r*******8
发帖数: 256 | 1 I feel like my application was ruined by the company's lawyer/law firm.
My background:
Journal publications: 12
Have reviewed 50+ papers from 7 journals
citation: 30 (this is a weak spot, but it is hard to be cited in our field)
Conference: 12
Some awards - mostly from China
The lawyer claimed 4 items out of 6, and TSC sent us a RFE letter on the
14th day. The problem is that the lawyer doesn't allow me to be involved
much by saying that our company is the petitioner and ethically she needs to
do the work by herself.
The only things I know in the RFE letter are: it asks for more evidence
to prove international impact and a list of citation (I can't believe she
didn't include this in the petition!). I emailed her and suggested some
ideas, such as showing that the authors who cited my papers are from 10
countries, and the papers I have reviewed are from 14 countries. But I am
not sure if she will listen to me.
My employer is a big company (30k+ employees), and the law firm is pretty
big as well.
I don't know what to do... any suggestion will be appreciated!
(btw, I can't type in Chinese from the company's computer. sorry!)
|
d******2
发帖数: 2795 | |
h****l
发帖数: 2993 | 3 1B为什么要claim4项，这个容易出问题吧
不过，公司律师这么强硬，估计你也没法提意见
Bless |
t****a
发帖数: 439 | |
d******g
发帖数: 988 | 5 bless, you have less control on your case since she is so strong minded. Try
to give as much material to her as you can, but as she said, she might not
use them. |
c*****t
发帖数: 590 | 6 fragomen?
to
【在 r*******8 的大作中提到】
: I feel like my application was ruined by the company's lawyer/law firm.
: My background:
: Journal publications: 12
: Have reviewed 50+ papers from 7 journals
: citation: 30 (this is a weak spot, but it is hard to be cited in our field)
: Conference: 12
: Some awards - mostly from China
: The lawyer claimed 4 items out of 6, and TSC sent us a RFE letter on the
: 14th day. The problem is that the lawyer doesn't allow me to be involved
: much by saying that our company is the petitioner and ethically she needs to
|
r*******8
发帖数: 256 | 7 Not fragomen.. another big lawfirm (over 400 attorneys)
Can't believe their work is so unreliable. |
r*******8
发帖数: 256 | 8 Have any one else been in similar situation? I thought EB1b was easy... sigh
... |
c******8
发帖数: 1558 | |
c*********7
发帖数: 19373 | 10 不管claim几项，都要证明两点:
1.academic impact
2.international recognized
这是为什么有人说contributation是必须claim的(很多时候IO自动给你加上)。
我觉得1B所有的材料都要围绕着这两点去展开说明就行了。 |
|
|
s***c
发帖数: 639 | 11 准备好所有可能有用的材料给律师，最好都写好了的那种，求/劝他老人家用。他不会
连RFE的信都不转给你吧。
RFE后机会还很大，而且你不是NSC#0002，也不用太悲观
to
【在 r*******8 的大作中提到】
: I feel like my application was ruined by the company's lawyer/law firm.
: My background:
: Journal publications: 12
: Have reviewed 50+ papers from 7 journals
: citation: 30 (this is a weak spot, but it is hard to be cited in our field)
: Conference: 12
: Some awards - mostly from China
: The lawyer claimed 4 items out of 6, and TSC sent us a RFE letter on the
: 14th day. The problem is that the lawyer doesn't allow me to be involved
: much by saying that our company is the petitioner and ethically she needs to
|
y*****7
发帖数: 220 | |
r*******8
发帖数: 256 | 13 非常感谢大家的建议和鼓励！我会尽量和律师沟通，从自己的角度做到最好。
继续欢迎建议和经验分享。
to
【在 r*******8 的大作中提到】
: I feel like my application was ruined by the company's lawyer/law firm.
: My background:
: Journal publications: 12
: Have reviewed 50+ papers from 7 journals
: citation: 30 (this is a weak spot, but it is hard to be cited in our field)
: Conference: 12
: Some awards - mostly from China
: The lawyer claimed 4 items out of 6, and TSC sent us a RFE letter on the
: 14th day. The problem is that the lawyer doesn't allow me to be involved
: much by saying that our company is the petitioner and ethically she needs to
|
e******r
发帖数: 9977 | 14 CS专业？这个1B属于边缘case，绿虱可能包装不够细致。
你能做的，至少补1-2封补推荐信，然后仔细挖掘引用等等。。
to
【在 r*******8 的大作中提到】
: I feel like my application was ruined by the company's lawyer/law firm.
: My background:
: Journal publications: 12
: Have reviewed 50+ papers from 7 journals
: citation: 30 (this is a weak spot, but it is hard to be cited in our field)
: Conference: 12
: Some awards - mostly from China
: The lawyer claimed 4 items out of 6, and TSC sent us a RFE letter on the
: 14th day. The problem is that the lawyer doesn't allow me to be involved
: much by saying that our company is the petitioner and ethically she needs to
|
r*******8
发帖数: 256 | |
p******n
发帖数: 767 | 16 夏花MM， 你这个“绿虱”亮了， 哈哈哈哈。。。
【在 e******r 的大作中提到】
: CS专业？这个1B属于边缘case，绿虱可能包装不够细致。
: 你能做的，至少补1-2封补推荐信，然后仔细挖掘引用等等。。
:
: to
|
