由买买提看人间百态

boards

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档,一周内的贴子最多显示50字,超过一周显示500字 访问原贴
Business版 - 理科博士8年R&D经验,想带领一个科研团队,MBA是不是出路?
相关主题
我这种情况该不该考虑MBA.Wharton EMBA interview
35岁读MBA晚吗?MBA出来到底做什么?
EMBA申请求建议问: Executive MBA是一个正式的学位吗?
念MBA是学位更重要还是过程更重要关于MBA专业方向
很不明白MBA是怎么分专业的consulting里的leadership和personal impact
请问CFA到底有什么用?能找什么样的工作?CE phd 想转finance或management的master,请帮忙定位。
Re: 请有经验的DX帮助:U of IOWA MBA电话interview谢谢大家,已删!
真心请教:我该读哪种MBA?现在这个时候读MBA合适吗?
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: mba话题: do话题: phd话题: work话题: research
1 (共1页)
m***5
发帖数: 83
1
美国Ph.D., 2年日本化学大公司R&D经验,+ 6年美国Fortune 500公司scientist经验。
热爱科研,但是希望自己能够在5年内领导一个科研团队。对团队管理比较感兴趣;对
金融没有什莫爱好。
MBA是不是好的敲门砖?什莫方向比较好?
谢谢
m***5
发帖数: 83
2
Any suggestions?
w********e
发帖数: 944
3
no.
All you need is an an opportunity.
m***5
发帖数: 83
4
where is the opportunity? Will MBA bring me more opportunities?
b***y
发帖数: 215
5
Given your experience, EMBA is a better option.
m***5
发帖数: 83
6
展开说说?
b******e
发帖数: 1311
7
大部分MBA即便进公司也是走金融,marketing,或者strategy的路线。像你说的这种带
领R&D团队主要还是内部专业做上来的。不排除弄个PT锦上添花。
s*****l
发帖数: 1844
8
Why do you need a MBA since you want to lead a team to do research?? A PhD
is enough. People skills, net working, and productive research are the keys.

【在 m***5 的大作中提到】
: 美国Ph.D., 2年日本化学大公司R&D经验,+ 6年美国Fortune 500公司scientist经验。
: 热爱科研,但是希望自己能够在5年内领导一个科研团队。对团队管理比较感兴趣;对
: 金融没有什莫爱好。
: MBA是不是好的敲门砖?什莫方向比较好?
: 谢谢

m***5
发帖数: 83
9
i am certainly interested in the leadership, organization management, and
strategic planning portion of the MBA program. However, does it worth the
two years and $100,000, which I probably do something else :)
h***s
发帖数: 1716
10
你这么多年经验, 还去读什么书? 去找机会实干啊, 试着争取一个Startup, 或者你自
己公司的CTO或者类似的工作职位, 靠人脉, 机遇和你自己在这方面的能力...

【在 m***5 的大作中提到】
: i am certainly interested in the leadership, organization management, and
: strategic planning portion of the MBA program. However, does it worth the
: two years and $100,000, which I probably do something else :)

相关主题
请问CFA到底有什么用?能找什么样的工作?Wharton EMBA interview
Re: 请有经验的DX帮助:U of IOWA MBA电话interviewMBA出来到底做什么?
真心请教:我该读哪种MBA?问: Executive MBA是一个正式的学位吗?
a***r
发帖数: 2677
11
官迷+书呆子
w**a
发帖数: 4743
12
不了解纯Research部门,但以前带过两个R&D部门。个人经验是对于R&D部门,manager
的skill和MBA关系不太大,但的确有些用处。
大多数中国人当领导的问题是没有leadership
s*****l
发帖数: 1844
13
I am confused. Aren't you saying that you want to lead a team to do
research? Managers, directors, VPs, do not really do research. Most of them
do management work. What exactly do you want? My personal opinion is that
if you can not learn leadership skills during your work, you can not learn
from MBA program either.

【在 m***5 的大作中提到】
: i am certainly interested in the leadership, organization management, and
: strategic planning portion of the MBA program. However, does it worth the
: two years and $100,000, which I probably do something else :)

m***5
发帖数: 83
14
I think I am certainly enjoying the involvement of R&D work, not necessary
bench work though. Project management is another one that intrigues me. In
my current company, I don't have opportunity to be a manager. In order for
me to be a R&D manager, an "easier" way may just be spending two years for a
part time (professional or executive) MBA, then start somewhere else?
Again, I would like to focus on organization management, strategic planning
and leadership development.
If you think there is obvious reason that I should not pursue MBA, please
let me know.
Thanks.
f********m
发帖数: 8397
15
肯定是有用的,但是值不值就不好说了。关键在于项目管理,人力资源和科学上的造诣
。如果有那种short course其实最好

【在 m***5 的大作中提到】
: 美国Ph.D., 2年日本化学大公司R&D经验,+ 6年美国Fortune 500公司scientist经验。
: 热爱科研,但是希望自己能够在5年内领导一个科研团队。对团队管理比较感兴趣;对
: 金融没有什莫爱好。
: MBA是不是好的敲门砖?什莫方向比较好?
: 谢谢

s*****l
发帖数: 1844
16
Of course I do not mean that you need to do bench work. People who Lead a R
&D group seldom do bench work. But to lead a research oriented group, in my
personal opinion, MBA is not needed, and does not help much. Many white
people, often w/o PhD, can still become managers. Becoming a manager
depends on your leadership skills in daily work. I do not think a MBA will
help much if you want to lead a research team. MBA training is usually for
operation/business/outsourcing etc.
Think about this scenario, you, PhD+MBA, an american PhD who enjoys good
relationship in the company, do you think you are more likely to become a
manager for a research oriented team? My opinion is no. I have seen many
Chinese with top school PhD, and PT MBA, doing bench work, while ordinary
white people become managers. It is discrimination, to say it in an ugly
way; it is culture/language difference, to say it in a nice way. No matter
what, if you do a statistical analysis on people with same education
background, with the nationality as variable, you will see a clear
difference. If you are still in a R&D team, many people do not care whether
you have a MBA or not. You will not get a promotion simply by getting a PT
MBA. Usually after one gets a MBA, he(she) transfers to Strategy/Business
Development/Corporate finance departments.

In
for
a
planning

【在 m***5 的大作中提到】
: I think I am certainly enjoying the involvement of R&D work, not necessary
: bench work though. Project management is another one that intrigues me. In
: my current company, I don't have opportunity to be a manager. In order for
: me to be a R&D manager, an "easier" way may just be spending two years for a
: part time (professional or executive) MBA, then start somewhere else?
: Again, I would like to focus on organization management, strategic planning
: and leadership development.
: If you think there is obvious reason that I should not pursue MBA, please
: let me know.
: Thanks.

s*******h
发帖数: 3731
17
那大牛给我们这些R&D的苦逼指条明路吧。。。

R
my
will
for

【在 s*****l 的大作中提到】
: Of course I do not mean that you need to do bench work. People who Lead a R
: &D group seldom do bench work. But to lead a research oriented group, in my
: personal opinion, MBA is not needed, and does not help much. Many white
: people, often w/o PhD, can still become managers. Becoming a manager
: depends on your leadership skills in daily work. I do not think a MBA will
: help much if you want to lead a research team. MBA training is usually for
: operation/business/outsourcing etc.
: Think about this scenario, you, PhD+MBA, an american PhD who enjoys good
: relationship in the company, do you think you are more likely to become a
: manager for a research oriented team? My opinion is no. I have seen many

m***5
发帖数: 83
18
R&D的出路在哪里?总不能一辈子都做实验吧?高人指点下?
c******m
发帖数: 884
19
如果肯去小公司,当director的可能性就会增加很多。大公司升职很难吧。

【在 m***5 的大作中提到】
: R&D的出路在哪里?总不能一辈子都做实验吧?高人指点下?
s*****l
发帖数: 1844
20
I would recommend to interact more with successful ppl in ur area. It's not
easy, and that's why many Chinese here r doing bench work.

【在 m***5 的大作中提到】
: R&D的出路在哪里?总不能一辈子都做实验吧?高人指点下?
1 (共1页)
相关主题
现在这个时候读MBA合适吗?很不明白MBA是怎么分专业的
MBA方向求教(Industrial Management?)请问CFA到底有什么用?能找什么样的工作?
工业工程博士毕业,三年公司工作经验,读MBA合适吗?Re: 请有经验的DX帮助:U of IOWA MBA电话interview
读business school的phd中途drop out, 学校发的是MBA的证书吗?真心请教:我该读哪种MBA?
我这种情况该不该考虑MBA.Wharton EMBA interview
35岁读MBA晚吗?MBA出来到底做什么?
EMBA申请求建议问: Executive MBA是一个正式的学位吗?
念MBA是学位更重要还是过程更重要关于MBA专业方向
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: mba话题: do话题: phd话题: work话题: research