s***e
发帖数: 830 | 1 Although, one of the reviewers favors the paper and has recommended various
revisions, we are sorry to inform you that we cannot publish your paper in
ET. Currently, we are experiencing a publication backlog of more than 15
months and are accepting only 3% of the papers we receive. Thus, we have to
select the very best papers and turn down some good and very good papers.
We wish you the best in pursing publication elsewhere.
Reviewer #1: See attachment.
Reviewer # 2: This is a good paper but n |
c**b
发帖数: 474 | 2 尽快投向下一家journal。学会被拒绝。
不过3%的接受率说明journal管理有问题，在这种情况下journal应该扩容，每年增加几
期。
various
to
be
【在 s***e 的大作中提到】
: Although, one of the reviewers favors the paper and has recommended various
: revisions, we are sorry to inform you that we cannot publish your paper in
: ET. Currently, we are experiencing a publication backlog of more than 15
: months and are accepting only 3% of the papers we receive. Thus, we have to
: select the very best papers and turn down some good and very good papers.
: We wish you the best in pursing publication elsewhere.
: Reviewer #1: See attachment.
: Reviewer # 2: This is a good paper but n
|
z***n
发帖数: 30 | |
z****e
发帖数: 438 | 4 which ET, Economic Theory or Econometric Theory? If the referees are asking
something reasonable and can be done within a couple of days, do it before
submitting the paper to another journal. Otherwise, just submit the paper to
another journal as soon as possible. |
s***e
发帖数: 830 | |
f**********g
发帖数: 107 | 6 I think by ET he/she refers to Economic Theory, since one referee mentioned
some proof. |
e*******a
发帖数: 514 | 7 An Econometric Theory paper does not have proof in it?
mentioned
【在 f**********g 的大作中提到】
: I think by ET he/she refers to Economic Theory, since one referee mentioned
: some proof.
|
z****f
发帖数: 484 | 8 we should infer the journal's name from lz's nick...Milgrom...
mentioned
【在 f**********g 的大作中提到】
: I think by ET he/she refers to Economic Theory, since one referee mentioned
: some proof.
|
s***e
发帖数: 830 | 9 It hurts me even more than the rejection that the second reviewer just gave
me one paragraph of words with no details... And the editor took his opinion.
I read the report from the first guy, it is actually positive.
various
to
be
【在 s***e 的大作中提到】
: Although, one of the reviewers favors the paper and has recommended various
: revisions, we are sorry to inform you that we cannot publish your paper in
: ET. Currently, we are experiencing a publication backlog of more than 15
: months and are accepting only 3% of the papers we receive. Thus, we have to
: select the very best papers and turn down some good and very good papers.
: We wish you the best in pursing publication elsewhere.
: Reviewer #1: See attachment.
: Reviewer # 2: This is a good paper but n
|
z****f
发帖数: 484 | 10 shit happens...
gave
opinion.
【在 s***e 的大作中提到】
: It hurts me even more than the rejection that the second reviewer just gave
: me one paragraph of words with no details... And the editor took his opinion.
: I read the report from the first guy, it is actually positive.
:
: various
: to
: be
|
|
|
U*****e
发帖数: 2882 | 11 pat pat.
You know similar things happened to me too. 就当挫折教育吧。
Is the first report helpful?
gave
opinion.
【在 s***e 的大作中提到】
: It hurts me even more than the rejection that the second reviewer just gave
: me one paragraph of words with no details... And the editor took his opinion.
: I read the report from the first guy, it is actually positive.
:
: various
: to
: be
|
c**b
发帖数: 474 | 12 这个正常吧。通常据信都很短。而且我觉得收到两个都negative的report的机率和收到
两个都positive的report的机率差不多。绝大多数被拒的情况都是一正一负的report。
慢慢习惯就好了。总之journal多的是。慢慢投呗。
gave
opinion.
【在 s***e 的大作中提到】
: It hurts me even more than the rejection that the second reviewer just gave
: me one paragraph of words with no details... And the editor took his opinion.
: I read the report from the first guy, it is actually positive.
:
: various
: to
: be
|
c**b
发帖数: 474 | 13 每期可以从10篇加到20篇啊。3%的接受率在这种level的journal我还第一回听说。如果
这样，那jet的接受率该是多少？连JPE，AER听说都有6%啊。
【在 z***n 的大作中提到】
: ET好像已经是一年12期了，难道要办成半月刊？
|
s***e
发帖数: 830 | 14 It is very helpful. the reviewer must have read my paper seriously, so he
gave a lot of detailed suggestions on the organization of the proofs, and
intuitions behind the proofs. he also gave some further extensions. His
report gives me more help than my own adviser. I really would like to know
who this guy is... Do you guys think this is possible?
【在 U*****e 的大作中提到】
: pat pat.
: You know similar things happened to me too. 就当挫折教育吧。
: Is the first report helpful?
:
: gave
: opinion.
|
s***e
发帖数: 830 | 15 3x, dude
【在 z****f 的大作中提到】
: shit happens...
:
: gave
: opinion.
|
s***e
发帖数: 830 | 16 Maybe we shall not take that "3%" seriously? who knows.
【在 c**b 的大作中提到】
: 每期可以从10篇加到20篇啊。3%的接受率在这种level的journal我还第一回听说。如果
: 这样，那jet的接受率该是多少？连JPE，AER听说都有6%啊。
|
s****t
发帖数: 21 | 17 ET是不好发的，尤其是phd学生作为独立作者投稿，没必要太沮丧。建议投EL的说法明
显有点mean。如果是我的话，会找该领域比较牛且nice的人请教些建议，然后作一点比
较大的修改后再试试差不多档次的杂志。
various
to
be
【在 s***e 的大作中提到】
: Although, one of the reviewers favors the paper and has recommended various
: revisions, we are sorry to inform you that we cannot publish your paper in
: ET. Currently, we are experiencing a publication backlog of more than 15
: months and are accepting only 3% of the papers we receive. Thus, we have to
: select the very best papers and turn down some good and very good papers.
: We wish you the best in pursing publication elsewhere.
: Reviewer #1: See attachment.
: Reviewer # 2: This is a good paper but n
|
l****o
发帖数: 2909 | 18 那就投 journal of economic theory. |
z****e
发帖数: 438 | 19 kidding? JET is easier than ET? |
