w*******t
发帖数: 2459 | 1 通过调查,发现Senator Grassley现在是真正的H1B/PERM/I140打假的推手.
1. Grassley Behind 221G Visa refusals --- 221(g) H1B Refusals at Consular
Posts in India
http://imminfo.com/News/Newsletter/2012-02-15/221g-h1b-refusals
ZZ from trackitt -
"ImmiHelp had discovered that Grassley is behind H1B 221G issues in India.
Please read article http://imminfo.com/News/Newsletter/2012-02-15/2...
Anybody who goes to consulate in India for a Visa Stamp is being tortured
down.Don't go for stamping in India unless in case of an emergency. 50% or
more of the H1B applications ends up in denials."
2. USCIS memo - 对ICC之流consulting firms的重拳出击:
The Associate Director of U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Service (USCIS)
issued a controversial January 8, 2010 memorandum to adjudicators who review
H-1B petitions for skilled foreign nationals that limits who can be
considered an “employee” of a company.1 In essence, the memorandum states
that in some third-party placements – where the worker is assigned by a
company to work at the location of a client – the worker would not be
considered an employee of the company. The memorandum affects physicians,
physical therapists,
occupational therapists, specialty nurses, software engineers and many other
professional occupations.
3. H1B denial rate (refer to NFAP - National Foundation of American Policy)
从美国公民及移民服务局(USCIS)取得新的数据显示，过去四年L1和H1B签证申请案的拒
签率巨幅增加。资料显示，遭拒签的多为印度人士，应与部分印度人涉嫌诈欺有关。
http://www.nfap.com/pdf/NFAP_Policy_Brief.USCIS_and_Denial_Rate
Denial rates for H-1B petitions increased from 11 percent in FY 2007 to 29
percent in FY 2009, and remained higher than in the past for H-1Bs at 21
percent in FY 2010 and 17 percent in FY 2011.
4. L-1B denial rate
Denial rates for L-1B petitions filed with USCIS, which are used to transfer
employees with “specialized knowledge” into the United States, rose from
7 percent in FY 2007 to 22 percent in FY 2008, despite no change in the law
or relevant regulation. The denial rates stayed high for L-1B petitions at
26 percent in FY 2009, 22 percent in FY 2010 and 27 percent in FY 2011.1 In
addition, 63 percent of L-1B petitions in FY 2011 were at least temporarily
denied or delayed due to a Request for Evidence.
5. 严打 EB3I porting to EB2
Shifting USCIS Position on Indian 3+2 Master's Degrees ---- The USCIS is
taking the position that one cannot have the equivalent of a U.S. master's
degree unless one also has four years of undergraduate work.
http://imminfo.com/News/Newsletter/2012-02-15/shifting-uscis-po
----------------------------------------
几点澄清:
1. Grassley是打假英雄, 能看出他老在背后付出的艰辛努力. 所以G对打假没性娶是站
不住脚的.
2. 打假没必要通过国会所谓的BILL, 几个USCIS memo就够了.
3. 参考(5), 现在由于EB2和EB3排期的差距, 可以想象会有大量的烙印各色"3+2"正在
想方设法转成EB2. 形势很不乐观. 去trackitt看看EB3 port EB2的跟贴就知道了, 长
长30多pages (从去年11月开始集结).
JWE 老兄能否用random sample法估算一下EB3I->EB2I的数目.
4. (5)是阻截EB3->EB2的最有效的办法.USCIS现在大量的PERM和I-140RFE都是针对所谓
"3+2"中的"3"和"2"的有效性. 烙印都是让非赢利机构类似AACRAO-IES来做评估. 我们
能否在AACRAO的有效性上做点文章. 大量的RFE也让它们发了横财.
http://ies.aacrao.org/
From tracitt:
Hi,
I recently got RFE for my i140 in EB2 requesting for transcripts and copy of
Masters degree. I have 3 years Bachelors (Maths, Physics, Chemistry) and 3
year MCA. I saw that many people here recommended AACRAO so I did my Masters
evaluation through AACRAO with evaluation type as course by course
immigration evaluation. AACRAO's evaluation says
1. Applicant has completed comparable level of US education as Indicated --
Masters degree
2. General Comments:
-- The applicant has completed a three year Bachelor of Science and a three
year Master of Computer Applications at XXX University. In combination these
degrees are comparable to a Bachelor of Science in Computer Science and one
year Master of Science in Computer Science from a regionally accredited
college or University in the United States. Note that the final year of
Computer Applications constitutes graduate credit
My question is how does USCIS handle this one year Master's degree thing ?
Did anyone else who did their evaluation through AACRAO get similar general
comments ? I am concerned that USCIS might reject it considering that Master
's here is usually 2 year degree. Can anyone please suggest if it is okay to
submit this evaluation or I should get another evaluation by TrustForte or
some other agency which just says it as master's degree and not as one year
or two year masters.
The RFE needs to be responded soon so will appreciate for a quick response.
------------------------------------------------------------------
Part (1)
Note: Part 2我会提出一些针对(5)和I-140 W2监控的思路, (5)已经是USCIS目前RFE的依据. 我们需要对AACRAO之类的机构提出质疑, 让鸭到国会听证去. I-140的W2监控根本不需要太多的budget投入, 设定一个参考值比例, 在公司没变的情况下收入减少1/3(举例),直接发140RFE,然后拒掉I-140. 如果USCIS针对(5)有新的memo, 这对已经提交485待批都具有追溯效力.
| a*******d
发帖数: 4846 | 2 不管是职场还是移民，这个是对老中长远很有益的东西啊！
大家应该要支持。 | d********e
发帖数: 267 | | a*******d
发帖数: 4846 | 4 如果把奥本按照PD分配SO，造成了事实上favor烙印EB2和鼓励EB3I->EB2I porting的
情况点给Senator Grassley，也许能促成中印松绑也不一定。 | w*******t
发帖数: 2459 | 5 所有真正支持的, 请say "I want to act for this".
同时也是征集支持ID!
如果有NIU的支持,力量就更大了.
打击EB3I的fraud, 所有的EB2C都受益! | H******i
发帖数: 4704 | 6 http://www.mitbbs.com/article0/EB23/31630105_0.html
.
)可以得出大量EB3->EB2 porting这样的结论. “3”是指3年undergraduate study. 烙
印EB3I里有大量这类野鸡学校弄出的”3”, 这些EB3I试图通过”2”这个2年的MS
study来试图(见P1.4的case)具备EB2的资格. USCIS已经注意到这个"3+2"模式, 发出了
不少RFE, 要求认证”3”或”2”. 烙印的策略是找AACRAO-IES( http://ies.aacrao.org )这样的非赢利机构认证. 我们可以从AACRAO认证的validity上入手, 争取让它到国会听证, 延缓这一porting的重要环节. 同时, 我们的努: 力方向的促成相关的USCIS memo.
略遏制相关的fraud. 我前面的贴子有相关的case http://www.mitbbs.com/article_t0/EB23/31621681.html. USCIS目前可能是通过W2来监控. . I-140的W2监控根本不需要太多的budget投入, 设定一个参考值比例, 在公司没变的情况下收入减少1/4(举例), 直接发140RFE, 然后拒掉I-140. 我们的努力方向的促成相关的USCIS memo.
【在 w*******t 的大作中提到】
: 所有真正支持的, 请say "I want to act for this".
: 同时也是征集支持ID!
: 如果有NIU的支持,力量就更大了.
: 打击EB3I的fraud, 所有的EB2C都受益!
| p***e
发帖数: 29053 | | w*******t
发帖数: 2459 | 8 Your arguments can't hold on themselves.
First, how do we know which IT firms made or are making frauds? We are not
FBI agents.
Second, There are sure behind-scene forces to push pressures & USCIS memos
on Indian-related frauds on a broad scale. We are not initiating anything
NEW. We are just joining them, ok. What they did explained in my post
already demonstrates USCIS, DOS, and Senators like Grassley are doing it.
They really enjoy it, agree?
What we can only achieve now is just to raise attentions on a more broad
level.
【在 H******i 的大作中提到】
: http://www.mitbbs.com/article0/EB23/31630105_0.html
:
: .
: )可以得出大量EB3->EB2 porting这样的结论. “3”是指3年undergraduate study. 烙
: 印EB3I里有大量这类野鸡学校弄出的”3”, 这些EB3I试图通过”2”这个2年的MS
: study来试图(见P1.4的case)具备EB2的资格. USCIS已经注意到这个"3+2"模式, 发出了
: 不少RFE, 要求认证”3”或”2”. 烙印的策略是找AACRAO-IES( http://ies.aacrao.org )这样的非赢利机构认证. 我们可以从AACRAO认证的validity上入手, 争取让它到国会听证, 延缓这一porting的重要环节. 同时, 我们的努: 力方向的促成相关的USCIS memo.
: 略遏制相关的fraud. 我前面的贴子有相关的case http://www.mitbbs.com/article_t0/EB23/31621681.html. USCIS目前可能是通过W2来监控. . I-140的W2监控根本不需要太多的budget投入, 设定一个参考值比例, 在公司没变的情况下收入减少1/4(举例), 直接发140RFE, 然后拒掉I-140. 我们的努力方向的促成相关的USCIS memo.
| H******i
发帖数: 4704 | 9 NIU只是一个空壳，你自己不加入进去充实NIU,利用NIU,NIU就啥也不是。
http://www.niunational.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=1406
【在 w*******t 的大作中提到】
: 所有真正支持的, 请say "I want to act for this".
: 同时也是征集支持ID!
: 如果有NIU的支持,力量就更大了.
: 打击EB3I的fraud, 所有的EB2C都受益!
| L**P
发帖数: 3792 | 10 很多老印自己开的学位认证，公司在美国，说不定就自己apt当office，认证文件在印
度做
美国政府是不regulate这些私人认证机构的
AACRAO认证的validity上入手, 争取让它到国会听证，但是光让aacrao去（怎么正好有
个rao的印度姓？）不够吧？没有反方。能找到另外的美国组织，维护美国本土教育机
构的证书含金量的去从反面作证来证明这些印度教育的要求不如美国么？比如有什么
computer science master的美国association啥么？
.
)可以得出大量EB3->EB2 porting这样的结论. “3”是指3年undergraduate study. 烙
印EB3I里有大量这类野鸡学校弄出的”3”, 这些EB3I试图通过”2”这个2年的MS
study来试图(见P1.4的case)具备EB2的资格. USCIS已经注意到这个"3+2"模式, 发出了
不少RFE, 要求认证”3”或”2”. 烙印的策略是找AACRAO-IES( http://ies.aacrao.org )这样的非赢利机构认证. 我们可以从AACRAO认证的validity上入手, 争取让它到国会听证, 延缓这一porting的重要环节. 同时, 我们的努: 力方向的促成相关的USCIS memo.
略遏制相关的fraud. 我前面的贴子有相关的case http://www.mitbbs.com/article_t0/EB23/31621681.html. USCIS目前可能是通过W2来监控. . I-140的W2监控根本不需要太多的budget投入, 设定一个参考值比例, 在公司没变的情况下收入减少1/4(举例), 直接发140RFE, 然后拒掉I-140. 我们的努力方向的促成相关的USCIS memo.
【在 w*******t 的大作中提到】
: Your arguments can't hold on themselves.
: First, how do we know which IT firms made or are making frauds? We are not
: FBI agents.
: Second, There are sure behind-scene forces to push pressures & USCIS memos
: on Indian-related frauds on a broad scale. We are not initiating anything
: NEW. We are just joining them, ok. What they did explained in my post
: already demonstrates USCIS, DOS, and Senators like Grassley are doing it.
: They really enjoy it, agree?
: What we can only achieve now is just to raise attentions on a more broad
: level.
| | | L**P
发帖数: 3792 | 11 他说的也有道理，基本思想是从小入手，直接瞄准icc，类似你提的瞄准学位认证机构
，一样
当然怎么证明人家fraud是很难，但是搞点证据提出reasonable suspicion还是不难吧
good luck
【在 w*******t 的大作中提到】
: Your arguments can't hold on themselves.
: First, how do we know which IT firms made or are making frauds? We are not
: FBI agents.
: Second, There are sure behind-scene forces to push pressures & USCIS memos
: on Indian-related frauds on a broad scale. We are not initiating anything
: NEW. We are just joining them, ok. What they did explained in my post
: already demonstrates USCIS, DOS, and Senators like Grassley are doing it.
: They really enjoy it, agree?
: What we can only achieve now is just to raise attentions on a more broad
: level.
| a*******d
发帖数: 4846 | 12 大量作假烙印造成其他烙印签证困难，已经引起不少拥有正规学位烙印的
反感，这样的的烙印应该也是可以争取anti-fraud的对象。
【在 L**P 的大作中提到】
: 很多老印自己开的学位认证，公司在美国，说不定就自己apt当office，认证文件在印
: 度做
: 美国政府是不regulate这些私人认证机构的
: AACRAO认证的validity上入手, 争取让它到国会听证，但是光让aacrao去（怎么正好有
: 个rao的印度姓？）不够吧？没有反方。能找到另外的美国组织，维护美国本土教育机
: 构的证书含金量的去从反面作证来证明这些印度教育的要求不如美国么？比如有什么
: computer science master的美国association啥么？
:
: .
: )可以得出大量EB3->EB2 porting这样的结论. “3”是指3年undergraduate study. 烙
| w*******t
发帖数: 2459 | 13 光喊有什么用...对烙引,拿出铁浪头一个一个地敲...
格老都不嫌累...老中真没救了???
看看烙印的哭诉...
###############################################################
Case:
Can you help me find an example or sample to prepare for an appeal for a
denied I-140 based on "Ability To Pay"?
My W2 for 2006 and 2007 is a little short of Profferred wages. My employer
is a very small startup company. He has agreed to show the balance from his
personal bank statements of Dec. 2006 and 2007. That balance sufficiently
covers for the difference.
I hoping that if you can help find a sample for the appeal would be great.
Also, if any of the members unfortunately had to go through this process,
please give poointers to keep in mind.
Thanks,
############################################################### | a*******d
发帖数: 4846 | 14 其实USCIS提高RFE的比例，特别是对employer的RFE以及税表和W2，
能一下扫倒一大片ICC造假的烙印。
这个应该是在Grassley力所能及的范围，甚至比海外领事馆拒签还容易。
不过这个建议的缺点就是不免会误伤一些老中而且会减慢绿卡审批速度。
his
【在 w*******t 的大作中提到】
: 光喊有什么用...对烙引,拿出铁浪头一个一个地敲...
: 格老都不嫌累...老中真没救了???
: 看看烙印的哭诉...
: ###############################################################
: Case:
: Can you help me find an example or sample to prepare for an appeal for a
: denied I-140 based on "Ability To Pay"?
: My W2 for 2006 and 2007 is a little short of Profferred wages. My employer
: is a very small startup company. He has agreed to show the balance from his
: personal bank statements of Dec. 2006 and 2007. That balance sufficiently
| S********9
发帖数: 1121 | 15 支持老赫，反对楼主缺乏针对性的打假。
老赫给的方向其实很好呀。
1.打击大的ICC，只要抓出一个大ICC，指名道姓的指出来，就可以抓出几千作假烙印，惠及等排期老中。同时又不会影响绝大多数其他无辜老中。实际上也更便于操作
2.打击烙印的学历认证系统，也是指名道姓的攻击最大的作假机构，搞掉那么几千烙印，这么做也不会伤及无辜老中。
3.如果像楼主你这样弄法，把格拉斯里弄进来，到时候，中印捆绑着审查，还没交485
的老中和还没拿卡的老中就等着哭吧。我还没交485呢，所以非常反对你这种损敌一千自损一千的做法！
【在 H******i 的大作中提到】
: http://www.mitbbs.com/article0/EB23/31630105_0.html
:
: .
: )可以得出大量EB3->EB2 porting这样的结论. “3”是指3年undergraduate study. 烙
: 印EB3I里有大量这类野鸡学校弄出的”3”, 这些EB3I试图通过”2”这个2年的MS
: study来试图(见P1.4的case)具备EB2的资格. USCIS已经注意到这个"3+2"模式, 发出了
: 不少RFE, 要求认证”3”或”2”. 烙印的策略是找AACRAO-IES( http://ies.aacrao.org )这样的非赢利机构认证. 我们可以从AACRAO认证的validity上入手, 争取让它到国会听证, 延缓这一porting的重要环节. 同时, 我们的努: 力方向的促成相关的USCIS memo.
: 略遏制相关的fraud. 我前面的贴子有相关的case http://www.mitbbs.com/article_t0/EB23/31621681.html. USCIS目前可能是通过W2来监控. . I-140的W2监控根本不需要太多的budget投入, 设定一个参考值比例, 在公司没变的情况下收入减少1/4(举例), 直接发140RFE, 然后拒掉I-140. 我们的努力方向的促成相关的USCIS memo.
|
|
