v****e
发帖数: 19471 | 1 看电影毕竟不是解题, 而是文艺享受, 太费脑子就没意思了, 因为文艺感因此而受损.
所以我对摸馒头, 摸后兰这种故意把简单问题复杂化的叙事方式非常反感. 结构应该是
为艺术服务的, 而不该成为负担. | y*****2
发帖数: 863 | 2 我第一次看卖馒头还真看懂了，不过也没看第二遍
那个警察想利用其记忆缺陷，结果作茧自缚招致杀身之祸的情节还是蛮有新意的
除了故事情节，这电影还真没什么可说的，色彩单调，倒叙手法故弄玄虚 | a***a
发帖数: 40617 | 3 你不是不灌水不来了吗？
.
【在 v****e 的大作中提到】
: 看电影毕竟不是解题, 而是文艺享受, 太费脑子就没意思了, 因为文艺感因此而受损.
: 所以我对摸馒头, 摸后兰这种故意把简单问题复杂化的叙事方式非常反感. 结构应该是
: 为艺术服务的, 而不该成为负担.
| l******e
发帖数: 12192 | 4 受众不同而已
高智商的观众也需要些高智商的文艺享受，很难说是负担
.
【在 v****e 的大作中提到】
: 看电影毕竟不是解题, 而是文艺享受, 太费脑子就没意思了, 因为文艺感因此而受损.
: 所以我对摸馒头, 摸后兰这种故意把简单问题复杂化的叙事方式非常反感. 结构应该是
: 为艺术服务的, 而不该成为负担.
| v****e
发帖数: 19471 | 5 this is not LA board, is it?
【在 a***a 的大作中提到】
: 你不是不灌水不来了吗？
:
: .
| j***b
发帖数: 5901 | 6 When you need movie to show off IQ, that's not a confident position.
Also, over analyzing a movie has nothing to do with intelligence. I only care about what you can tell based on the movie itself. All else is all subjective. You may very well be simply expressing your own idea, instead of what the movie is saying.
【在 l******e 的大作中提到】
: 受众不同而已
: 高智商的观众也需要些高智商的文艺享受，很难说是负担
:
: .
| v****e
发帖数: 19471 | 7 嘿嘿, 这才是聪明人看问题的方式.
【在 j***b 的大作中提到】
: When you need movie to show off IQ, that's not a confident position.
: Also, over analyzing a movie has nothing to do with intelligence. I only care about what you can tell based on the movie itself. All else is all subjective. You may very well be simply expressing your own idea, instead of what the movie is saying.
| j***b
发帖数: 5901 | 8 The way various people trying to give various interpolation of what they
think about the movie bullet flying is trying to tell, to be honest, sounds
pretty stupid.
【在 v****e 的大作中提到】
: 嘿嘿, 这才是聪明人看问题的方式.
| v****e
发帖数: 19471 | 9 一个国家的观众争先恐后对一个本国电影的隐喻和影射做出种种猜测并形成一股持续时
间很长的潮流, 说明几点:
1. 人们有诸多的不满, 希望在文艺作品中寻找到相应的带有反讽性质的出口.
2. 这个国家的人已经很久没有直截了当地说过话了
3. 这个国家上映的电影很少, 能让人琢磨的电影更少.
sounds
【在 j***b 的大作中提到】
: The way various people trying to give various interpolation of what they
: think about the movie bullet flying is trying to tell, to be honest, sounds
: pretty stupid.
| l******e
发帖数: 12192 | 10 你为啥觉得是showoff呢？
有人就是对电影的叙述方式感兴趣不行呀
就像寻宝游戏，有人对找宝藏的过程感兴趣，有人对宝藏感兴趣。这是很正常的事。
另外，认为废脑子是楼主说的。
并不是所以人都认为废脑子。
care about what you can tell based on the movie itself. All else is all
subjective. You may very well be simply expressing your own idea, instead of
what the movie is saying.
【在 j***b 的大作中提到】
: When you need movie to show off IQ, that's not a confident position.
: Also, over analyzing a movie has nothing to do with intelligence. I only care about what you can tell based on the movie itself. All else is all subjective. You may very well be simply expressing your own idea, instead of what the movie is saying.
| | | l******e
发帖数: 12192 | 11 直接说子弹飞不就得了。
这种隐喻完全是姜文装13装出来的
sounds
【在 j***b 的大作中提到】
: The way various people trying to give various interpolation of what they
: think about the movie bullet flying is trying to tell, to be honest, sounds
: pretty stupid.
| j***b
发帖数: 5901 | 12 There had been time that I used my brain literally to the extreme. I read proofs after proofs, until my brain simply don't process it any more. That is what I call testing brain power.
For movies, I prefer simply to relax and watch. That's not saying that I wouldn't get the plot of the so called IQ movies.
And I don't take any of the "Yin Yu" shit. For me, as long as you are with the plot, you get the movie.
of
【在 l******e 的大作中提到】
: 你为啥觉得是showoff呢？
: 有人就是对电影的叙述方式感兴趣不行呀
: 就像寻宝游戏，有人对找宝藏的过程感兴趣，有人对宝藏感兴趣。这是很正常的事。
: 另外，认为废脑子是楼主说的。
: 并不是所以人都认为废脑子。
:
: care about what you can tell based on the movie itself. All else is all
: subjective. You may very well be simply expressing your own idea, instead of
: what the movie is saying.
| j***b
发帖数: 5901 | 13 Sometimes, the key to get a certain plot is not just intelligence, but
rather attention to details and good memory. While these are also aspects of
brain power, usually, in a intelligence test, you are allowed to go back
and read again, instead of relying on memory. Kind of different. | n*****r
发帖数: 1981 | 14 电影的作用就是把观众的智商拉到跟那些小学都没毕业的演员，正经文化课都不过关的
导演，唯利是图的制片一样水平。很奇怪观众看不懂一个电影先去自责自己的智商不够
，不齐怪导演拍不好，或是故意装逼。。。 | T*******x
发帖数: 8565 | 15 同意。
.
【在 v****e 的大作中提到】
: 看电影毕竟不是解题, 而是文艺享受, 太费脑子就没意思了, 因为文艺感因此而受损.
: 所以我对摸馒头, 摸后兰这种故意把简单问题复杂化的叙事方式非常反感. 结构应该是
: 为艺术服务的, 而不该成为负担.
| S*M
发帖数: 10832 | 16 拉倒吧
你喜欢一个电影就是喜欢，不喜欢就是不喜欢
扯什么“结构为艺术服务”？
艺术是个什么东西？
没事儿别装大尾巴狼
.
【在 v****e 的大作中提到】
: 看电影毕竟不是解题, 而是文艺享受, 太费脑子就没意思了, 因为文艺感因此而受损.
: 所以我对摸馒头, 摸后兰这种故意把简单问题复杂化的叙事方式非常反感. 结构应该是
: 为艺术服务的, 而不该成为负担.
|
|
