h***y
发帖数: 710 | 1 丝丝入扣动人心弦！今年最好的电影之一。
★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7 |
P*******e
发帖数: 39399 | 2 这片好听懂么？ 昆丁话痨时听起来可不轻松 呵呵
【在 h***y 的大作中提到】
: 丝丝入扣动人心弦！今年最好的电影之一。
: ★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
|
u******a
发帖数: 7843 | 3 看预告片就知道很高级...
【在 h***y 的大作中提到】
: 丝丝入扣动人心弦！今年最好的电影之一。
: ★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
|
h***y
发帖数: 710 | 4 还行。95%没问题。偶有几句口音太重得没听懂。
★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
【在 P*******e 的大作中提到】
: 这片好听懂么？ 昆丁话痨时听起来可不轻松 呵呵
|
j****e
发帖数: 12067 | 5 同赞，昆丁确实厉害，换个导演，这剧本可能会拍得很平庸像流水帐 |
w******0
发帖数: 3908 | |
e****s
发帖数: 258 | 7 刚看完，烂片一部。
影院里面的白人都是板着脸出来的。这点最有意思。
【在 h***y 的大作中提到】
: 丝丝入扣动人心弦！今年最好的电影之一。
: ★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
|
G*8
发帖数: 13261 | 8 昨晚看的，全场块坐满了。
今年看到的最好一部，从故事，表演，夸张的色彩，都太精彩了.
昆丁鬼才，他的电影从没叫我失望过，每部都要看。 |
e****s
发帖数: 258 | 9 血醒是肯定的。但故事没看出来有多精彩。
看了1／4就知道结局了吧。这部讨好黑人的片子，其实黑人并不买帐。
【在 G*8 的大作中提到】
: 昨晚看的，全场块坐满了。
: 今年看到的最好一部，从故事，表演，夸张的色彩，都太精彩了.
: 昆丁鬼才，他的电影从没叫我失望过，每部都要看。
|
e****s
发帖数: 258 | 10 There are still rational people, nevertheless.
The worst movie I've seen since 'Soul Plane', 26 December 2012
Author: Shamontiel Vaughn from United States
*** This review may contain spoilers ***
I wanted to see this movie for two reasons: 1) I am a big music and movie
fan of Jamie Foxx. 2) I wanted to know why Nate Parker turned the movie down
and seemed so disappointed in the script when he did an interview on The
Breakfast Club.
I didn't know the movie was going to be 2 hours and 45 minutes long nor did
I care. I am not a fan of Quentin Tarantino (although I like the John
Travolta parts of "Pulp Fiction") but I knew I was going to hear the n-word
a lot from watching an interview on "BET's Don't Sleep." Didn't bother me.
That's realistic terminology for that time period in slavery. I'm far more
irritated by black folks who know the history and are brainwashed enough to
think that the term has changed. I read several articles and interviews
about how Leonardo Dicaprio had a hard time using the word, but he was
playing a slaveowner. That word is a given. I'm a big fan of Samuel L.
Jackson and love quite a few Dicaprio flicks, too, so I thought, "How could
this be bad? Why didn't Nate Parker like the movie?" This turned out to be
the worst movie I've ever seen since "Soul Plane." Comedic timing: Quentin
Tarantino did a recent interview in Ebony magazine (Dec 2012) where he said,
"One of the characteristics of my work is that I make you laugh at f*****
up s***." While there were people in the audience who laughed at random
parts of the movie, I never cracked a smile. There's nothing funny to me
about the Ku Klux Klan or their rambling about whether the eye holes are too
short in their masks. The KKK is the most horrendous group in American
history (in my opinion) and trying to make light of them seemed odd to me.
Quentin Tarantino said, "I haven't liked any of the representations of
slavery that I've seen on film." Slavery isn't meant to be liked. It's meant
to be documented. You're not supposed to laugh about it or make light of it
or find some amusing cowboy entertainment. It's ugly. It's graphic. It's
heavy. And I truly couldn't give a damn about a horse being able to do the
robot.
Field slave vs house slave: Judging from the amount of lashes on Django's
back, I got the impression that he was a field slave. So why this guy who
didn't appear to spend any amount of time inside anybody's slave quarters
could speak perfect English and read and was this brown in complexion (
complexion meant a helluva lot back then) seemed odd to me. It wasn't until
he reached a bar that we started hearing broken English and him saying words
he didn't understand but his vernacular was way too crisp. Jamie Foxx said
Quentin Tarantino told him he needed to act like a slave. Django was someone
I could see strolling down the street in 2012 -- just with outdated
clothing on -- if you heard him speak.
Black man on a horse: As hard as Quakers had to hide themselves from
affiliation with the Underground Railroad and with the amount of covering up
even after the Emancipation Proclamation, racism was more harsh, more
violent and more impulsive. So how in the world this random black man could
roll through town on a horse and not be shot dead before anybody even asked
his comrade why he was there was beyond me. You know how you see action
movies and think, "This guy would be dead in three minutes if this was real
life"? That's how I felt about Django as soon as he grabbed the winter coat
and boots.
Leonardo Dicaprio and Samuel L. Jackson: These were the only two characters
in the entire film who seemed realistic. Sam Jackson's character was
definitely a house slave (and ironically enough he spoke English in a more
broken manner than this obvious field slave Django). Dicaprio wasn't kidding
when he said his character was horrible. There were moments when I flinched
at some of the stuff his character smiled about, but I was finally starting
to get into the film. Same for Sam Jackson.
Kerry Washington: I just found it odd that she went from being in a box and
splashed with water after being whipped and then walked around perfectly
straight and graceful when she was pulled back into the mansion. While I
understand why her character could speak German (she was another realistic
house slave) and even why she seemed a bit more cultured than other slaves,
I can't see someone being whipped and caged like an animal and then bopping
around a dining room like nothing happened.
Bounty hunter scenes: I get why there had to be a bounty hunter plot in
order for the relationship to make sense and the rescue-the-wife part, but
the bounty hunting scenes were so dreadfully boring. The movie didn't pick
up until it started at Dicaprio's character's plantation.
Music: Every time there was a serious scene, there was this obnoxious cowboy
music or really upbeat music that contradicted what was going on. It's like
playing a techno song in the middle of a guy getting raped in prison. The
music never matched the scene. Has Tarantino ever heard of spirituals? Pick
one.
The entire film made a mockery of slavery and should've never used that
topic. It was basically a cowboy movie with chains. And I hated it. And I'm
incredibly annoyed that I ruined part of my Christmas evening paying $8 to
see this stupid film.
【在 h***y 的大作中提到】
: 丝丝入扣动人心弦！今年最好的电影之一。
: ★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
|
|
|
H****r
发帖数: 16240 | 11 黑人买账的片子是这样的：
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-GlwowBL_bY
vhttps://www.youtube.com/v/-GlwowBL_bY
反正我是欣赏不了
还不如去看planet apes
【在 e****s 的大作中提到】
: 血醒是肯定的。但故事没看出来有多精彩。
: 看了1／4就知道结局了吧。这部讨好黑人的片子，其实黑人并不买帐。
|
H****r
发帖数: 16240 | 12 哈哈
我刚刚联想到就是soul plane！
down
did
【在 e****s 的大作中提到】
: There are still rational people, nevertheless.
: The worst movie I've seen since 'Soul Plane', 26 December 2012
: Author: Shamontiel Vaughn from United States
: *** This review may contain spoilers ***
: I wanted to see this movie for two reasons: 1) I am a big music and movie
: fan of Jamie Foxx. 2) I wanted to know why Nate Parker turned the movie down
: and seemed so disappointed in the script when he did an interview on The
: Breakfast Club.
: I didn't know the movie was going to be 2 hours and 45 minutes long nor did
: I care. I am not a fan of Quentin Tarantino (although I like the John
|
r*****n
发帖数: 3014 | 13 这样的剧本，谁也拍不出好来。。看完了只有一个感觉，江郎才尽。。回家看电视上重
播落水狗，唏嘘啊。。
★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
【在 j****e 的大作中提到】
: 同赞，昆丁确实厉害，换个导演，这剧本可能会拍得很平庸像流水帐
|
k*******y
发帖数: 798 | 14 对，剧本太弱了，以至于看到最后血肉横飞的已经不觉得过瘾，而是恶心。看完我第一
个感觉就是，昆汀可以从此走下我心中的神坛了。
这样的剧本，谁也拍不出好来。。看完了只有一个感觉，江郎才尽。。回家看电视上重
播落水狗，唏嘘啊。。
【在 r*****n 的大作中提到】
: 这样的剧本，谁也拍不出好来。。看完了只有一个感觉，江郎才尽。。回家看电视上重
: 播落水狗，唏嘘啊。。
:
: ★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
|
g**o
发帖数: 3033 | 15 跟我看法差不多，看着乱七八糟的，很多地方感觉不流畅，一些不怎么有趣的情节
硬撑着过一遍。比如那个头套吧，是要展示昆式幽默？不过实在乏味。
【在 k*******y 的大作中提到】
: 对，剧本太弱了，以至于看到最后血肉横飞的已经不觉得过瘾，而是恶心。看完我第一
: 个感觉就是，昆汀可以从此走下我心中的神坛了。
:
: 这样的剧本，谁也拍不出好来。。看完了只有一个感觉，江郎才尽。。回家看电视上重
: 播落水狗，唏嘘啊。。
|
y***1
发帖数: 787 | 16 我旁边的白人大叔确实不太开心，整个电影出去三次，看到枪战还浑身发抖，他旁边疑
似他俩儿子，一直很high地鼓掌
★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
【在 e****s 的大作中提到】
: 刚看完，烂片一部。
: 影院里面的白人都是板着脸出来的。这点最有意思。
|
h***y
发帖数: 710 | 17 看来我们的品味还真的大不同。我觉得特别好。
★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
【在 g**o 的大作中提到】
: 跟我看法差不多，看着乱七八糟的，很多地方感觉不流畅，一些不怎么有趣的情节
: 硬撑着过一遍。比如那个头套吧，是要展示昆式幽默？不过实在乏味。
|
l********1
发帖数: 5909 | 18 I like it too, only I can't understand some of the lines.
And Is this the first black cowboy ever?
【在 h***y 的大作中提到】
: 看来我们的品味还真的大不同。我觉得特别好。
:
: ★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
|
s**i
发帖数: 4448 | 19 I loved it!
The German did it again! Humorous and elegant. Fantastic!
Dicaprio did not disappoint either. His role of a cultured, pretentious
cruel villain was very successful. The scene where he sawed open a black
skull and gave a speech about dimples associated with submission of black
people was so obscene yet powerful that makes viewers so uncomfortable and
elicits strong emotion of utter disgust and fury.
Jimmy's acting is little too confident and cocky. But this is a made up
story, not a documentary. So it's forgivable. People' criticism of the
accuracy of portrait of historical slavery is off the point. This is a gory
comedy.
I knew what to expect from a Quntin movie and I am not disappointed. |
h***y
发帖数: 710 | 20 丝丝入扣动人心弦！今年最好的电影之一。
★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7 |
|
|
P*******e
发帖数: 39399 | 21 这片好听懂么？ 昆丁话痨时听起来可不轻松 呵呵
【在 h***y 的大作中提到】
: 丝丝入扣动人心弦！今年最好的电影之一。
: ★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
|
u******a
发帖数: 7843 | 22 看预告片就知道很高级...
【在 h***y 的大作中提到】
: 丝丝入扣动人心弦！今年最好的电影之一。
: ★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
|
h***y
发帖数: 710 | 23 还行。95%没问题。偶有几句口音太重得没听懂。
★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
【在 P*******e 的大作中提到】
: 这片好听懂么？ 昆丁话痨时听起来可不轻松 呵呵
|
j****e
发帖数: 12067 | 24 同赞，昆丁确实厉害，换个导演，这剧本可能会拍得很平庸像流水帐 |
w******0
发帖数: 3908 | |
e****s
发帖数: 258 | 26 刚看完，烂片一部。
影院里面的白人都是板着脸出来的。这点最有意思。
【在 h***y 的大作中提到】
: 丝丝入扣动人心弦！今年最好的电影之一。
: ★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
|
G*8
发帖数: 13261 | 27 昨晚看的，全场块坐满了。
今年看到的最好一部，从故事，表演，夸张的色彩，都太精彩了.
昆丁鬼才，他的电影从没叫我失望过，每部都要看。 |
e****s
发帖数: 258 | 28 血醒是肯定的。但故事没看出来有多精彩。
看了1／4就知道结局了吧。这部讨好黑人的片子，其实黑人并不买帐。
【在 G*8 的大作中提到】
: 昨晚看的，全场块坐满了。
: 今年看到的最好一部，从故事，表演，夸张的色彩，都太精彩了.
: 昆丁鬼才，他的电影从没叫我失望过，每部都要看。
|
e****s
发帖数: 258 | 29 There are still rational people, nevertheless.
The worst movie I've seen since 'Soul Plane', 26 December 2012
Author: Shamontiel Vaughn from United States
*** This review may contain spoilers ***
I wanted to see this movie for two reasons: 1) I am a big music and movie
fan of Jamie Foxx. 2) I wanted to know why Nate Parker turned the movie down
and seemed so disappointed in the script when he did an interview on The
Breakfast Club.
I didn't know the movie was going to be 2 hours and 45 minutes long nor did
I care. I am not a fan of Quentin Tarantino (although I like the John
Travolta parts of "Pulp Fiction") but I knew I was going to hear the n-word
a lot from watching an interview on "BET's Don't Sleep." Didn't bother me.
That's realistic terminology for that time period in slavery. I'm far more
irritated by black folks who know the history and are brainwashed enough to
think that the term has changed. I read several articles and interviews
about how Leonardo Dicaprio had a hard time using the word, but he was
playing a slaveowner. That word is a given. I'm a big fan of Samuel L.
Jackson and love quite a few Dicaprio flicks, too, so I thought, "How could
this be bad? Why didn't Nate Parker like the movie?" This turned out to be
the worst movie I've ever seen since "Soul Plane." Comedic timing: Quentin
Tarantino did a recent interview in Ebony magazine (Dec 2012) where he said,
"One of the characteristics of my work is that I make you laugh at f*****
up s***." While there were people in the audience who laughed at random
parts of the movie, I never cracked a smile. There's nothing funny to me
about the Ku Klux Klan or their rambling about whether the eye holes are too
short in their masks. The KKK is the most horrendous group in American
history (in my opinion) and trying to make light of them seemed odd to me.
Quentin Tarantino said, "I haven't liked any of the representations of
slavery that I've seen on film." Slavery isn't meant to be liked. It's meant
to be documented. You're not supposed to laugh about it or make light of it
or find some amusing cowboy entertainment. It's ugly. It's graphic. It's
heavy. And I truly couldn't give a damn about a horse being able to do the
robot.
Field slave vs house slave: Judging from the amount of lashes on Django's
back, I got the impression that he was a field slave. So why this guy who
didn't appear to spend any amount of time inside anybody's slave quarters
could speak perfect English and read and was this brown in complexion (
complexion meant a helluva lot back then) seemed odd to me. It wasn't until
he reached a bar that we started hearing broken English and him saying words
he didn't understand but his vernacular was way too crisp. Jamie Foxx said
Quentin Tarantino told him he needed to act like a slave. Django was someone
I could see strolling down the street in 2012 -- just with outdated
clothing on -- if you heard him speak.
Black man on a horse: As hard as Quakers had to hide themselves from
affiliation with the Underground Railroad and with the amount of covering up
even after the Emancipation Proclamation, racism was more harsh, more
violent and more impulsive. So how in the world this random black man could
roll through town on a horse and not be shot dead before anybody even asked
his comrade why he was there was beyond me. You know how you see action
movies and think, "This guy would be dead in three minutes if this was real
life"? That's how I felt about Django as soon as he grabbed the winter coat
and boots.
Leonardo Dicaprio and Samuel L. Jackson: These were the only two characters
in the entire film who seemed realistic. Sam Jackson's character was
definitely a house slave (and ironically enough he spoke English in a more
broken manner than this obvious field slave Django). Dicaprio wasn't kidding
when he said his character was horrible. There were moments when I flinched
at some of the stuff his character smiled about, but I was finally starting
to get into the film. Same for Sam Jackson.
Kerry Washington: I just found it odd that she went from being in a box and
splashed with water after being whipped and then walked around perfectly
straight and graceful when she was pulled back into the mansion. While I
understand why her character could speak German (she was another realistic
house slave) and even why she seemed a bit more cultured than other slaves,
I can't see someone being whipped and caged like an animal and then bopping
around a dining room like nothing happened.
Bounty hunter scenes: I get why there had to be a bounty hunter plot in
order for the relationship to make sense and the rescue-the-wife part, but
the bounty hunting scenes were so dreadfully boring. The movie didn't pick
up until it started at Dicaprio's character's plantation.
Music: Every time there was a serious scene, there was this obnoxious cowboy
music or really upbeat music that contradicted what was going on. It's like
playing a techno song in the middle of a guy getting raped in prison. The
music never matched the scene. Has Tarantino ever heard of spirituals? Pick
one.
The entire film made a mockery of slavery and should've never used that
topic. It was basically a cowboy movie with chains. And I hated it. And I'm
incredibly annoyed that I ruined part of my Christmas evening paying $8 to
see this stupid film.
【在 h***y 的大作中提到】
: 丝丝入扣动人心弦！今年最好的电影之一。
: ★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
|
H****r
发帖数: 16240 | 30 黑人买账的片子是这样的：
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-GlwowBL_bY
vhttps://www.youtube.com/v/-GlwowBL_bY
反正我是欣赏不了
还不如去看planet apes
【在 e****s 的大作中提到】
: 血醒是肯定的。但故事没看出来有多精彩。
: 看了1／4就知道结局了吧。这部讨好黑人的片子，其实黑人并不买帐。
|
|
|
H****r
发帖数: 16240 | 31 哈哈
我刚刚联想到就是soul plane！
down
did
【在 e****s 的大作中提到】
: There are still rational people, nevertheless.
: The worst movie I've seen since 'Soul Plane', 26 December 2012
: Author: Shamontiel Vaughn from United States
: *** This review may contain spoilers ***
: I wanted to see this movie for two reasons: 1) I am a big music and movie
: fan of Jamie Foxx. 2) I wanted to know why Nate Parker turned the movie down
: and seemed so disappointed in the script when he did an interview on The
: Breakfast Club.
: I didn't know the movie was going to be 2 hours and 45 minutes long nor did
: I care. I am not a fan of Quentin Tarantino (although I like the John
|
r*****n
发帖数: 3014 | 32 这样的剧本，谁也拍不出好来。。看完了只有一个感觉，江郎才尽。。回家看电视上重
播落水狗，唏嘘啊。。
★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
【在 j****e 的大作中提到】
: 同赞，昆丁确实厉害，换个导演，这剧本可能会拍得很平庸像流水帐
|
k*******y
发帖数: 798 | 33 对，剧本太弱了，以至于看到最后血肉横飞的已经不觉得过瘾，而是恶心。看完我第一
个感觉就是，昆汀可以从此走下我心中的神坛了。
这样的剧本，谁也拍不出好来。。看完了只有一个感觉，江郎才尽。。回家看电视上重
播落水狗，唏嘘啊。。
【在 r*****n 的大作中提到】
: 这样的剧本，谁也拍不出好来。。看完了只有一个感觉，江郎才尽。。回家看电视上重
: 播落水狗，唏嘘啊。。
:
: ★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
|
g**o
发帖数: 3033 | 34 跟我看法差不多，看着乱七八糟的，很多地方感觉不流畅，一些不怎么有趣的情节
硬撑着过一遍。比如那个头套吧，是要展示昆式幽默？不过实在乏味。
【在 k*******y 的大作中提到】
: 对，剧本太弱了，以至于看到最后血肉横飞的已经不觉得过瘾，而是恶心。看完我第一
: 个感觉就是，昆汀可以从此走下我心中的神坛了。
:
: 这样的剧本，谁也拍不出好来。。看完了只有一个感觉，江郎才尽。。回家看电视上重
: 播落水狗，唏嘘啊。。
|
y***1
发帖数: 787 | 35 我旁边的白人大叔确实不太开心，整个电影出去三次，看到枪战还浑身发抖，他旁边疑
似他俩儿子，一直很high地鼓掌
★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
【在 e****s 的大作中提到】
: 刚看完，烂片一部。
: 影院里面的白人都是板着脸出来的。这点最有意思。
|
h***y
发帖数: 710 | 36 看来我们的品味还真的大不同。我觉得特别好。
★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
【在 g**o 的大作中提到】
: 跟我看法差不多，看着乱七八糟的，很多地方感觉不流畅，一些不怎么有趣的情节
: 硬撑着过一遍。比如那个头套吧，是要展示昆式幽默？不过实在乏味。
|
l********1
发帖数: 5909 | 37 I like it too, only I can't understand some of the lines.
And Is this the first black cowboy ever?
【在 h***y 的大作中提到】
: 看来我们的品味还真的大不同。我觉得特别好。
:
: ★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
|
s**i
发帖数: 4448 | 38 I loved it!
The German did it again! Humorous and elegant. Fantastic!
Dicaprio did not disappoint either. His role of a cultured, pretentious
cruel villain was very successful. The scene where he sawed open a black
skull and gave a speech about dimples associated with submission of black
people was so obscene yet powerful that makes viewers so uncomfortable and
elicits strong emotion of utter disgust and fury.
Jimmy's acting is little too confident and cocky. But this is a made up
story, not a documentary. So it's forgivable. People' criticism of the
accuracy of portrait of historical slavery is off the point. This is a gory
comedy.
I knew what to expect from a Quntin movie and I am not disappointed. |
n*********e
发帖数: 25274 | 39 这片放中南部农村放,肯定要搞砸的...
那边农奴思想还根深蒂固...
【在 y***1 的大作中提到】
: 我旁边的白人大叔确实不太开心，整个电影出去三次，看到枪战还浑身发抖，他旁边疑
: 似他俩儿子，一直很high地鼓掌
:
: ★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
|
H**r
发帖数: 10015 | 40 勾起了黑人痛苦的回忆
【在 e****s 的大作中提到】
: 血醒是肯定的。但故事没看出来有多精彩。
: 看了1／4就知道结局了吧。这部讨好黑人的片子，其实黑人并不买帐。
|
|
|
s***y
发帖数: 3042 | 41 我看第二遍地时候，就跟喜欢了。的确是非常好的电影。
【在 h***y 的大作中提到】
: 丝丝入扣动人心弦！今年最好的电影之一。
: ★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
|
