V******n
发帖数: 881 | 1 自己到网上嗖嗖，看看一般人都是怎么看的。几个人在那自己吆喝incomplete有意思么
？随便找出来一片看看
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/01/04/sugar-bowl-2012-virgin
It can be hard to blame the referees for a loss when a football team
squanders trips to the red zone, botches a fake punt, fumbles a kick return,
loses a fourth down gamble and also misses a field goal. But good luck
trying to tell that to Virginia Tech fans after the controversial ending to
the 2012 Sugar Bowl. Although Frank Beamer's Hokies were
uncharacteristically mistake prone on special teams, Tech feels incredibly
hard done by a controversial replay review that overturned a touchdown
during the overtime session in the loss to Michigan.
On the first possession of OT, Tech appeared to have scored a crucial
touchdown on an acrobatic, all-out diving catch by wide receiver Danny Coale
. Michigan defenders immediately, speculatively, began signaling that Coale
had not completed the catch. But the official right on top of the play
looked, paused, and then raised his arms to signal for six points. Touchdown!
Not so fast. Before the Hokies' replacement kicker could poke the PAT
through the uprights, play was paused for a review of the play. Watching the
replay, it was clear that there were several things the official would be
looking at on the very close call. Had Coale come down in bounds? Did he
have possession of the ball when he hit the ground? Was that elbow down? Did
the ground help him control the ball?
Given two chances to make the call at the Superdome, the on-site officiating
crew made two calls. On the second, the original call was overturned.
Coale said after the game that he thought he scored and it would have been
hard to reverse, "but they obviously saw something I didn't see."
The ESPN broadcast team and analysts seemed to think the touchdown should
not have been overturned and were not shy about it during the broadcast.
Richard Deitsch of Sports Illustrated felt the same way. Even Michigan coach
Brady Hoke candidly admitted during a postgame interview that he thought
the original touchdown call would be confirmed during the replay review.
What do you think?
Quick Poll
Was This A Touchdown?All The Way! Initial Call Was Right One
37.49%
Nope. Replay Official Got It Right
27.11%
Replay Unclear So It Should Have Stayed With Original On-Field Call
28.31%
Does It Matter? Michigan Would've Won Anyway!
7.1% |
Y******e
发帖数: 20256 | 2 it doesn't matter any more. |
r***l
发帖数: 9084 | 3 vt的粉丝应该mad为什么在regulation没有赢2 TD. |
h**********o
发帖数: 1445 | 4 确实阿，太多的失误和进攻的选择不当
【在 r***l 的大作中提到】
: vt的粉丝应该mad为什么在regulation没有赢2 TD.
|
V******n
发帖数: 881 | 5 Just want to tell you.
Most people think it is a CATCH
别得了便宜在那不停的喊incomplete
【在 Y******e 的大作中提到】
: it doesn't matter any more.
|
b**j
发帖数: 20742 | 6 define "most"? 有数据吗？
【在 V******n 的大作中提到】
: Just want to tell you.
: Most people think it is a CATCH
: 别得了便宜在那不停的喊incomplete
|
p******n
发帖数: 9144 | 7 本来是这样的，耐不住某些人jjww啥incomplete，心虚啥啊
【在 r***l 的大作中提到】
: vt的粉丝应该mad为什么在regulation没有赢2 TD.
|
l*****8
发帖数: 16949 | 8 网上的这种球迷投票没有太多的可信度。球迷里搞不清规则的太多了。 |
t****t
发帖数: 530 | 9 most of people agree = correct? Not to mention it is just 1/3 of the poll.
That is why most people cannot be referees.
【在 V******n 的大作中提到】
: Just want to tell you.
: Most people think it is a CATCH
: 别得了便宜在那不停的喊incomplete
|
t**y
发帖数: 310 | 10 granted, referees make mistakes all the time, you'd be kidding yourself if
you think "most people" know the rules better than the refs.
let's wait until the next wave in revolutionizing football officiating where
controversial rulings are decided by fan votings, american idol style
【在 V******n 的大作中提到】
: Just want to tell you.
: Most people think it is a CATCH
: 别得了便宜在那不停的喊incomplete
|
l********e
发帖数: 2499 | 11 真逗，你们VT自己的fan先挑头，拿了张静态的图片说事儿，还不允许别人不同意了？
动态图我们也上了，那个logic98（非um fan）把规则也讲了，还上了好几个视频解释
，还不行？
first down和总码数少不少我们承认，被outplay了也承认，
你们自己负22yard的跑，自己fumble球，自己胡乱搞trick，自己踢飞fg，输掉比赛能怪谁？还在这里jjww一个complete。 |
Y******e
发帖数: 20256 | 12 those may not even be VT fans. the VT fans water in this forum doesn't seem
that way. |
t****t
发帖数: 530 | 13 There are many VT graduates in Mclean, VA.
seem
【在 Y******e 的大作中提到】
: those may not even be VT fans. the VT fans water in this forum doesn't seem
: that way.
|
