t****d
发帖数: 127 | 1 我认为鲍家街43号的新专辑比起他们第一张专辑跟好了。这一张专辑非常与众不同。
每一首歌都不一样， 非常diverse. 一首听上去像techno, 一首听上去像rap,
感觉上去比他们上一盘更加diverse.上一盘非常bluesy..太专一于一种音乐style了。
我认为鲍家街43号是中国最有前途的一个乐队， 比起xuwei, 等更加有出路。
其他人太注重于一种音乐style, too limiting. No wonder they are students from
中国中央音乐学院。
Very good.
I think this is the best album this year so far.
thekid. | R****e
发帖数: 878 | 2
Well, actually I like the other side. In my mind the best album should be
like a good book. It should have a 基调. I can't imagine a ablum with rap
and techno or sth together...sounds strange.
I never heard of their 2nd ablum. When I first heard the band on the radio,
I'm glad to see that china also has a blues band. But when I heard their
debut album...so disappointing...why did they change?
【在 t****d 的大作中提到】
: 我认为鲍家街43号的新专辑比起他们第一张专辑跟好了。这一张专辑非常与众不同。
: 每一首歌都不一样， 非常diverse. 一首听上去像techno, 一首听上去像rap,
: 感觉上去比他们上一盘更加diverse.上一盘非常bluesy..太专一于一种音乐style了。
: 我认为鲍家街43号是中国最有前途的一个乐队， 比起xuwei, 等更加有出路。
: 其他人太注重于一种音乐style, too limiting. No wonder they are students from
: 中国中央音乐学院。
: Very good.
: I think this is the best album this year so far.
: thekid.
| t****d
发帖数: 127 | 3
I disagree with you. I think a band with a wide range of sound and capabilty
is a great band. Because such band won't just follow what other people does,
they also can innovate. This second album of theirs is a sign to me that
they are not very limitting.. It takes skills to cover such wide range, and
cover them with such skill. And it is even harder to innovate. This album
actually broke my dislike for them when their first album came out, because
that particular album was extremely bluesy. Bl
【在 R****e 的大作中提到】
:
: Well, actually I like the other side. In my mind the best album should be
: like a good book. It should have a 基调. I can't imagine a ablum with rap
: and techno or sth together...sounds strange.
: I never heard of their 2nd ablum. When I first heard the band on the radio,
: I'm glad to see that china also has a blues band. But when I heard their
: debut album...so disappointing...why did they change?
| R****e
发帖数: 878 | 4 hmm, no change doesn't mean no improve, also when you changed
it didn't mean you got better. (here "change" means change of style)
What do you want to show by music? to show that you can play many kinds
of music? that's nonsense. Actually I think most musician can play several
different kinds of music 'cause all kinds of music is 相通. but I can't
garantee they could play well.
Metallica changed and Metallica is dying. R.E.M. also seems to get a little
bit faraway in their new "up". I can't image
【在 t****d 的大作中提到】
:
: I disagree with you. I think a band with a wide range of sound and capabilty
: is a great band. Because such band won't just follow what other people does,
: they also can innovate. This second album of theirs is a sign to me that
: they are not very limitting.. It takes skills to cover such wide range, and
: cover them with such skill. And it is even harder to innovate. This album
: actually broke my dislike for them when their first album came out, because
: that particular album was extremely bluesy. Bl
| t****d
发帖数: 127 | 5 Yes I do mean a change of style. However, in baojiajie's case, they covered
a wide range of styles, it is not like they came out with an album with one
style and suddenly the next album is totally something new or different. That
is not what I mean.. what I mean is that baojiaje presented themselves as a
band with range, so later on when they come out with certain style of song
people won't call them sellouts. this gives them room to experiment, change,
evolve as the band members mature and thei
【在 R****e 的大作中提到】
: hmm, no change doesn't mean no improve, also when you changed
: it didn't mean you got better. (here "change" means change of style)
: What do you want to show by music? to show that you can play many kinds
: of music? that's nonsense. Actually I think most musician can play several
: different kinds of music 'cause all kinds of music is 相通. but I can't
: garantee they could play well.
: Metallica changed and Metallica is dying. R.E.M. also seems to get a little
: bit faraway in their new "up". I can't image
| g*******a
发帖数: 1383 | 6 各位老大，小的提一点看法
首先这盘带子要2。19号才能听到
不过他们的一很精彩啦，我当时在水母发文说总算有新乐队有点儿真活的
你们说的都有道理，乐队得有自己的风格，不然没多久就被忘记了
不过象报价街这种新乐队，你也不能强求他们开始就定了调，总得什么都试试
然后找感觉好的走。就我觉得一个好乐队应当有各种方面的知识和技巧
但得有一个相对固定的独特风格，象糖超一里面来个月梦，点缀点缀。
各位大虾指教 | g*******a
发帖数: 1383 | 7 嗯，不奇怪了，我怀疑你是开CD店的
啊，对了，大家从来没人听LIVE，我在水母还被奚落一番，妈妈的
LIVE很不错啊，我现在听的最多
【在 t****d 的大作中提到】
: Yes I do mean a change of style. However, in baojiajie's case, they covered
: a wide range of styles, it is not like they came out with an album with one
: style and suddenly the next album is totally something new or different. That
: is not what I mean.. what I mean is that baojiaje presented themselves as a
: band with range, so later on when they come out with certain style of song
: people won't call them sellouts. this gives them room to experiment, change,
: evolve as the band members mature and thei
| l********a
发帖数: 4 | 8 I don't see anything wrong with anyone doing blues in China. In fact,
I'm hoping to see more bands doing blues. Blues might originate from
US but it's universal and anyone can sing to it. Blues is one of the
few musical forms that I still don't get old with, and probably never
will.
In some sense blues and techno have many commonalities. I know this
sounds weird but think about it. In techno basically you have the
same beat pattern looped back, while in blues you have this
constant 12 bar struct |
|
