由买买提看人间百态

boards

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档,一周内的贴子最多显示50字,超过一周显示500字 访问原贴
Immigration版 - EB1-b REF 求助
相关主题
NSC EB1A RFE, 求助!急!(通过后包子重谢!)EB1a PP RFE后悲剧:'(,写详细情况恳求建议! (长)
EB1B REF help! Thanks!这是我收到的EB1a的结果,还有希望吗?谢谢
Eb1B pp 求祝福我收到的EB1a的结果,还有希望吗?
EB1B RFE, 附背景RFE Letter 来了, 请指教.
关于IO两步法审核的疑问???DIY EB1a PP NSC Request for Evidence, Help!
eb1a 140 pp noid asking for helpEB1B 申请详解2 —— EB1B AAO 判例关键点
RFE 求帮助Eb1b 推荐信都是美国的会有问题么
judge of other's work: internationally recognized?DIY Eb-1a 一个RFE 求助 106号,怎么证明contribution?
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: ref话题: evidence话题: citation话题: 律师话题: 10
进入Immigration版参与讨论
1 (共1页)
r******r
发帖数: 19
1
今天刚刚收到律师转发的REF notice from NSC, 向大家请教应该如何应对.
在REF信中说" The beneficiary has met at least three criteria. However, the
totality of the evidence must establish that the beneficiary is recognized
internationally as outstanding in the academic field specified in the
petition. Please provide further evidence that the beneficiary's articles
have been widely cited providing evidence that he is recognized
internationally as outstanding in the academic field".
是不是说USCIS 认为我文章被引用的证据不足呢?
我的背景:
08 US PhD (学校较烂), EECS 专业. 现在一个大公司的R&D
5 journal, ~20 conference. Citation: ~50 (独立引用)
8 recommendation letter (7 independent), 1 swiss, 1 France, 6 US, 基本是IEEE
Fellow 和 相似level的. 没有major award 和 membership
我申请的过程比较曲折. 我09年11月就把材料给律师了,结果律师拖到10年5月份才
submit.结果等到10年9月份,发现USCIS根本没受到材料(没有receipt, 我当时傻傻的以
为等着就可以了). 所以10年10月份又重新提交了一次. 因为我一直没看到PL,所以也不
知道律师究竟claim了哪几点.
根据REF, "Review", "contribution" 和 "authorship" 显示"this criterion has
been met". "Award" 显示"this award is not considered as major". "membership"
和 "Published material written by others" 显示 "no evidence has been
provided for this criterion".
从REF来看, 如果显示 "no evidence has been provided",是不是意味着律师根本没把
我的citation的材料提交呢? (这个可能性不是没有, 公司的律师没办法)
在10年10月第二次提交时, 我的citation还是09年11月时的状态, 只有10次左右. 现在
50次 的引用中, 除美国外, 还包括欧洲一些国家, 加拿大, 澳大利亚,中国等地作者地
引用, 能否凭借这一点来establish evidence for "international recognized"?
另外, 更多的recommendation letter 还会有用吗? 主要是我们这个领域的大牛已经基
本上都给写过了.
感谢大家看完. 请大家不吝赐教.十分感谢!
w*********m
发帖数: 4740
2
1. 50 indep citation is many: similar to Molecular biology's 300+ indep
citations
http://www.timeshighereducation.co.uk/story.asp?storyCode=40578
2. show those citations are from worldwide

【在 r******r 的大作中提到】
: 今天刚刚收到律师转发的REF notice from NSC, 向大家请教应该如何应对.
: 在REF信中说" The beneficiary has met at least three criteria. However, the
: totality of the evidence must establish that the beneficiary is recognized
: internationally as outstanding in the academic field specified in the
: petition. Please provide further evidence that the beneficiary's articles
: have been widely cited providing evidence that he is recognized
: internationally as outstanding in the academic field".
: 是不是说USCIS 认为我文章被引用的证据不足呢?
: 我的背景:
: 08 US PhD (学校较烂), EECS 专业. 现在一个大公司的R&D

h*w
发帖数: 134
3
who is your officer
l******t
发帖数: 2243
4
seems like you have to provide more information about your citations such as
cited by ppl around the world etc.
bless!

发信人: realizer (再来一次), 信区: Immigration
标 题: EB1-b REF 求助
发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Tue Mar 22 00:18:53 2011, 美东)
今天刚刚收到律师转发的REF notice from NSC, 向大家请教应该如何应对.
在REF信中说" The beneficiary has met at least three criteria. However, the
totality of the evidence must establish that the beneficiary is recognized
internationally as outstanding in the academic field specified in the
petition. Please provide further evidence that the beneficiary's articles
have been widely cited providing evidence that he is recognized
internationally as outstanding in the academic field".
是不是说USCIS 认为我文章被引用的证据不足呢?
我的背景:
08 US PhD (学校较烂), EECS 专业. 现在一个大公司的R&D
5 journal, ~20 conference. Citation: ~50 (独立引用)
8 recommendation letter (7 independent), 1 swiss, 1 France, 6 US, 基本是IEEE
Fellow 和 相似level的. 没有major award 和 membership
我申请的过程比较曲折. 我09年11月就把材料给律师了,结果律师拖到10年5月份才
submit.结果等到10年9月份,发现USCIS根本没受到材料(没有receipt, 我当时傻傻的以
为等着就可以了). 所以10年10月份又重新提交了一次. 因为我一直没看到PL,所以也不
知道律师究竟claim了哪几点.
根据REF, "Review", "contribution" 和 "authorship" 显示"this criterion has
been met". "Award" 显示"this award is not considered as major". "membership"
和 "Published material written by others" 显示 "no evidence has been
provided for this criterion".
从REF来看, 如果显示 "no evidence has been provided",是不是意味着律师根本没把
我的citation的材料提交呢? (这个可能性不是没有, 公司的律师没办法)
在10年10月第二次提交时, 我的citation还是09年11月时的状态, 只有10次左右. 现在
50次 的引用中, 除美国外, 还包括欧洲一些国家, 加拿大, 澳大利亚,中国等地作者地
引用, 能否凭借这一点来establish evidence for "international recognized"?
另外, 更多的recommendation letter 还会有用吗? 主要是我们这个领域的大牛已经基
本上都给写过了.
感谢大家看完. 请大家不吝赐教.十分感谢!

【在 r******r 的大作中提到】
: 今天刚刚收到律师转发的REF notice from NSC, 向大家请教应该如何应对.
: 在REF信中说" The beneficiary has met at least three criteria. However, the
: totality of the evidence must establish that the beneficiary is recognized
: internationally as outstanding in the academic field specified in the
: petition. Please provide further evidence that the beneficiary's articles
: have been widely cited providing evidence that he is recognized
: internationally as outstanding in the academic field".
: 是不是说USCIS 认为我文章被引用的证据不足呢?
: 我的背景:
: 08 US PhD (学校较烂), EECS 专业. 现在一个大公司的R&D

b****M
发帖数: 1390
5
1。 your citation world wide, list countries.
2. famous scientist cited your paper.
3. try to find our the quality of your citation.我的发现引发大牛产生newidea
,导致大牛这篇高质量的文章发表在业内高杂志上。
r******r
发帖数: 19
6
这个怎么看?

【在 h*w 的大作中提到】
: who is your officer
r******r
发帖数: 19
7
多谢!

newidea

【在 b****M 的大作中提到】
: 1。 your citation world wide, list countries.
: 2. famous scientist cited your paper.
: 3. try to find our the quality of your citation.我的发现引发大牛产生newidea
: ,导致大牛这篇高质量的文章发表在业内高杂志上。

s********l
发帖数: 213
8
ask more reference letters from guys cited your paper around the world.
p*******h
发帖数: 1542
9
Bless!!

【在 s********l 的大作中提到】
: ask more reference letters from guys cited your paper around the world.
1 (共1页)
进入Immigration版参与讨论
相关主题
DIY Eb-1a 一个RFE 求助 106号,怎么证明contribution?关于IO两步法审核的疑问???
NSC EB1b PP RFE 0002 求助eb1a 140 pp noid asking for help
eb1a 140 RFE 求助RFE 求帮助
EB1-A RFE (NSC)求帮助!judge of other's work: internationally recognized?
NSC EB1A RFE, 求助!急!(通过后包子重谢!)EB1a PP RFE后悲剧:'(,写详细情况恳求建议! (长)
EB1B REF help! Thanks!这是我收到的EB1a的结果,还有希望吗?谢谢
Eb1B pp 求祝福我收到的EB1a的结果,还有希望吗?
EB1B RFE, 附背景RFE Letter 来了, 请指教.
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: ref话题: evidence话题: citation话题: 律师话题: 10