由买买提看人间百态

boards

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档,一周内的贴子最多显示50字,超过一周显示500字 访问原贴
Medicalpractice版 - Botox injection: Evidence based medicine or money based
相关主题
EPIC门诊大家用EMR有什么感受?
AirplaneVA 系统的优缺点
你们别整天钱不钱的,让我来点高尚的如何治疗TMJ
美国医生生活的无聊偏头痛吗?我是不是有焦虑症
【活动通知】Medicalpractice Bowldiplopia
临床常用的 website or software?嘴巴张不开,小脑好像很沉,找什么医生看?
Jaw pain 请教问医求助脑瘫儿
Funny story about OSH梅氏综合症(Meige's syndrome)
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: botox话题: evidence话题: based话题: injection话题: migraine
进入Medicalpractice版参与讨论
1 (共1页)
k********n
发帖数: 756
1
今天和一个ATTENDING谈论起BOTOX injection for migraine, 说到简直不敢相信FDA竟
然APPROVE了这个治疗, ATTENDING说还是有些EVIDENCE的, 我说EVIDENCE是EVIDENCE,
但是是MONEY-BASED EVIDENCE。ATTENDING听了说,若干年前当他听说 17 个PHASE II
的临床试验证明BOTOX无效,没有MEET primary end point, 但某公司仍然要进行
PHASE III的临床试验的时候,他的反应就是“见证奇迹的时刻就要到了”。 然后讲了
一通故事,听得心里一颤一颤,医药这个水真是太深了...
A*******s
发帖数: 9638
2
From mechanism, Botox helps dystonia and muscle spasm. It makes sense to
treat chronic daily headche or transformed migraine. But how to promote the
use of botox is another story.
Off-label use of Botox for migraine is difficult due to the price. FDA
approval makes it affordable to those ordinary patients.
k********n
发帖数: 756
3
1. Somebody (taxpayer) other than the patient still needs to pay 1200 per
visit. It is lucrative for physicians and the company but the price is not
decreased.
2. There is no scientific evidences and logic supporting its actions on
nociceptor and cortical spreading depression.
3. Why a company wanted to conduct the most risky and expensive phase III
trial after seeing 17 trial failed?
4. Why other countries rejected it based on the same data?

the

【在 A*******s 的大作中提到】
: From mechanism, Botox helps dystonia and muscle spasm. It makes sense to
: treat chronic daily headche or transformed migraine. But how to promote the
: use of botox is another story.
: Off-label use of Botox for migraine is difficult due to the price. FDA
: approval makes it affordable to those ordinary patients.

A*******s
发帖数: 9638
4
Man, the word lucrative is really abused here.
Why 17 trials? Does it only mean all those trials are not reliable?

【在 k********n 的大作中提到】
: 1. Somebody (taxpayer) other than the patient still needs to pay 1200 per
: visit. It is lucrative for physicians and the company but the price is not
: decreased.
: 2. There is no scientific evidences and logic supporting its actions on
: nociceptor and cortical spreading depression.
: 3. Why a company wanted to conduct the most risky and expensive phase III
: trial after seeing 17 trial failed?
: 4. Why other countries rejected it based on the same data?
:
: the

d**o
发帖数: 618
5
Just a technical question - do you really believe CSD is the sole mechanism
of migraine? What do you think about the possibility of arising from TMJ?
s********e
发帖数: 1596
6
I have seen patients who benefit from Botox injections, and of course, also
some who don't. The latter group wouldn't continue Botox injections anyway.
Really not much harm there:)

EVIDENCE,
II

【在 k********n 的大作中提到】
: 今天和一个ATTENDING谈论起BOTOX injection for migraine, 说到简直不敢相信FDA竟
: 然APPROVE了这个治疗, ATTENDING说还是有些EVIDENCE的, 我说EVIDENCE是EVIDENCE,
: 但是是MONEY-BASED EVIDENCE。ATTENDING听了说,若干年前当他听说 17 个PHASE II
: 的临床试验证明BOTOX无效,没有MEET primary end point, 但某公司仍然要进行
: PHASE III的临床试验的时候,他的反应就是“见证奇迹的时刻就要到了”。 然后讲了
: 一通故事,听得心里一颤一颤,医药这个水真是太深了...

k********n
发帖数: 756
7
TMJ can be a trigger but not the primary cause. Correct me if I am wrong

mechanism

【在 d**o 的大作中提到】
: Just a technical question - do you really believe CSD is the sole mechanism
: of migraine? What do you think about the possibility of arising from TMJ?

k********n
发帖数: 756
8
I agree but sometime doing good things does not mean doing the right thing.

also
.

【在 s********e 的大作中提到】
: I have seen patients who benefit from Botox injections, and of course, also
: some who don't. The latter group wouldn't continue Botox injections anyway.
: Really not much harm there:)
:
: EVIDENCE,
: II

1 (共1页)
进入Medicalpractice版参与讨论
相关主题
梅氏综合症(Meige's syndrome)【活动通知】Medicalpractice Bowl
第二诊断治疗意见临床常用的 website or software?
请教神经科医生:脱髓鞘、脊髓炎除了激素还有什么疗法吗?Jaw pain 请教
请问 带状疱疹后遗神经痛 PHN 如何治疗Funny story about OSH
EPIC门诊大家用EMR有什么感受?
AirplaneVA 系统的优缺点
你们别整天钱不钱的,让我来点高尚的如何治疗TMJ
美国医生生活的无聊偏头痛吗?我是不是有焦虑症
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: botox话题: evidence话题: based话题: injection话题: migraine