t******o
发帖数: 149 | 1 My background:
PhD from top US school;
~10 Journal papers + ~10 conference papers;
~20 self-citation + ~2 independent citations;
Below is my RFE letter. Please help! Thx!
My RFE:
The record claims you meet criteria numbers two, four, five and six of Title
8 Code of Federal Regulations Part 204.5(h)(3).
The record shows you do meet criterion number four. However, the record is
more problematic regarding the remaining criteria.
Regarding the second criterion, the record establishes you belong |
l******t
发帖数: 2243 | |
j*********o
发帖数: 336 | 3 try to find everything that could prove your contribution such as presention
you did before, emails from your collaborators, or ..... |
A*********r
发帖数: 8271 | 4 citations do count. Sigh. |
l******5
发帖数: 3030 | 5 only two citation? difficult |
j*********o
发帖数: 336 | 6 argue about the citation with: your papers are new and your area is not hot
and the journals are good....... |
t******o
发帖数: 149 | 7 Thank you all for insightful input, which makes me think that arguments can
still be made. BTW, my case is with TSC.
I was invited to review a journal paper and this paper cites me
independently. May I use this as evidence? |
s******t
发帖数: 3572 | 8 tough。回答方法估计还是得从满足的第四条入手。你得想想你的第四条为什么过了。
Title
is
【在 t******o 的大作中提到】
: My background:
: PhD from top US school;
: ~10 Journal papers + ~10 conference papers;
: ~20 self-citation + ~2 independent citations;
: Below is my RFE letter. Please help! Thx!
: My RFE:
: The record claims you meet criteria numbers two, four, five and six of Title
: 8 Code of Federal Regulations Part 204.5(h)(3).
: The record shows you do meet criterion number four. However, the record is
: more problematic regarding the remaining criteria.
|
A*********r
发帖数: 8271 | 9 of course.
why did that show up in google scholar？
Did you count citations use google scholar? You need to provide IO a list.
can
【在 t******o 的大作中提到】
: Thank you all for insightful input, which makes me think that arguments can
: still be made. BTW, my case is with TSC.
: I was invited to review a journal paper and this paper cites me
: independently. May I use this as evidence?
|
A*********r
发帖数: 8271 | 10 Regarding the fifth criterion, the record, particularly in the form of
reference letters, shows you have done some fine work in engineering.
However, and with all due respect, nothing in the evidence documents or
establishes you have made any truly original and major contribution to
engineering or any related field that highly influenced a significant
portion of similarly employed engineers and/or researchers. |
|
|
t******o
发帖数: 149 | 11 The paper that cited me was still under review.
【在 A*********r 的大作中提到】
: of course.
: why did that show up in google scholar？
: Did you count citations use google scholar? You need to provide IO a list.
:
: can
|
t******o
发帖数: 149 | 12 Indeed,I mainly used reference letters to support contribution.
【在 A*********r 的大作中提到】
: Regarding the fifth criterion, the record, particularly in the form of
: reference letters, shows you have done some fine work in engineering.
: However, and with all due respect, nothing in the evidence documents or
: establishes you have made any truly original and major contribution to
: engineering or any related field that highly influenced a significant
: portion of similarly employed engineers and/or researchers.
|
s******t
发帖数: 3572 | 13 that is a soft evidence. You need some hard evidences.
【在 t******o 的大作中提到】
: Indeed,I mainly used reference letters to support contribution.
|
l******5
发帖数: 3030 | 14 第四条是REVIEW， LZ并未给出背景。
【在 s******t 的大作中提到】
: tough。回答方法估计还是得从满足的第四条入手。你得想想你的第四条为什么过了。
:
: Title
: is
|
t******o
发帖数: 149 | 15 I had 20+ reviews for 10+ journals/conference. Can I use review experience
to support contribution as well?
【在 l******5 的大作中提到】
: 第四条是REVIEW， LZ并未给出背景。
|
m******M
发帖数: 136 | |
t******o
发帖数: 149 | |
k**********e
发帖数: 643 | 18 can u share with us your timeline?
Title
is
【在 t******o 的大作中提到】
: My background:
: PhD from top US school;
: ~10 Journal papers + ~10 conference papers;
: ~20 self-citation + ~2 independent citations;
: Below is my RFE letter. Please help! Thx!
: My RFE:
: The record claims you meet criteria numbers two, four, five and six of Title
: 8 Code of Federal Regulations Part 204.5(h)(3).
: The record shows you do meet criterion number four. However, the record is
: more problematic regarding the remaining criteria.
|
u****9
发帖数: 1888 | |
