r**********n
发帖数: 5281 | 1 富人income 来源多种多样，穷人没什么income, 一劳本神儿地上班族有稳定的单一的
收入，正是被割韭菜的好材料。我老看到一沓一沓的w-2就想笑。拿w-2的都属于被剥削
阶级。
共和党那个竞选人说要改成在消费环节收税维持财政，我老同样不看好。虽然说drug
dealers rapists 和有很低cash income可以偷税漏税的穷人以及小承包商们也需要消
费，如果取消income tax 改为sales tax模式，sales tax 税率一定会大涨，进而抑制
消费。对美国这种消费型经济来说，没了消费就彻底不用再玩儿了。
我觉得问题的关键是要鼓励富人多投资，多消费。让囤积起来的钱都进入流通环节，这
样钱才不会成为一串无意义的数字。 |
k***n
发帖数: 3158 | 2 TX does not have income tax and they get the tax revenue from sales and
property.
it works just fine, although I don't agree with everything they do there
I don't see why we can't do the same in the federal level
【在 r**********n 的大作中提到】
: 富人income 来源多种多样，穷人没什么income, 一劳本神儿地上班族有稳定的单一的
: 收入，正是被割韭菜的好材料。我老看到一沓一沓的w-2就想笑。拿w-2的都属于被剥削
: 阶级。
: 共和党那个竞选人说要改成在消费环节收税维持财政，我老同样不看好。虽然说drug
: dealers rapists 和有很低cash income可以偷税漏税的穷人以及小承包商们也需要消
: 费，如果取消income tax 改为sales tax模式，sales tax 税率一定会大涨，进而抑制
: 消费。对美国这种消费型经济来说，没了消费就彻底不用再玩儿了。
: 我觉得问题的关键是要鼓励富人多投资，多消费。让囤积起来的钱都进入流通环节，这
: 样钱才不会成为一串无意义的数字。
|
a*********a
发帖数: 3656 | 3 sales tax is defeated by all cash transactions. income tax is defeated by
income recharacter schemes. tax either alone leaves some holes that are
exploit more by some population.
I think it needs to be a combination of flat rate income and sales tax. And
each year, every one paid tax should receive a check in the amount of "
lesser of actual tax paid and poverty line times combined tax rate", so
effectively real poors do not pay tax but each dollar earned or spend above
poverty line is taxed. I feel a 10% income tax + 10% sales tax could work.
【在 k***n 的大作中提到】
: TX does not have income tax and they get the tax revenue from sales and
: property.
: it works just fine, although I don't agree with everything they do there
: I don't see why we can't do the same in the federal level
|
V**3
发帖数: 12756 | 4 你的这个主意的原意是好的，但是在美国这种虚拟经济主导的情况下无法实现
你以为现在富人们没有“多投资” 么？ 他么投资很多，都投资到金融产品上了，这种
投资基本上对社会不产生正面推动效应。 只产生财富，而不推动就业
这是美国经济结构的癌症。 投资不进入实业领域，而在虚拟经济领域，就不能产生就
业以及相关的一切。 于是超富越来越富，然后政客却以此为借口杀中产
【在 r**********n 的大作中提到】
: 富人income 来源多种多样，穷人没什么income, 一劳本神儿地上班族有稳定的单一的
: 收入，正是被割韭菜的好材料。我老看到一沓一沓的w-2就想笑。拿w-2的都属于被剥削
: 阶级。
: 共和党那个竞选人说要改成在消费环节收税维持财政，我老同样不看好。虽然说drug
: dealers rapists 和有很低cash income可以偷税漏税的穷人以及小承包商们也需要消
: 费，如果取消income tax 改为sales tax模式，sales tax 税率一定会大涨，进而抑制
: 消费。对美国这种消费型经济来说，没了消费就彻底不用再玩儿了。
: 我觉得问题的关键是要鼓励富人多投资，多消费。让囤积起来的钱都进入流通环节，这
: 样钱才不会成为一串无意义的数字。
|
x*********3
发帖数: 1438 | 5 一直都是这样了，共和党还稍微好点。民主党就是赤裸裸的，宰的就是中产。不管那帮
人怎么说加富人的税，最后所有加的税最后全到中产了。 |
t***n
发帖数: 546 | 6 只收地产税就好了，反正房子跑不了
要是富人愿意挤地下室少交税就由他去吧
And
above
【在 a*********a 的大作中提到】
: sales tax is defeated by all cash transactions. income tax is defeated by
: income recharacter schemes. tax either alone leaves some holes that are
: exploit more by some population.
: I think it needs to be a combination of flat rate income and sales tax. And
: each year, every one paid tax should receive a check in the amount of "
: lesser of actual tax paid and poverty line times combined tax rate", so
: effectively real poors do not pay tax but each dollar earned or spend above
: poverty line is taxed. I feel a 10% income tax + 10% sales tax could work.
|
