t**********o
发帖数: 26 | 1 Only in May of 2012, I was told that Donaldson claimed he could do the
case for dimension 3. I was not surprised because I had told quite a few
people,
including X.X. Chen, in many occasions before that if I wanted, I could
prove the
partial C0-estimate for Kahler-Einstein metrics and then use the
classification
of Fano 3-manifolds to solve Calabi's problem in dimension 3.
翻译过来就是，我什么都知道，就是没有写下来。 |
R**********n
发帖数: 523 | 2 This can be verified by asking Chen.
【在 t**********o 的大作中提到】
: Only in May of 2012, I was told that Donaldson claimed he could do the
: case for dimension 3. I was not surprised because I had told quite a few
: people,
: including X.X. Chen, in many occasions before that if I wanted, I could
: prove the
: partial C0-estimate for Kahler-Einstein metrics and then use the
: classification
: of Fano 3-manifolds to solve Calabi's problem in dimension 3.
: 翻译过来就是，我什么都知道，就是没有写下来。
|
w**k
发帖数: 320 | 3 说过也没啥用吧
这种老猜测他们肯定知道关键点在那里
做不做出才是真功夫
【在 R**********n 的大作中提到】
: This can be verified by asking Chen.
|
r******k
发帖数: 97 | 4 关键是田刚的名声不好，偷鸡摸狗的事干得太多了。没人愿意和他share credit
【在 t**********o 的大作中提到】
: Only in May of 2012, I was told that Donaldson claimed he could do the
: case for dimension 3. I was not surprised because I had told quite a few
: people,
: including X.X. Chen, in many occasions before that if I wanted, I could
: prove the
: partial C0-estimate for Kahler-Einstein metrics and then use the
: classification
: of Fano 3-manifolds to solve Calabi's problem in dimension 3.
: 翻译过来就是，我什么都知道，就是没有写下来。
|
Z*********g
发帖数: 68 | 5 这段应该代表了不少专家的意见
http://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=6430
Maybe there is not a single big new idea. The obstacles have been there and
been known to experts for many years. There are many possible ways to solve
the problem, and none of them seems to work at first sight. You have to try
and try, test and test. The new idea is that some guy Jimmy finally find one
of the ways works, and if he told the outline to an expert Tom who had
worked on this problem for many years, Tom could fill in most of the details
, if not all. But you cannnot say that Tom didn’t know this outline. He
just didn’t know that this outline works. |
x******g
发帖数: 289 | 6 只和师傅有过争议而已。有过那一次，田不可能不倍加小心。我不相信这次老田有
guilty。
数学界落井下石的作风可不好
【在 r******k 的大作中提到】
: 关键是田刚的名声不好，偷鸡摸狗的事干得太多了。没人愿意和他share credit
|
f******h
发帖数: 104 | 7 田应该好好反省，而不是做无用的狡辩。就怕他不回应。网友的评论看的偶肚子都笑疼
了。
【在 r******k 的大作中提到】
: 关键是田刚的名声不好，偷鸡摸狗的事干得太多了。没人愿意和他share credit
|
f******h
发帖数: 104 | 8 听过某大牛的报告，田刚上一次对丘猜想有实质贡献是在16年前。近十年来的主要突破
大都是Donaldson的贡献。 |
g****a
发帖数: 1520 | 9 其实大致的证明思路，很多数学家都知道，但是技术的细节非常的formidable，所以20
多年没有什么进展。CDS近些年一直在尝试不同的改进技术的方法。田从各种Donaldson
的公开报告跟踪进展，伺机下手。很快会有第三方的专家出来给个说法。
【在 t**********o 的大作中提到】
: Only in May of 2012, I was told that Donaldson claimed he could do the
: case for dimension 3. I was not surprised because I had told quite a few
: people,
: including X.X. Chen, in many occasions before that if I wanted, I could
: prove the
: partial C0-estimate for Kahler-Einstein metrics and then use the
: classification
: of Fano 3-manifolds to solve Calabi's problem in dimension 3.
: 翻译过来就是，我什么都知道，就是没有写下来。
|
l********o
发帖数: 5629 | 10 田刚被抄袭抓了现行。
田刚就是数学界的成昆恶贼！ |
|
|
t**********o
发帖数: 26 | 11 Only in May of 2012, I was told that Donaldson claimed he could do the
case for dimension 3. I was not surprised because I had told quite a few
people,
including X.X. Chen, in many occasions before that if I wanted, I could
prove the
partial C0-estimate for Kahler-Einstein metrics and then use the
classification
of Fano 3-manifolds to solve Calabi's problem in dimension 3.
翻译过来就是，我什么都知道，就是没有写下来。 |
R**********n
发帖数: 523 | 12 This can be verified by asking Chen.
【在 t**********o 的大作中提到】
: Only in May of 2012, I was told that Donaldson claimed he could do the
: case for dimension 3. I was not surprised because I had told quite a few
: people,
: including X.X. Chen, in many occasions before that if I wanted, I could
: prove the
: partial C0-estimate for Kahler-Einstein metrics and then use the
: classification
: of Fano 3-manifolds to solve Calabi's problem in dimension 3.
: 翻译过来就是，我什么都知道，就是没有写下来。
|
w**k
发帖数: 320 | 13 说过也没啥用吧
这种老猜测他们肯定知道关键点在那里
做不做出才是真功夫
【在 R**********n 的大作中提到】
: This can be verified by asking Chen.
|
r******k
发帖数: 97 | 14 关键是田刚的名声不好，偷鸡摸狗的事干得太多了。没人愿意和他share credit
【在 t**********o 的大作中提到】
: Only in May of 2012, I was told that Donaldson claimed he could do the
: case for dimension 3. I was not surprised because I had told quite a few
: people,
: including X.X. Chen, in many occasions before that if I wanted, I could
: prove the
: partial C0-estimate for Kahler-Einstein metrics and then use the
: classification
: of Fano 3-manifolds to solve Calabi's problem in dimension 3.
: 翻译过来就是，我什么都知道，就是没有写下来。
|
Z*********g
发帖数: 68 | 15 这段应该代表了不少专家的意见
http://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=6430
Maybe there is not a single big new idea. The obstacles have been there and
been known to experts for many years. There are many possible ways to solve
the problem, and none of them seems to work at first sight. You have to try
and try, test and test. The new idea is that some guy Jimmy finally find one
of the ways works, and if he told the outline to an expert Tom who had
worked on this problem for many years, Tom could fill in most of the details
, if not all. But you cannnot say that Tom didn’t know this outline. He
just didn’t know that this outline works. |
x******g
发帖数: 289 | 16 只和师傅有过争议而已。有过那一次，田不可能不倍加小心。我不相信这次老田有
guilty。
数学界落井下石的作风可不好
【在 r******k 的大作中提到】
: 关键是田刚的名声不好，偷鸡摸狗的事干得太多了。没人愿意和他share credit
|
f******h
发帖数: 104 | 17 田应该好好反省，而不是做无用的狡辩。就怕他不回应。网友的评论看的偶肚子都笑疼
了。
【在 r******k 的大作中提到】
: 关键是田刚的名声不好，偷鸡摸狗的事干得太多了。没人愿意和他share credit
|
f******h
发帖数: 104 | 18 听过某大牛的报告，田刚上一次对丘猜想有实质贡献是在16年前。近十年来的主要突破
大都是Donaldson的贡献。 |
g****a
发帖数: 1520 | 19 其实大致的证明思路，很多数学家都知道，但是技术的细节非常的formidable，所以20
多年没有什么进展。CDS近些年一直在尝试不同的改进技术的方法。田从各种Donaldson
的公开报告跟踪进展，伺机下手。很快会有第三方的专家出来给个说法。
【在 t**********o 的大作中提到】
: Only in May of 2012, I was told that Donaldson claimed he could do the
: case for dimension 3. I was not surprised because I had told quite a few
: people,
: including X.X. Chen, in many occasions before that if I wanted, I could
: prove the
: partial C0-estimate for Kahler-Einstein metrics and then use the
: classification
: of Fano 3-manifolds to solve Calabi's problem in dimension 3.
: 翻译过来就是，我什么都知道，就是没有写下来。
|
l********o
发帖数: 5629 | 20 田刚被抄袭抓了现行。
田刚就是数学界的成昆恶贼！ |
d******r
发帖数: 16947 | 21 搞笑
【在 t**********o 的大作中提到】
: Only in May of 2012, I was told that Donaldson claimed he could do the
: case for dimension 3. I was not surprised because I had told quite a few
: people,
: including X.X. Chen, in many occasions before that if I wanted, I could
: prove the
: partial C0-estimate for Kahler-Einstein metrics and then use the
: classification
: of Fano 3-manifolds to solve Calabi's problem in dimension 3.
: 翻译过来就是，我什么都知道，就是没有写下来。
|
