d*******g
发帖数: 1265 | 1 以下是摘自Perelman的Wikipedia条目中关于庞加莱猜想验证过程的介绍。第二部分是
朱熹平的工作。我个人猜测Perelman隐退数学界的动机之一是这个事件：他觉得数学界
的人太不纯粹了。
Verification
Since 2003, Perelman's program has attracted increasing attention from the
mathematical community. In April 2003, he accepted an invitation to visit
the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Princeton University, Stony Brook
University, Columbia University and New York University, where he gave a
series of talks on his work.[18]
Three independent groups of scholars have verified that Perelman's papers
contain all the essentials for a complete proof of the geometrization
conjecture:
1. On 25 May 2006, Bruce Kleiner and John Lott, both of the University of
Michigan, posted a paper on arXiv that fills in the details of Perelman's
proof of the Geometrization conjecture.[19] John Lott said in ICM2006, "It
has taken us some time to examine Perelman's work. This is partly due to the
originality of Perelman's work and partly to the technical sophistication
of his arguments. All indications are that his arguments are correct."
2. In June 2006, the Asian Journal of Mathematics published a paper by Zhu
Xiping of Sun Yat-sen University in China and Huai-Dong Cao of Lehigh
University in Pennsylvania, giving a complete description of Perelman's
proof of the Poincaré and the geometrization conjectures. The June 2006
paper claimed: "This proof should be considered as the crowning achievement
of the Hamilton-Perelman theory of Ricci flow."[20] (Asked about the paper,
Perelman said the pair had not contributed anything original, and had simply
reworked his proof because they "did not quite understand the argument".)[
18]
In November 2006, Cao and Zhu published an erratum disclosing that they had
failed to cite properly the previous work of Kleiner and Lott published in
2003. In the same issue, the AJM editorial board issued an apology for what
it called "incautions" in the Cao–Zhu paper.[21]
On December 3, 2006, Cao and Zhu retracted the original version of their
paper, which was titled "A Complete Proof of the Poincaré and
Geometrization Conjectures — Application of the Hamilton–Perelman Theory
of the Ricci Flow"[22] and posted a revised version, renamed, more modestly,
"Hamilton–Perelman's Proof of the Poincaré Conjecture and the
Geometrization Conjecture".[23] Rather than the grand claim of the original
abstract, "we give a complete proof", suggesting the proof is by the authors
, the revised abstract states: "we give a detailed exposition of a complete
proof". The authors also removed the phrase "crowning achievement" from the
abstract.
3. In July 2006, John Morgan of Columbia University and Gang Tian of the
Massachusetts Institute of Technology posted a paper on the arXiv titled, "
Ricci Flow and the Poincaré Conjecture". In this paper, they provide a
detailed version of Perelman's proof of the Poincaré conjecture.[24] On 24
August 2006, Morgan delivered a lecture at the ICM in Madrid on the Poincar
é conjecture.[25] This was followed up with the paper on the arXiv, "
Completion of the Proof of the Geometrization Conjecture" on 24 September
2008. | s**p
发帖数: 1097 | 2 laf.他要是能成为让Perelman退隐的原因，那确实该得奖：削弱敌人就是增强我军啊
Brook
【在 d*******g 的大作中提到】
: 以下是摘自Perelman的Wikipedia条目中关于庞加莱猜想验证过程的介绍。第二部分是
: 朱熹平的工作。我个人猜测Perelman隐退数学界的动机之一是这个事件：他觉得数学界
: 的人太不纯粹了。
: Verification
: Since 2003, Perelman's program has attracted increasing attention from the
: mathematical community. In April 2003, he accepted an invitation to visit
: the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Princeton University, Stony Brook
: University, Columbia University and New York University, where he gave a
: series of talks on his work.[18]
: Three independent groups of scholars have verified that Perelman's papers
| l******r
发帖数: 18699 | 3 太丢人了，都替中山大学脸红
不过说实话，学术界这种剽窃别人credit的事情屡见不鲜，只不过没有猪草这次搞的这
么轰动而已
Brook
【在 d*******g 的大作中提到】
: 以下是摘自Perelman的Wikipedia条目中关于庞加莱猜想验证过程的介绍。第二部分是
: 朱熹平的工作。我个人猜测Perelman隐退数学界的动机之一是这个事件：他觉得数学界
: 的人太不纯粹了。
: Verification
: Since 2003, Perelman's program has attracted increasing attention from the
: mathematical community. In April 2003, he accepted an invitation to visit
: the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Princeton University, Stony Brook
: University, Columbia University and New York University, where he gave a
: series of talks on his work.[18]
: Three independent groups of scholars have verified that Perelman's papers
|
|
