v***l
发帖数: 2623 | 1 朋友的proposal今天得到了review 结果。他告诉我说cover letter上说“unable to
fund"，但是review结果是3个excellent和1个very good，panel recommendation是"
highly recommend".
有经验的能讲讲怎么回事吗?如果这样都不能被fund,还有必要resubmit吗?
谢谢! |
l*******s
发帖数: 3562 | 2 Comfort.
【在 v***l 的大作中提到】
: 朋友的proposal今天得到了review 结果。他告诉我说cover letter上说“unable to
: fund"，但是review结果是3个excellent和1个very good，panel recommendation是"
: highly recommend".
: 有经验的能讲讲怎么回事吗?如果这样都不能被fund,还有必要resubmit吗?
: 谢谢!
|
v***l
发帖数: 2623 | 3 唉,看来就是说这种情况很常见了.....
【在 l*******s 的大作中提到】
: Comfort.
|
x5
发帖数: 27871 | 4 为哈不去问PM?
【在 v***l 的大作中提到】
: 朋友的proposal今天得到了review 结果。他告诉我说cover letter上说“unable to
: fund"，但是review结果是3个excellent和1个very good，panel recommendation是"
: highly recommend".
: 有经验的能讲讲怎么回事吗?如果这样都不能被fund,还有必要resubmit吗?
: 谢谢!
|
s***e
发帖数: 1490 | 5 建议联系一下PM，问问原因。
Resubmit肯定要Resubmit的，不然不是浪费了。
【在 v***l 的大作中提到】
: 朋友的proposal今天得到了review 结果。他告诉我说cover letter上说“unable to
: fund"，但是review结果是3个excellent和1个very good，panel recommendation是"
: highly recommend".
: 有经验的能讲讲怎么回事吗?如果这样都不能被fund,还有必要resubmit吗?
: 谢谢!
|
l*******s
发帖数: 3562 | 6 肯定不能说常见，但是也不是非常罕见，我有个同事的Proposal两次被Panel highly r
ecommended还是没拿到钱。
【在 v***l 的大作中提到】
: 唉,看来就是说这种情况很常见了.....
|
c**********0
发帖数: 836 | 7 不常见，也不罕见。我也遇到这种情况，只有resubmit了，没法和PM argue的。
【在 v***l 的大作中提到】
: 朋友的proposal今天得到了review 结果。他告诉我说cover letter上说“unable to
: fund"，但是review结果是3个excellent和1个very good，panel recommendation是"
: highly recommend".
: 有经验的能讲讲怎么回事吗?如果这样都不能被fund,还有必要resubmit吗?
: 谢谢!
|
V****n
发帖数: 651 | 8 Unfortunately, "highly recommend" is not a guarantee for funding. I served
as NSF proposal reviewer a few years ago. The program manager asked us to
select a few "highly recommend" proposals out of a total of 22 or so
proposals, but said the program can only support 2-3 proposals. We ended up
giving her five "highly recommend" proposals and spent about an hour
debating which ones should be downgraded. Eventually we kept three or maybe
four (can't remember exactly) proposals each having a specifi
【在 v***l 的大作中提到】
: 朋友的proposal今天得到了review 结果。他告诉我说cover letter上说“unable to
: fund"，但是review结果是3个excellent和1个very good，panel recommendation是"
: highly recommend".
: 有经验的能讲讲怎么回事吗?如果这样都不能被fund,还有必要resubmit吗?
: 谢谢!
|
v***l
发帖数: 2623 | 9 非常感谢你这么详细的回答！
up
maybe
say
【在 V****n 的大作中提到】
: Unfortunately, "highly recommend" is not a guarantee for funding. I served
: as NSF proposal reviewer a few years ago. The program manager asked us to
: select a few "highly recommend" proposals out of a total of 22 or so
: proposals, but said the program can only support 2-3 proposals. We ended up
: giving her five "highly recommend" proposals and spent about an hour
: debating which ones should be downgraded. Eventually we kept three or maybe
: four (can't remember exactly) proposals each having a specifi
|
