, these cases are actually relatively stronger cases
: I think they were just unlucky to have crazy IO for review....
|
|
