g*******s
发帖数: 2828 | 1 这个应该是最objective的analysis了。
nalysis: Sanders had broken free down the right sideline and was looking
back over his left shoulder for Peyton Manning's pass in the third quarter
at the Edward Jones Dome. McLeod approached as the ball arrived, resulting
in a violent collision that flipped Sanders and left him with a concussion.
As a receiver attempting to catch a pass, Sanders qualified for defenseless
player protection. That meant McLeod couldn't "forcibly" hit Sanders' head
or neck area with his own helmet or shoulder, according to Rule 12, Section
2, Article 7(b)-1. Corrente's crew penalized him for doing just that, an
understandable reaction after seeing the play full speed that becomes far
less certain when watching in slow motion.
As the play ticks by frame-by-frame, you can see McLeod lower his right
shoulder and turn his head away from Sanders at the point of contact. Much
of the force came from McLeod's shoulder, but the right side of his helmet
did hit the top Sanders' helmet. Was it intentional? McLeod's pre-contact
movement suggested he was trying to hit with his shoulder and remove his
helmet from contact. Was it forcible? We'll never know if it caused Sanders'
concussion, whether it resulted from overall violence of the hit or contact
with the ground.
As usual, subjective judgment is involved here. If McLeod led with his
shoulder, and in the subsequent motion his helmet touched Sanders', it seems
reasonable to consider this a legal hit. But remember, Corrente didn't have
the benefit of slow motion. All his crew saw was a defenseless player
knocked on his back and clearly concussed. Corrente's call appears wrong in
retrospect, but it's understandable why he made it based only on a live look
. | b**l
发帖数: 33123 | 2 你们在论证什么？15码，我看挺好。
.
defenseless
Section
Sanders'
contact
seems
have
in
look
【在 g*******s 的大作中提到】
: 这个应该是最objective的analysis了。
: nalysis: Sanders had broken free down the right sideline and was looking
: back over his left shoulder for Peyton Manning's pass in the third quarter
: at the Edward Jones Dome. McLeod approached as the ball arrived, resulting
: in a violent collision that flipped Sanders and left him with a concussion.
: As a receiver attempting to catch a pass, Sanders qualified for defenseless
: player protection. That meant McLeod couldn't "forcibly" hit Sanders' head
: or neck area with his own helmet or shoulder, according to Rule 12, Section
: 2, Article 7(b)-1. Corrente's crew penalized him for doing just that, an
: understandable reaction after seeing the play full speed that becomes far
|
|
