e****t
发帖数: 17914 | 1 490 of 505 people found the following review helpful:
Canon EF 24-70mm vs. 24-105mm IS: Read this if you are a hobbyist, November
19, 2009
By va1800
This review is from: Canon EF 24-105mm f/4 L IS USM Lens for Canon EOS SLR
Cameras (Electronics)
I am a hobbyist and this review is for people like me. What I mean by that
is that I take pictures for fun and nobody buys my pictures. I mostly shoot
landscape, nature, and portraits of family, friends, and relatives. I will
refer to 24-70mm as the 70, and the 24-105mm IS as the 105. I first made the
mistake of buying the 70, then I returned it with a hefty restocking fee
and bought the 105 - I don't have the slightest regret and I could not be
happier. I'm taking my time to write this review so that you can spend your
hard earned money wisely. Let's analyze the trade-off between the two:
* Both lenses have excellent build and image quality. So these are not
differentiating factors.
* The one and only advantage of the 70 is the one smaller f-stop. For me,
this means more blur when I shoot portraits, so this is all good.
* The advantage of 105 over the 70 are as follows:
- You get an extra 35mm, which is 50% more zoom. I like this.
- You get a 3-stop IS. For me, this is a great advantage, because I rarely
use tripods and IS saves the day. I would choose the 105 over 70 for the IS
alone.
- The 105 is 10 ounces lighter and close to half an inch shorter.
The last part is the most important part: that additional 10 ounces make a
heavy lens TOO HEAVY, and that extra length makes a big lens TOO BIG.
Carrying the 70 on my 50D was a pain. I can assure you, the 70 is just too
heavy to walk around and take pictures for fun. The keyword here is "fun".
The 70 is a pain, the 105 is fun. The 105 is still heavy, but not too heavy.
It's still big, but not too big. After having the 70 for a few weeks, I
lost all my joy for shooting. It just made me very uncomfortable (and I'm 6-
foot 2). When I replaced it with the 105, it did make a difference. I enjoy
taking pictures now, once again. Pros might like the 70 because they need it
for their professional work. But if you're shooting just for fun, stay away
from the 70 and get the 105. | J**********s
发帖数: 158 | 2 这两个头都不好，老猫直接上定焦吧。。。24L TSE, 35L, 85L, 135L 200L
November
shoot
the
【在 e****t 的大作中提到】
: 490 of 505 people found the following review helpful:
: Canon EF 24-70mm vs. 24-105mm IS: Read this if you are a hobbyist, November
: 19, 2009
: By va1800
: This review is from: Canon EF 24-105mm f/4 L IS USM Lens for Canon EOS SLR
: Cameras (Electronics)
: I am a hobbyist and this review is for people like me. What I mean by that
: is that I take pictures for fun and nobody buys my pictures. I mostly shoot
: landscape, nature, and portraits of family, friends, and relatives. I will
: refer to 24-70mm as the 70, and the 24-105mm IS as the 105. I first made the
| a**i
发帖数: 7261 | 3 两个都买吧
November
shoot
the
【在 e****t 的大作中提到】
: 490 of 505 people found the following review helpful:
: Canon EF 24-70mm vs. 24-105mm IS: Read this if you are a hobbyist, November
: 19, 2009
: By va1800
: This review is from: Canon EF 24-105mm f/4 L IS USM Lens for Canon EOS SLR
: Cameras (Electronics)
: I am a hobbyist and this review is for people like me. What I mean by that
: is that I take pictures for fun and nobody buys my pictures. I mostly shoot
: landscape, nature, and portraits of family, friends, and relatives. I will
: refer to 24-70mm as the 70, and the 24-105mm IS as the 105. I first made the
| m****7
发帖数: 14685 | 4 buying a ff standard zoom lens on apsc has already told too much about this
guy. | b********2
发帖数: 3189 | 5 24-105是个不错的头，我用了几天
但是，如果有钱，还是35L吧，前后走两步的事，但是画质确实好多了 | e****t
发帖数: 17914 | 6
短的定焦基本都拥有过
现在想不好买啥
有娃了不能乱用钱了
【在 J**********s 的大作中提到】
: 这两个头都不好，老猫直接上定焦吧。。。24L TSE, 35L, 85L, 135L 200L
:
: November
: shoot
: the
| J**********s
发帖数: 158 | 7 呵呵，那就整套灯具好好给娃拍拍照吧。记得前段时间yotube上有个视频，那人每天给
孩子拍一张照片拍了10年，很有意思。老猫也可以效仿嘛。
【在 e****t 的大作中提到】
:
: 短的定焦基本都拥有过
: 现在想不好买啥
: 有娃了不能乱用钱了
| J**********s
发帖数: 158 | 8 给你把这个视频挖出来了，从出生开始10年，一天一张，挺有意义的。老猫看看。你们
家“小猫”多大？：）
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ejbNVWES4LI
【在 e****t 的大作中提到】
:
: 短的定焦基本都拥有过
: 现在想不好买啥
: 有娃了不能乱用钱了
|
|
