S**b
发帖数: 1883 | 1 在我下面论证三年饥荒不可能饿死三千万的几种方法中，是一种并的关系，也就是说，
如果驳倒我其中的一种方法，而其它的方法没有驳倒，那么不可能饿死三千万左右的人
就成立。
方法一，抽象统计的办法。
如果当年全国六亿人口中有三千万人饿死，那么就有二十分之一的人饿死，而一个
人的生活圈，朋友圈通常都有一百人左右，在这种情况下每个人的亲戚朋友一定会有五
个人左右饿死。你们有谁知道自己亲人朋友圈子里饿死五个人？
方法二，目击证人的办法。
有人说，之所以没有那么多的网友家里饿死了人，是因为饥饿是整个村庄地绝户地饿
死的。这样一来就不会有人活着出来报告。如果是这样，那么就一定会有幸存者，这幸
存者就是目击证人，他就会发表文章，谈他家里全家饿死，全村饿死，只有他一个人活
了出来的情况。他必须以第一人称 “我”，来叙述这件事。正如日本法西斯的南京大
屠杀，德国法西斯的屠杀二百万犹太人，都有目击证人，都有幸存者亲身出来控诉。可
是至今没有看到这样的目击证人。
如果一个村庄灭绝，是一定会有目击证人。比如说，当时的解放军是在全国征兵的，而
且因为人人都想当兵，因此当兵的名额是平均地分配到每个村庄，因此几乎每 | q******r
发帖数: 154 | 2 Dr. Cui Qi, the Nobel price winner lost his parent, his sisters, and most of
his family relatives in Henan in the early of 1960s. He may provide you a
more accurate number. More or less than 30 million. But that is not the
important part of the story. If we cannot face to the disaster our ancestors
made for our homeland, how can we require the others to do so? | g****d
发帖数: 88 | 3 There were a lot of people died of hungry. My grand father was one of them.
About 30% of population in the village my grand father lived dead during
that period of time.
My grand mother survived because she moved to live with my father after my
grand father dead. Fortunately, my father did not live in the same village
as my grand parent. |
|
