由买买提看人间百态

boards

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档,一周内的贴子最多显示50字,超过一周显示500字 访问原贴
Military版 - 《木兰》上映,美国的蒙古人很Struggle
相关主题
一直以为关于韩国人的说法是网络娱乐DF-21C
蒙古新纳粹崛起駐中大使︰美應防解放軍恫嚇台
满族蒙族即将在中国消失 米犹日本急得火上房全胜时期的蒙古帝国面积和苏联哪个大?
英国小报庆祝中国马年ZTWhy Chinese Used Bow Centuries After Europeans Discontinued
随手搜了一下prc inner mongolia manchuria tibet,被雷了华夏历史上最大的谎言---蒙元与满清
西部大开发10年了,有什么成就?UCSD种族歧视事件,要解决关键是要造成一定的社会影响
蒙古新纳粹:与中国人睡觉的蒙古女人都要剃光头zt中国崛起之六:“海归、海不归”的背后
回族在对日抗战中的英勇事迹中国历史上最大的谎言——元朝与清朝
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: mulan话题: huns话题: struggle话题: disney话题: mongols
进入Military版参与讨论
1 (共1页)
R*****5
发帖数: 4915
1
he told me that he finally explained to the children how Mulan depicts us –
the Mongols
We were the Huns – the yellow-eyed, grey-skinned, long-haired, fur wearing
evil monsters
https://macongolia.com/2017/11/30/becoming-the-villain-a-mongol-american-
struggle-with-mulan/
来源
Becoming the Villain: A Mongol-American Struggle with Mulan
November 30, 2017 macongolia
Four years ago, my nephew and niece, at the time aged ten and six
respectively, saw Disney’s animated film Mulan. They gleefully watched a
story featuring a red fast-talking sidekick dragon, the brave young Mulan,
and the yellow-eyed evil Huns. The movie’s catchy songs were sung around
the house calling everyone to “let’s get down to business, to defeat the
Huns!”
A year later, I visited my family for the winter holidays. Remembering all
the fun we had singing Mulan songs, I suggested we re-watch the movie.
Except this time, my nephew and niece both strongly disagreed. When I asked
my brother why, he told me that he finally explained to the children how
Mulan depicts us – the Mongols.
We were the Huns – the yellow-eyed, grey-skinned, long-haired, fur wearing
evil monsters in the movie that are shown in the beginning as characters to
be feared but by the end are ones to be laughed at. Naturally, my nephew and
niece did not like watching a movie that depicted us as such.
R*****5
发帖数: 4915
2
我也感觉《木兰》里,丑化另一个民族有点过分
R*****5
发帖数: 4915
3
In recent years, a growing multicultural society has called on Disney to
diversify characters and increase cultural sensitivity in their films. For
the most part, they have responded – see Moana from the same titled movie
and Tiana from the Princess and the Frog. Unfortunately, capable Asian
characters remain few and far between – with millions of Asian girls
looking up to and absorbing the story of Mulan, and the barbarity of her
rivals. This is evident in the character of Mulan being identified by Disney
as a Princess, while she is not a princess in any capacity, essentially
tokenizing her.
But where does this story come from?
Mongolians traditionally trace themselves back to the Khunnu (Хүнн&
#1199;) Empire, which is where the word for person – “khun” (xүн)
comes from. This is often also referred to as the Xiongnu Empire, and
sometimes the Hun Empire, with a debatable connection to Attila the Hun’s
reign in Europe.
During the annual summer Naadam Festival, Mongol heritage is highlighted
through various performances. Last July, during the opening ceremony for the
festival, the President called for a celebration of the “2,226th year
anniversary of the establishment of the Empire, 811th year anniversary of
the establishment of the Mongol State, 106th year anniversary of
independence and 96th year anniversary of the People’s Revolution.”
The common stereotypes of Mongols arose from this period of time as well as
later in Chinggis Khan’s reign, as most written records were kept by those
that the Mongolians fought with for resources and power. Called “barbarians
” by sources written in Chinese, Persian and Sanskrit, Mongolians were
described as having slanted yellow eyes, stocky bodies and tanned skin. They
were superior archers and brutal warriors that rode short and stocky horses
. These are all the characteristics that Disney’s Mulan shamelessly depicts.
W*****B
发帖数: 4796
4
活该,蒙古人当年对欧亚大陆人民灭绝人性的种族屠杀,空前绝后。本来按照他们所犯
的反人类罪行是应该整体灭族的。现在让他们活着已经是恩赐了,还唧唧歪歪什么?

:he told me that he finally explained to the children how Mulan depicts us
– the Mongols
:We were the Huns – the yellow-eyed, grey-skinned, long-haired, fur
wearing evil monsters
https://macongolia.com/2017/11/30/becoming-the-villain-a-mongol-american-
:struggle-with-mulan/
:来源
:Becoming the Villain: A Mongol-American Struggle with Mulan
:November 30, 2017 macongolia
:Four years ago, my nephew and niece, at the time aged ten and six
:respectively, saw Disney’s animated film Mulan. They gleefully watched a
:story featuring a red fast-talking sidekick dragon, the brave young Mulan,
:..........

【在 R*****5 的大作中提到】
: In recent years, a growing multicultural society has called on Disney to
: diversify characters and increase cultural sensitivity in their films. For
: the most part, they have responded – see Moana from the same titled movie
: and Tiana from the Princess and the Frog. Unfortunately, capable Asian
: characters remain few and far between – with millions of Asian girls
: looking up to and absorbing the story of Mulan, and the barbarity of her
: rivals. This is evident in the character of Mulan being identified by Disney
: as a Princess, while she is not a princess in any capacity, essentially
: tokenizing her.
: But where does this story come from?

l**p
发帖数: 6080
5
难道以前不是那个样子?
只会更野蛮

wearing

【在 R*****5 的大作中提到】
: he told me that he finally explained to the children how Mulan depicts us –
: the Mongols
: We were the Huns – the yellow-eyed, grey-skinned, long-haired, fur wearing
: evil monsters
: https://macongolia.com/2017/11/30/becoming-the-villain-a-mongol-american-
: struggle-with-mulan/
: 来源
: Becoming the Villain: A Mongol-American Struggle with Mulan
: November 30, 2017 macongolia
: Four years ago, my nephew and niece, at the time aged ten and six

l**p
发帖数: 6080
6
难道以前不是那个样子?
只会更野蛮

wearing

【在 R*****5 的大作中提到】
: he told me that he finally explained to the children how Mulan depicts us –
: the Mongols
: We were the Huns – the yellow-eyed, grey-skinned, long-haired, fur wearing
: evil monsters
: https://macongolia.com/2017/11/30/becoming-the-villain-a-mongol-american-
: struggle-with-mulan/
: 来源
: Becoming the Villain: A Mongol-American Struggle with Mulan
: November 30, 2017 macongolia
: Four years ago, my nephew and niece, at the time aged ten and six

R*****5
发帖数: 4915
7
你这就扯远了,蒙古人杀人不少,但也促进了东西交流,别的民族也杀人,只是杀不过
蒙古人而已。

us

【在 W*****B 的大作中提到】
: 活该,蒙古人当年对欧亚大陆人民灭绝人性的种族屠杀,空前绝后。本来按照他们所犯
: 的反人类罪行是应该整体灭族的。现在让他们活着已经是恩赐了,还唧唧歪歪什么?
:
: :he told me that he finally explained to the children how Mulan depicts us
: – the Mongols
: :We were the Huns – the yellow-eyed, grey-skinned, long-haired, fur
: wearing evil monsters
: :https://macongolia.com/2017/11/30/becoming-the-villain-a-mongol-american-
: :struggle-with-mulan/
: :来源

f******t
发帖数: 19544
8
这小心灵能适应美帝社会吗。
e****w
发帖数: 1565
9
蒙古人要跟小萌辜一样
把屁股撅起来给白大人很艹就行了


: 这小心灵能适应美帝社会吗。



【在 f******t 的大作中提到】
: 这小心灵能适应美帝社会吗。
R*****5
发帖数: 4915
10
蒙古杀人厉害,但也知道知识的重要,蒙古军中有各民族的工匠和学者,汉人,安南人
,波斯人,阿拉伯人,维吾尔人,欧洲人,北京城格局就是元朝开建的元大都。
比起汉人缠小脚,欣赏三寸金莲强多了。

【在 l**p 的大作中提到】
: 难道以前不是那个样子?
: 只会更野蛮
:
: wearing

相关主题
西部大开发10年了,有什么成就?DF-21C
蒙古新纳粹:与中国人睡觉的蒙古女人都要剃光头zt駐中大使︰美應防解放軍恫嚇台
回族在对日抗战中的英勇事迹全胜时期的蒙古帝国面积和苏联哪个大?
进入Military版参与讨论
R*****5
发帖数: 4915
11
周永康显然没问题

【在 f******t 的大作中提到】
: 这小心灵能适应美帝社会吗。
R*****5
发帖数: 4915
12
Christina Aguilera - Reflection(木兰主题曲)
m*****n
发帖数: 3575
13
史上第一次细菌战就是蒙古人发动的
往围城里扔死尸灭绝了欧洲1/3的人口
核弹还促进核电厂呢
你少矫情有利有弊

【在 R*****5 的大作中提到】
: 你这就扯远了,蒙古人杀人不少,但也促进了东西交流,别的民族也杀人,只是杀不过
: 蒙古人而已。
:
: us

K*****2
发帖数: 9308
14
蒙古人都白痴
匈奴跟蒙古没有半毛钱关系
b********n
发帖数: 38600
15
Struggle个鸡巴。
成吉思汗都打到了欧洲,奸杀掠夺,世界1/200的人有蒙古DNA
v*******e
发帖数: 11604
16
就是,还有本版的傻X们,历史人文一窍不通


: 蒙古人都白痴

: 匈奴跟蒙古没有半毛钱关系



【在 K*****2 的大作中提到】
: 蒙古人都白痴
: 匈奴跟蒙古没有半毛钱关系

n********t
发帖数: 21
17
小蒙古 哈哈哈
1 (共1页)
进入Military版参与讨论
相关主题
中国历史上最大的谎言——元朝与清朝随手搜了一下prc inner mongolia manchuria tibet,被雷了
咱中国没有人学法律也没有人会辩论吗?西部大开发10年了,有什么成就?
菲律宾媒体周末专栏文章: "黄岩岛属于中国"蒙古新纳粹:与中国人睡觉的蒙古女人都要剃光头zt
新疆这事根源上怪安禄山回族在对日抗战中的英勇事迹
一直以为关于韩国人的说法是网络娱乐DF-21C
蒙古新纳粹崛起駐中大使︰美應防解放軍恫嚇台
满族蒙族即将在中国消失 米犹日本急得火上房全胜时期的蒙古帝国面积和苏联哪个大?
英国小报庆祝中国马年ZTWhy Chinese Used Bow Centuries After Europeans Discontinued
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: mulan话题: huns话题: struggle话题: disney话题: mongols