j***b
发帖数: 5901 | 1 感觉浪得虚名啊。当时班上大家挺推崇的，评分也挺高。 |
s******n
发帖数: 6806 | 2 好在是小制作，比大制作的很多片子强多了。
【在 j***b 的大作中提到】
: 感觉浪得虚名啊。当时班上大家挺推崇的，评分也挺高。
|
m*****d
发帖数: 13718 | 3 主要是尾巴搞坏了，就是等到字幕出完再续貂也没这么狗血
【在 j***b 的大作中提到】
: 感觉浪得虚名啊。当时班上大家挺推崇的，评分也挺高。
|
C*******r
发帖数: 10345 | 4 完全同意，其实画面凝固的那一刻就出字幕，基本就是一部中等偏上的片子。结果又来
了个荷里活式的传统曲笔，love conquers all, 让人倒胃口。
【在 m*****d 的大作中提到】
: 主要是尾巴搞坏了，就是等到字幕出完再续貂也没这么狗血
|
j***b
发帖数: 5901 | 5 That's not my idea. I never believe that an otherwise good 115 minutes can be ruined by 5 minutes bad ending. Or a otherwise mediocre 115 minutes can be saved by 5 minutes of good ending.
I never buy the crap of leaving suspense for the viewer (such as inception, which is overrated like hell).
As for the movie. I just think that overall it's not exceptional. Actually I think the ending wins some scores because the parallel universe thing. Without spelling this out, the movie will be incomplete. It's just that I think the overall idea is mediocre, that doesn't mean it can become a good movie if this idea isn't expressed at all and left out as "suspense". They can just as well leave the whole movie out as suspense so that I can imagine a perfect movie from scrach all by myself.
【在 m*****d 的大作中提到】
: 主要是尾巴搞坏了，就是等到字幕出完再续貂也没这么狗血
|
m*****d
发帖数: 13718 | 6 平行宇宙不是不可以，但是不能是混乱不能自圆其说的平行宇宙
be ruined by 5 minutes bad ending. Or a otherwise mediocre 115 minutes can
be saved by 5 minutes of good ending.
, which is overrated like hell).
I think the ending wins some scores because the parallel universe thing.
Without spelling this out, the movie will be incomplete. It's just that I
think the overall idea is mediocre, that doesn't mean it can become a good
movie if this idea isn't expressed at all and left out as "suspense". They
can just as well leave the whole movie out as suspense so that I can imagine
a perfect movie from scrach all by myself.
【在 j***b 的大作中提到】
: That's not my idea. I never believe that an otherwise good 115 minutes can be ruined by 5 minutes bad ending. Or a otherwise mediocre 115 minutes can be saved by 5 minutes of good ending.
: I never buy the crap of leaving suspense for the viewer (such as inception, which is overrated like hell).
: As for the movie. I just think that overall it's not exceptional. Actually I think the ending wins some scores because the parallel universe thing. Without spelling this out, the movie will be incomplete. It's just that I think the overall idea is mediocre, that doesn't mean it can become a good movie if this idea isn't expressed at all and left out as "suspense". They can just as well leave the whole movie out as suspense so that I can imagine a perfect movie from scrach all by myself.
|
j***b
发帖数: 5901 | 7 I'm saying that bad idea is still better than no idea at all.
can
imagine
【在 m*****d 的大作中提到】
: 平行宇宙不是不可以，但是不能是混乱不能自圆其说的平行宇宙
:
: be ruined by 5 minutes bad ending. Or a otherwise mediocre 115 minutes can
: be saved by 5 minutes of good ending.
: , which is overrated like hell).
: I think the ending wins some scores because the parallel universe thing.
: Without spelling this out, the movie will be incomplete. It's just that I
: think the overall idea is mediocre, that doesn't mean it can become a good
: movie if this idea isn't expressed at all and left out as "suspense". They
: can just as well leave the whole movie out as suspense so that I can imagine
|
c******o
发帖数: 4751 | 8 come on, give that poor movie a break.
every time u bring up the idea of parallel universes, it's already 混乱不能
自圆其说 to a lot of people.
just go with it....
【在 m*****d 的大作中提到】
: 平行宇宙不是不可以，但是不能是混乱不能自圆其说的平行宇宙
:
: be ruined by 5 minutes bad ending. Or a otherwise mediocre 115 minutes can
: be saved by 5 minutes of good ending.
: , which is overrated like hell).
: I think the ending wins some scores because the parallel universe thing.
: Without spelling this out, the movie will be incomplete. It's just that I
: think the overall idea is mediocre, that doesn't mean it can become a good
: movie if this idea isn't expressed at all and left out as "suspense". They
: can just as well leave the whole movie out as suspense so that I can imagine
|
m*****d
发帖数: 13718 | 9 不能认同
【在 j***b 的大作中提到】
: I'm saying that bad idea is still better than no idea at all.
:
: can
: imagine
|
m*****d
发帖数: 13718 | 10 可以自圆其说，比如说fringe
【在 c******o 的大作中提到】
: come on, give that poor movie a break.
: every time u bring up the idea of parallel universes, it's already 混乱不能
: 自圆其说 to a lot of people.
: just go with it....
|
|
|
f**********r
发帖数: 2137 | 11 结尾是为了拍续集，不过整体也不算太烂，即使idea不新，表达方式还不错 |
c******o
发帖数: 4751 | 12 the TV series?
【在 m*****d 的大作中提到】
: 可以自圆其说，比如说fringe
|
y****n
发帖数: 3184 | 13 浪得虚名谈不上吧
这片中等偏上吧
跟同期的Adjustment Bureau一比简直就是神片
近几年好的科幻片太少了,只有山中无虎，猴子称王了
当然，Duncan Jones之前的Moon很好
【在 j***b 的大作中提到】
: 感觉浪得虚名啊。当时班上大家挺推崇的，评分也挺高。
|
j***b
发帖数: 5901 | 14 Adjustment Bureau一看介绍是神棍片立刻pass。
不看一切神棍片。
【在 y****n 的大作中提到】
: 浪得虚名谈不上吧
: 这片中等偏上吧
: 跟同期的Adjustment Bureau一比简直就是神片
: 近几年好的科幻片太少了,只有山中无虎，猴子称王了
: 当然，Duncan Jones之前的Moon很好
|
l*****u
发帖数: 1788 | 15 没那么差了，在今年还是很说得过去的电影。后来看影评才知道是 月亮 的导演，怪不
得立意很像，也都是小成本科幻片。
至于结尾，没有什么不好，只不过给演完了大家突然觉得不习惯罢了。影评的时候也就
没那么多联想和讨论了。 |
T*******x
发帖数: 8565 | 16 我觉得还不错。
创意给8.5
小制作给7.5
总评8.0
【在 j***b 的大作中提到】
: 感觉浪得虚名啊。当时班上大家挺推崇的，评分也挺高。
|
i***1
发帖数: 2534 | 17 同意，看电影太较真没意思。。。
【在 T*******x 的大作中提到】
: 我觉得还不错。
: 创意给8.5
: 小制作给7.5
: 总评8.0
|
