由买买提看人间百态

boards

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档,一周内的贴子最多显示50字,超过一周显示500字 访问原贴
MedicalCareer版 - to make an educated judgement--let discuss why residency match is difficult this year
相关主题
a JAMA article: 对 IMG 前景的预测Be attention for this news, please
和FM的PD谈话有感为什么general surgery的filled spots 百分比最少?
2013 match 比 2012 match 少了多少pre-match 位置?transfer 一问
2009 Match result的粗浅分析有关2015年,我的理解。
2015不是末日,是悬在头上的剑IMG(CMG):这扇大门开使关闭...
谈谈今年我们program (IM) 的MATCH情况看着印度人很多都有消息了,不管是iv还是rej
见PD的失败经历除了鼓励,说几句实用的给lovelypony--还有其他准备考试的人
说几句不招人爱听的话IM-Match-基本没有动静?
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: year话题: amgs话题: match话题: ivs话题: cmgs
进入MedicalCareer版参与讨论
1 (共1页)
x***y
发帖数: 45
1
Many CMGs are suffering with few interviews. It would be helpful if we can
clarify where we stand now. Let's discuss the possible reasons that can
reduce FMGs probability of getting matched in general particularly for this
year.
more applicants---- not really if counting less European doctors this year
less spots ---- not significant
favor young applicant ---- how many IVs young applicant got so far?
favor high scores --- how many IVs 99ers got so far?
favor GC?--- how many IVs GC got so far
e*****a
发帖数: 1334
2
Little increase in number of residency spots but more AMGs (MD and DO) come
out from schools. Last year some AMGs failed to match and it becomes even
more difficult for them to scramble now. This year more programs give AMGs
invites first, even in categorical IM and preliminary medicine.
x***m
发帖数: 140
3
This is a good post. Good list of Qs.
I agree more AMGs could be one explanation. Do they also apply to more
programs than before? How many do they apply on average this year and last
year?
I bet IMGs are also applying more programs than before, even some people
with very good credential, and they took a lot of IV spots. do you guys
agree?
x***y
发帖数: 45
4
Hi Eric, thanks for the input. Could you give a rough number of the
increase AMGs this year and AMGs failed to match last year? It will help
most of us estimate our starting point in this race.

come

【在 e*****a 的大作中提到】
: Little increase in number of residency spots but more AMGs (MD and DO) come
: out from schools. Last year some AMGs failed to match and it becomes even
: more difficult for them to scramble now. This year more programs give AMGs
: invites first, even in categorical IM and preliminary medicine.

h**i
发帖数: 148
5
from info on studentdoctor, AMGs apply around 20 programs.

【在 x***m 的大作中提到】
: This is a good post. Good list of Qs.
: I agree more AMGs could be one explanation. Do they also apply to more
: programs than before? How many do they apply on average this year and last
: year?
: I bet IMGs are also applying more programs than before, even some people
: with very good credential, and they took a lot of IV spots. do you guys
: agree?

b*********n
发帖数: 162
6
I heard that more and more FMGs from India, Parkistan and Arabic countires
are applying this year since they can not apply in England and the
environment is not friendly to them in Europe. They took a lot of IVs out of
all IMGs especially in IM and FM. That is why IM and FM are the big hurts
among CMGs this year but not Pathology. Just my 2 cents
e*****a
发帖数: 1334
7
There were 522 more students enrolled in MD and DO schools in 2006. Those
are the people for this year's match.
In 2009, more than 13,000 people competed for the 1087 unfilled spots, about
half of these were PGY-1 only positions in preliminary surgery and
preliminary medicine. There were 1072 unmatched AMGs (MD). Even if every AMG
would get these spots, half of them could end up in a one-year only
position.

【在 x***y 的大作中提到】
: Hi Eric, thanks for the input. Could you give a rough number of the
: increase AMGs this year and AMGs failed to match last year? It will help
: most of us estimate our starting point in this race.
:
: come

x***y
发帖数: 45
8
I see. So increased AMGs alone will use up more than 25% of FMGs slot. I
know there is some increase in carribean medical grads as well. I think
last year, people got about 6/80 interviews on average. This year we should
get about 3-4/80. In general, 3-4 interviews is not a safe number to go
for match, right?

about
AMG

【在 e*****a 的大作中提到】
: There were 522 more students enrolled in MD and DO schools in 2006. Those
: are the people for this year's match.
: In 2009, more than 13,000 people competed for the 1087 unfilled spots, about
: half of these were PGY-1 only positions in preliminary surgery and
: preliminary medicine. There were 1072 unmatched AMGs (MD). Even if every AMG
: would get these spots, half of them could end up in a one-year only
: position.

e*****a
发帖数: 1334
9
Depending on specialty. For internal medicine match, the mean number of
ranks in 2009 was 8.7 for AMGs and 6.2 for independent applicants. However,
if you shine in one interview you're set. CMGs with strong research
background or extensive clinical experience have some advantages for the
match. The main concerns from programs are English, communication skill and
personality. So do an intensive interview preparation and go out to fight
for your chance.
BTW, this week has been a busy week for us.

【在 x***y 的大作中提到】
: I see. So increased AMGs alone will use up more than 25% of FMGs slot. I
: know there is some increase in carribean medical grads as well. I think
: last year, people got about 6/80 interviews on average. This year we should
: get about 3-4/80. In general, 3-4 interviews is not a safe number to go
: for match, right?
:
: about
: AMG

u********8
发帖数: 120
10
congratulation, eric, you are superb! Your character to help people and
your maturity will be appreciated by every PD and you will certainly get a
dream place.

,
and

【在 e*****a 的大作中提到】
: Depending on specialty. For internal medicine match, the mean number of
: ranks in 2009 was 8.7 for AMGs and 6.2 for independent applicants. However,
: if you shine in one interview you're set. CMGs with strong research
: background or extensive clinical experience have some advantages for the
: match. The main concerns from programs are English, communication skill and
: personality. So do an intensive interview preparation and go out to fight
: for your chance.
: BTW, this week has been a busy week for us.

e*****a
发帖数: 1334
11
Thanks. The "dream place" is the one I can "fit in" comfortably and can get
a good training. :)
Internal medicine is easy to match for AMGs. Some of my classmates applied
for 10 programs and already got a good number of invites.

your maturity will be appreciated by every PD and you will certainly get a
dream place.

【在 u********8 的大作中提到】
: congratulation, eric, you are superb! Your character to help people and
: your maturity will be appreciated by every PD and you will certainly get a
: dream place.
:
: ,
: and

x***y
发帖数: 45
12
I totally agree. I want to add one more thing. For CMGs applying internal
medicine. I would suggest accepting prematch offer instead of going for
match regardless of English, communication, personality, scores.

,
and

【在 e*****a 的大作中提到】
: Depending on specialty. For internal medicine match, the mean number of
: ranks in 2009 was 8.7 for AMGs and 6.2 for independent applicants. However,
: if you shine in one interview you're set. CMGs with strong research
: background or extensive clinical experience have some advantages for the
: match. The main concerns from programs are English, communication skill and
: personality. So do an intensive interview preparation and go out to fight
: for your chance.
: BTW, this week has been a busy week for us.

f*****y
发帖数: 53
13
Every year, ppl say it is the most difficult year. It is NOT AT ALL
different this year. I happen to know several CMG friends who got quite some
internal medicine interviews/pathology interviews this year. I kind of feel
that jimmyzhang's old post "you are beautiful" is the most important
guideline for CMGs going to match (Don't tell me that you had not read that
old post before you even started STEP1). He almost mentioned every important
factor; and people got most interviews are almost always
1 (共1页)
进入MedicalCareer版参与讨论
相关主题
IM-Match-基本没有动静?2015不是末日,是悬在头上的剑
More interview tips谈谈今年我们program (IM) 的MATCH情况
各位大虾, Paper对以后的Match等重要吗?见PD的失败经历
Why be scared?说几句不招人爱听的话
a JAMA article: 对 IMG 前景的预测Be attention for this news, please
和FM的PD谈话有感为什么general surgery的filled spots 百分比最少?
2013 match 比 2012 match 少了多少pre-match 位置?transfer 一问
2009 Match result的粗浅分析有关2015年,我的理解。
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: year话题: amgs话题: match话题: ivs话题: cmgs