S*********r
发帖数: 4729 | 1 好伤心啊。。。有个家伙居然给了我们个definitely reject，真是没天理。
今年的iccv大家都很harsh好像。不知道这里有没有人也投了？ |
T**********n
发帖数: 480 | 2 今年还不错吧，清华都种了一个半了
【在 S*********r 的大作中提到】
: 好伤心啊。。。有个家伙居然给了我们个definitely reject，真是没天理。
: 今年的iccv大家都很harsh好像。不知道这里有没有人也投了？
|
S*********r
发帖数: 4729 | 3 ？你怎么知道的？
今天review结果才出来，都还没给acceptance通知。你说的是cvpr吧。
【在 T**********n 的大作中提到】
: 今年还不错吧，清华都种了一个半了
|
e******y
发帖数: 15 | 4 overall rating 远比各项均分低多了。
【在 S*********r 的大作中提到】
: 好伤心啊。。。有个家伙居然给了我们个definitely reject，真是没天理。
: 今年的iccv大家都很harsh好像。不知道这里有没有人也投了？
|
S*********r
发帖数: 4729 | 5 我们组今年审了16篇，最高的给了borderline。
我们组自己投了6篇，最高的是1 3 4，
其他的都和我的差不多，我的是2 3 5，估计是没戏了。
今年大家都很狠啊。
【在 e******y 的大作中提到】
: overall rating 远比各项均分低多了。
|
e******y
发帖数: 15 | 6 OMG,你们组很strong啊，估计是这个领域挺有名的啊。
【在 S*********r 的大作中提到】
: 我们组今年审了16篇，最高的给了borderline。
: 我们组自己投了6篇，最高的是1 3 4，
: 其他的都和我的差不多，我的是2 3 5，估计是没戏了。
: 今年大家都很狠啊。
|
S*********r
发帖数: 4729 | 7 我们组一般，不算有名。每年平均2－3篇cvpr,或者iccv还是有的。
【在 e******y 的大作中提到】
: OMG,你们组很strong啊，估计是这个领域挺有名的啊。
|
e******y
发帖数: 15 | 8 一般情况下什么样的review能被接受，比如今年这个情况。
【在 S*********r 的大作中提到】
: 我们组一般，不算有名。每年平均2－3篇cvpr,或者iccv还是有的。
|
T**********n
发帖数: 480 | 9 我说的是ICCV呀
一片123肯定中了吧
还有一片224可以算中了一半么？
【在 S*********r 的大作中提到】
: 我们组一般，不算有名。每年平均2－3篇cvpr,或者iccv还是有的。
|
T**********n
发帖数: 480 | 10 你们组哪里啊?
vision越来越hard了
做监控倒是能拿到钱，可惜发不了paper
【在 S*********r 的大作中提到】
: 我们组一般，不算有名。每年平均2－3篇cvpr,或者iccv还是有的。
|
|
|
p*********e
发帖数: 48 | 11 我的是2,4,4,是不是也没戏了？
【在 S*********r 的大作中提到】
: 我们组一般，不算有名。每年平均2－3篇cvpr,或者iccv还是有的。
|
S*********r
发帖数: 4729 | 12 呵呵，你也投了啊？
【在 p*********e 的大作中提到】
: 我的是2,4,4,是不是也没戏了？
|
p*********e
发帖数: 48 | 13 是啊，把我CVPR文章的余热贡献出来。因为是“余热”，所以两个给4的reviewers说不够
novel，只是我先前的工作的改进。你们组的review那么狠，不会是落在你们手里吧？
【在 S*********r 的大作中提到】
: 呵呵，你也投了啊？
|
k*********t
发帖数: 2999 | 14 too many people are submitting papers.
for example, someone in this bbs gotmore than 1 paper in cvpr and still had
papers sent to iccv... Somehow I cannot believe that one can have so many
decent work at once. so...
【在 T**********n 的大作中提到】
: 你们组哪里啊?
: vision越来越hard了
: 做监控倒是能拿到钱，可惜发不了paper
|
k*********t
发帖数: 2999 | 15 sorry to say that. but there are already too many “余热” papers in vision
conferences. and in so a short time...
够
。
【在 p*********e 的大作中提到】
: 是啊，把我CVPR文章的余热贡献出来。因为是“余热”，所以两个给4的reviewers说不够
: novel，只是我先前的工作的改进。你们组的review那么狠，不会是落在你们手里吧？
|
e******y
发帖数: 15 | 16 do you know a big bull water N papers in this year's CVPR, (N>4), and
still have M submissions to this year's ICCV.
Can not understand, most time is spent in writing papers.
Maybe bull is different to normal human.
【在 k*********t 的大作中提到】
: too many people are submitting papers.
: for example, someone in this bbs gotmore than 1 paper in cvpr and still had
: papers sent to iccv... Somehow I cannot believe that one can have so many
: decent work at once. so...
|
p*********e
发帖数: 48 | 17 Mr. Anger 生气了,后果很严重啊,我怕.
不
？
理
【在 k*********t 的大作中提到】
: sorry to say that. but there are already too many “余热” papers in vision
: conferences. and in so a short time...
:
: 够
: 。
|
S*********r
发帖数: 4729 | 18 I totally agree with you, it is sometimes unusual or should be considered
bad to publish paper in a rush. I don't believe those people who can make so
many papers at a single year. For instance, last year, one HongKong prof had 7
paper in CVPR, and 3 are oral. Every paper has only two authors, by him and
his student. I don't know how they can make this happen. Just writing 7 papers
can take 2 months.
【在 k*********t 的大作中提到】
: too many people are submitting papers.
: for example, someone in this bbs gotmore than 1 paper in cvpr and still had
: papers sent to iccv... Somehow I cannot believe that one can have so many
: decent work at once. so...
|
p*********e
发帖数: 48 | 19 我也注意到了，有四篇CVPR，他还是国内的。如果不是灌水，我们应该为同胞感到自豪啊
。先别生气哦。有机会到CVPR去跟他切磋切磋，看看到底牛不牛。本人从最严肃的纯理科
专业转到engineering,确实看到绝大多数的engineering文章是水货（可能我的眼光高点
）
。对以利益驱动的engineer们的怀疑是绝对应该的。
had
【在 e******y 的大作中提到】
: do you know a big bull water N papers in this year's CVPR, (N>4), and
: still have M submissions to this year's ICCV.
: Can not understand, most time is spent in writing papers.
: Maybe bull is different to normal human.
|
e******y
发帖数: 15 | 20 right. I once read some papers from bulls in this area, one of which is
a assistant prof. in a fairly good univ. But I have to say some of his papers
are only qulified to be pulish as one conference paper and one journal paper.
But he published fairly too many on top conferences and journals on the same
topic, exactly a kind of watering.
【在 p*********e 的大作中提到】
: 我也注意到了，有四篇CVPR，他还是国内的。如果不是灌水，我们应该为同胞感到自豪啊
: 。先别生气哦。有机会到CVPR去跟他切磋切磋，看看到底牛不牛。本人从最严肃的纯理科
: 专业转到engineering,确实看到绝大多数的engineering文章是水货（可能我的眼光高点
: ）
: 。对以利益驱动的engineer们的怀疑是绝对应该的。
:
: had
|
|
|
T**********n
发帖数: 480 | 21 说句丧气的
我觉得VISION本身基本上都是余热。。。
有价值的可解的问题基本上都在70年代被扫荡光了
现在剩下的都是硬骨头，而且找不到真正有用的application
缈茫呀
【在 k*********t 的大作中提到】
: sorry to say that. but there are already too many “余热” papers in vision
: conferences. and in so a short time...
:
: 够
: 。
|
T**********n
发帖数: 480 | 22 CVPR是人家的山头吧
也无可厚非，这个圈子也不是很大，基本上看个题目就知道是哪里的作品了
不过7篇也得算是人品相当不错了，呵呵
【在 S*********r 的大作中提到】
: I totally agree with you, it is sometimes unusual or should be considered
: bad to publish paper in a rush. I don't believe those people who can make so
: many papers at a single year. For instance, last year, one HongKong prof had 7
: paper in CVPR, and 3 are oral. Every paper has only two authors, by him and
: his student. I don't know how they can make this happen. Just writing 7 papers
: can take 2 months.
:
|
p*******e
发帖数: 40 | 23 大部分research还不都是小打小闹, 东敲西补
值得开辟的领域也很难留到现在了, 尤其是eecs
【在 T**********n 的大作中提到】
: 说句丧气的
: 我觉得VISION本身基本上都是余热。。。
: 有价值的可解的问题基本上都在70年代被扫荡光了
: 现在剩下的都是硬骨头，而且找不到真正有用的application
: 缈茫呀
|
T**********n
发帖数: 480 | 24 engineer难道不应该利益趋动么？
【在 p*********e 的大作中提到】
: 我也注意到了，有四篇CVPR，他还是国内的。如果不是灌水，我们应该为同胞感到自豪啊
: 。先别生气哦。有机会到CVPR去跟他切磋切磋，看看到底牛不牛。本人从最严肃的纯理科
: 专业转到engineering,确实看到绝大多数的engineering文章是水货（可能我的眼光高点
: ）
: 。对以利益驱动的engineer们的怀疑是绝对应该的。
:
: had
|
T**********n
发帖数: 480 | 25 这倒是亚，所以我从来不藐视做application作engineer的，呵呵
【在 p*******e 的大作中提到】
: 大部分research还不都是小打小闹, 东敲西补
: 值得开辟的领域也很难留到现在了, 尤其是eecs
|
k*********t
发帖数: 2999 | 26
That is right. He has lots of buddies in this small society.
Politics is very important in academia. Having a good network is also a kind
of ability.
considered
so
had 7
and
papers
had
many
【在 T**********n 的大作中提到】
: CVPR是人家的山头吧
: 也无可厚非，这个圈子也不是很大，基本上看个题目就知道是哪里的作品了
: 不过7篇也得算是人品相当不错了，呵呵
|
k*********t
发帖数: 2999 | 27 hehe. I was not angry at all. I myself published
“余热” papers too. just not so efficient.
vision
是啊，把我CVPR文章的余热贡献出来。因为是“余热”，所以两个给4的reviewers说
吧
天
【在 p*********e 的大作中提到】
: Mr. Anger 生气了,后果很严重啊,我怕.
:
: 不
: ？
: 理
|
k*********t
发帖数: 2999 | 28 The problem is that too many people have entered such an area with only 硬骨头
...
vision
是啊，把我CVPR文章的余热贡献出来。因为是“余热”，所以两个给4的reviewers说不
吧？
【在 T**********n 的大作中提到】
: 说句丧气的
: 我觉得VISION本身基本上都是余热。。。
: 有价值的可解的问题基本上都在70年代被扫荡光了
: 现在剩下的都是硬骨头，而且找不到真正有用的application
: 缈茫呀
|
k*********t
发帖数: 2999 | 29 that is right. It seems bioinfomatics and network security are still very hot.
vision
【在 p*******e 的大作中提到】
: 大部分research还不都是小打小闹, 东敲西补
: 值得开辟的领域也很难留到现在了, 尤其是eecs
|
k*********t
发帖数: 2999 | 30 I think I know who you are referring to. The weird thing is that he got
several orals for almost the same techniques. But sometimes we have to agree
that some people are really good at writing papers. Good networking is also
important.
papers
paper.
豪啊
科专
点）
【在 e******y 的大作中提到】
: right. I once read some papers from bulls in this area, one of which is
: a assistant prof. in a fairly good univ. But I have to say some of his papers
: are only qulified to be pulish as one conference paper and one journal paper.
: But he published fairly too many on top conferences and journals on the same
: topic, exactly a kind of watering.
|
|
|
k*********t
发帖数: 2999 | 31 A Chinese folk got 5 in CVPR 2005 (submitted more. 2 or so orals) and
submitted another 5 or so to ICCV. He is not even an assistant professor. He
must be really good to finish so many in a year. Very impressive.
啊
科
点
many
【在 p*********e 的大作中提到】
: 我也注意到了，有四篇CVPR，他还是国内的。如果不是灌水，我们应该为同胞感到自豪啊
: 。先别生气哦。有机会到CVPR去跟他切磋切磋，看看到底牛不牛。本人从最严肃的纯理科
: 专业转到engineering,确实看到绝大多数的engineering文章是水货（可能我的眼光高点
: ）
: 。对以利益驱动的engineer们的怀疑是绝对应该的。
:
: had
|
p*********e
发帖数: 48 | 32 How do you know this information about other people's ICCV papers?
豪
理
高
still
【在 k*********t 的大作中提到】
: A Chinese folk got 5 in CVPR 2005 (submitted more. 2 or so orals) and
: submitted another 5 or so to ICCV. He is not even an assistant professor. He
: must be really good to finish so many in a year. Very impressive.
:
: 啊
: 科
: 点
: many
|
k*********t
发帖数: 2999 | 33 from someone's showoff. :-)
He
自
纯
光
【在 p*********e 的大作中提到】
: How do you know this information about other people's ICCV papers?
:
: 豪
: 理
: 高
: still
|
r**t
发帖数: 937 | 34 道理很简单，学生多，好学生多，老板的paper就多。大牛学生一年贡献两篇CVPR，
小牛学生一篇，如果手下有那么四五个，嘿嘿.......
【在 S*********r 的大作中提到】
: I totally agree with you, it is sometimes unusual or should be considered
: bad to publish paper in a rush. I don't believe those people who can make so
: many papers at a single year. For instance, last year, one HongKong prof had 7
: paper in CVPR, and 3 are oral. Every paper has only two authors, by him and
: his student. I don't know how they can make this happen. Just writing 7 papers
: can take 2 months.
:
|
r**t
发帖数: 937 | 35 bioinformatics很热，一方面做的人少，一方面做生物的人和做计算机的人互相都
不精通，能把对方的领域懂一点点就能做bioinformatics的小牛了。不过现在扑上
来的人也不少了，包括做统计的，这么下去迟早又是一个泡沫。
网络安全外国人很难做，没办法的事～～
【在 k*********t 的大作中提到】
: that is right. It seems bioinfomatics and network security are still very hot.
:
: vision
|
l**l
发帖数: 860 | 36 大牛学生除了每年两片cvpr 是不是顺带还噼里啪啦的写一些其他文章?
(非一稿多投)
【在 r**t 的大作中提到】
: 道理很简单，学生多，好学生多，老板的paper就多。大牛学生一年贡献两篇CVPR，
: 小牛学生一篇，如果手下有那么四五个，嘿嘿.......
|
k*********t
发帖数: 2999 | 37 how about a bull student publishing 5 papers at once.
considered
so
had 7
and
papers
had
many
【在 r**t 的大作中提到】
: 道理很简单，学生多，好学生多，老板的paper就多。大牛学生一年贡献两篇CVPR，
: 小牛学生一篇，如果手下有那么四五个，嘿嘿.......
|
X*****r
发帖数: 2521 | 38 Oh,I can too.
But 5 pages
【在 k*********t 的大作中提到】
: how about a bull student publishing 5 papers at once.
:
: considered
: so
: had 7
: and
: papers
: had
: many
|
k*********t
发帖数: 2999 | 39 "publishing" in cvpr/iccv ...
，
【在 X*****r 的大作中提到】
: Oh,I can too.
: But 5 pages
|
X*****r
发帖数: 2521 | 40 I am only publish on Joke Board
【在 k*********t 的大作中提到】
: "publishing" in cvpr/iccv ...
:
: ，
|
|
|
k*********t
发帖数: 2999 | 41 sounds good.
【在 X*****r 的大作中提到】
: I am only publish on Joke Board
|
h******u
发帖数: 1 | 42
I got a review of 1,3,4, what's the chance of it being accepted by ICCV?
【在 e******y 的大作中提到】
: 一般情况下什么样的review能被接受，比如今年这个情况。
|
r**t
发帖数: 937 | 43 probably most vision papers are junks
ppl are waiting for a break through |
m*******y
发帖数: 48 | 44 客气点说你是mean，不客气点说你是无知无畏，
有本事你也灌7篇junk到CVPR！包括三个oral。 |
e******y
发帖数: 15 | 45 我也听说这几个paper比较一般般，颇有灌水之嫌，oral的哪几片好像反响也一般，
当然对普通人已经够牛了，对牛人要高要求。
【在 m*******y 的大作中提到】
: 客气点说你是mean，不客气点说你是无知无畏，
: 有本事你也灌7篇junk到CVPR！包括三个oral。
|
m*******y
发帖数: 48 | 46 说实话这几年CVPR ICCV出了多少真正好的paper？大家水平都差不多。
大家都是在灌水而已，看人家灌得多了就出来jjww，有这功夫自己也灌去呀。
【在 e******y 的大作中提到】
: 我也听说这几个paper比较一般般，颇有灌水之嫌，oral的哪几片好像反响也一般，
: 当然对普通人已经够牛了，对牛人要高要求。
|
e******y
发帖数: 15 | 47 //cft, 不要激动，即便都是水，也有纯净水和矿泉水的分别。
俺不懂，瞎说瞎说。
【在 m*******y 的大作中提到】
: 说实话这几年CVPR ICCV出了多少真正好的paper？大家水平都差不多。
: 大家都是在灌水而已，看人家灌得多了就出来jjww，有这功夫自己也灌去呀。
|
m*******y
发帖数: 48 | 48 vision这个行当现在停滞不前，除非谁做点划时代的成果出来，或者从别的地方来
点崭新的应用需求，要不大家就这么不死不活地挖点边角余料过活吧。
【在 e******y 的大作中提到】
: //cft, 不要激动，即便都是水，也有纯净水和矿泉水的分别。
: 俺不懂，瞎说瞎说。
|
x***j
发帖数: 109 | 49 people have different styles. some like watering a lot and making things
appear working. the others like working on real things. nothing wrong on both
sides. just different focuses on research.
considered
make so
had
and
【在 m*******y 的大作中提到】
: 客气点说你是mean，不客气点说你是无知无畏，
: 有本事你也灌7篇junk到CVPR！包括三个oral。
|
s*****s
发帖数: 27 | 50 this group will have more than 5 papers in cvpr+iccv this year again.
some of them are oral.
you can not simply say they are rubbish, what I know is that the students
in that group are really smart guys, they are not at usa only because
they do not have taken English exam like toefl and gre or do not have
very good gpa (but good gpa is not closely related with his research ability as
I see).
【在 e******y 的大作中提到】
: 我也听说这几个paper比较一般般，颇有灌水之嫌，oral的哪几片好像反响也一般，
: 当然对普通人已经够牛了，对牛人要高要求。
|
|
|
s*****s
发帖数: 27 | 51 several of the group members have won prize in the Math Modelling Contest.
【在 s*****s 的大作中提到】
: this group will have more than 5 papers in cvpr+iccv this year again.
: some of them are oral.
: you can not simply say they are rubbish, what I know is that the students
: in that group are really smart guys, they are not at usa only because
: they do not have taken English exam like toefl and gre or do not have
: very good gpa (but good gpa is not closely related with his research ability as
: I see).
|
x***j
发帖数: 109 | 52 It is fairly reasonable for a group of students to publish 5 or 7 papers. If
one student publishes 5 papers at once, it is a little superising.
as
【在 s*****s 的大作中提到】
: this group will have more than 5 papers in cvpr+iccv this year again.
: some of them are oral.
: you can not simply say they are rubbish, what I know is that the students
: in that group are really smart guys, they are not at usa only because
: they do not have taken English exam like toefl and gre or do not have
: very good gpa (but good gpa is not closely related with his research ability as
: I see).
|
m*******y
发帖数: 48 | 53 for ICCV, one negative review is enough to kill a paper. in this way, th
e guy needs to satisfy 15 reviewers to bring in 5 papers. i have to say
that IS very good job. or, maybe some of his papers are assigned to same
reviewer, which makes things even harder!
【在 x***j 的大作中提到】
: It is fairly reasonable for a group of students to publish 5 or 7 papers. If
: one student publishes 5 papers at once, it is a little superising.
:
: as
|
S*********r
发帖数: 4729 | 54 That guy is from my university, our alumni.
ability as
，
【在 s*****s 的大作中提到】
: several of the group members have won prize in the Math Modelling Contest.
|
x***j
发帖数: 109 | 55 It is superisingly good to publish so many papers in ICCV at once, especially
for a student. Many people I know cannot get even one ICCV paper after several
trials. Of course bad luck was also one of the reasons.
If
students
ability
【在 m*******y 的大作中提到】
: for ICCV, one negative review is enough to kill a paper. in this way, th
: e guy needs to satisfy 15 reviewers to bring in 5 papers. i have to say
: that IS very good job. or, maybe some of his papers are assigned to same
: reviewer, which makes things even harder!
|
T**********n
发帖数: 480 | 56 不能这样啊
不能啊不能
哀哀哀
【在 m*******y 的大作中提到】
: vision这个行当现在停滞不前，除非谁做点划时代的成果出来，或者从别的地方来
: 点崭新的应用需求，要不大家就这么不死不活地挖点边角余料过活吧。
|
T**********n
发帖数: 480 | 57 这个说起来就搞笑了。。。
参加过MCM的人都知道那是什么货色吧，赫赫
【在 s*****s 的大作中提到】
: several of the group members have won prize in the Math Modelling Contest.
|
i*****s
发帖数: 26 | 58 我的是124.
4的说我该写字的地方用了公式，不好读，给了一个3，另外实验项是3,这两项另外两个
审稿人都给的1。
就像前面有兄弟说的，iccv有一个negative的评价都可能据。我现在还是挺担心的。
【在 T**********n 的大作中提到】
: 我说的是ICCV呀
: 一片123肯定中了吧
: 还有一片224可以算中了一半么？
|
T**********n
发帖数: 480 | 59 感觉好像就是高考考了一个上吊分，也不知道到底会不会被录取，哈哈
我觉得124很好了，应该能中，赫赫
【在 i*****s 的大作中提到】
: 我的是124.
: 4的说我该写字的地方用了公式，不好读，给了一个3，另外实验项是3,这两项另外两个
: 审稿人都给的1。
: 就像前面有兄弟说的，iccv有一个negative的评价都可能据。我现在还是挺担心的。
|
i*****s
发帖数: 26 | 60 真希望你是Chair啊......
【在 T**********n 的大作中提到】
: 感觉好像就是高考考了一个上吊分，也不知道到底会不会被录取，哈哈
: 我觉得124很好了，应该能中，赫赫
|
|
|
v******d
发帖数: 1322 | 61 how abt 225? no hope
【在 T**********n 的大作中提到】
: 感觉好像就是高考考了一个上吊分，也不知道到底会不会被录取，哈哈
: 我觉得124很好了，应该能中，赫赫
|
r**t
发帖数: 937 | 62 5 means worst right?
that guy is so BT!
【在 v******d 的大作中提到】
: how abt 225? no hope
|
O******Y
发帖数: 88 | 63 There are lots of BT reviews for vision conferences...
For the same paper, the review comments are often opposite.
【在 r**t 的大作中提到】
: 5 means worst right?
: that guy is so BT!
|
v******d
发帖数: 1322 | 64 this seems often happen in all areas...
【在 O******Y 的大作中提到】
: There are lots of BT reviews for vision conferences...
: For the same paper, the review comments are often opposite.
|
r**t
发帖数: 937 | 65 area chairs always know who the reviewers are.
they know how to choose.
but, for conferences such as ICCV or CVPR, one slightly negative review
is enough to kill a paper, if the negative comments really make sense to
the chair. however, sometimes a ridiculous negative comment still gives
the chair an excuse to kill your paper :(
life is really tough !! |
v******d
发帖数: 1322 | |
v******d
发帖数: 1322 | 67 only the paper pushed by someone would be brought for discussion.
if no one push your paper, a weak negative review can surely kill
the paper.
【在 r**t 的大作中提到】
: area chairs always know who the reviewers are.
: they know how to choose.
: but, for conferences such as ICCV or CVPR, one slightly negative review
: is enough to kill a paper, if the negative comments really make sense to
: the chair. however, sometimes a ridiculous negative comment still gives
: the chair an excuse to kill your paper :(
: life is really tough !!
|
p*****s
发帖数: 8 | 68 那象2,3,3这种分数呢?
倒是没有一个人说probably reject , 一个给3的说clearance方面英文太差,让他读的费
劲, 其他方面都给的1, 2.
另一个给3的也没有狠批,就觉得文章创新性还不是非常的强,其他也还好.
所以的reviewer都觉得实验很好, 全是1, 2.
哪位给分析分析?
【在 v******d 的大作中提到】
: only the paper pushed by someone would be brought for discussion.
: if no one push your paper, a weak negative review can surely kill
: the paper.
|
a***r
发帖数: 35 | 69 你的昵称。。ft 真e
【在 S*********r 的大作中提到】
: That guy is from my university, our alumni.
:
: ability as
: ，
|
O******Y
发帖数: 88 | 70 Very possibly a poster. congrats!
费
【在 p*****s 的大作中提到】
: 那象2,3,3这种分数呢?
: 倒是没有一个人说probably reject , 一个给3的说clearance方面英文太差,让他读的费
: 劲, 其他方面都给的1, 2.
: 另一个给3的也没有狠批,就觉得文章创新性还不是非常的强,其他也还好.
: 所以的reviewer都觉得实验很好, 全是1, 2.
: 哪位给分析分析?
|
|
|
p*****s
发帖数: 8 | 71 可是,reviewer 3说我的创新不行,说incremental, 这不是很negative么?
按照前面兄弟们的贴子, 这应该算negative point了吧.
的
review
to
gives
confident.
【在 O******Y 的大作中提到】
: Very possibly a poster. congrats!
:
: 费
|
T**********n
发帖数: 480 | 72 poster不会那么严吧
不过话又说回来，poster也就算是让老板掏注册费的一个理由，赫赫
【在 p*****s 的大作中提到】
: 可是,reviewer 3说我的创新不行,说incremental, 这不是很negative么?
: 按照前面兄弟们的贴子, 这应该算negative point了吧.
:
: 的
: review
: to
: gives
: confident.
|
O******Y
发帖数: 88 | 73 There is very little difference between a poster and an oral in your resume.
【在 T**********n 的大作中提到】
: poster不会那么严吧
: 不过话又说回来，poster也就算是让老板掏注册费的一个理由，赫赫
|
O******Y
发帖数: 88 | 74 He gave a "3". Then it was not very negative. You should be fine, unless your
paper is in a very competitive topic.
读
sense
【在 p*****s 的大作中提到】
: 可是,reviewer 3说我的创新不行,说incremental, 这不是很negative么?
: 按照前面兄弟们的贴子, 这应该算negative point了吧.
:
: 的
: review
: to
: gives
: confident.
|
e******y
发帖数: 15 | 75 今年ICCV尤其难,前面有人说submission 1500多, 所以...
【在 O******Y 的大作中提到】
: He gave a "3". Then it was not very negative. You should be fine, unless your
: paper is in a very competitive topic.
:
: 读
: sense
|
p*****s
发帖数: 8 | 76 我也不知道我们是不是very competitive topic, 你说的是recognition这种领域? 那倒
不是.
今天我们实验室的博士后说, 233还不如224, 说只有50%的可能性, :(
发现现在大家意见很不统一的说.
rebuttal基本写完了,就等老板润色寄走了.
reviewer 2 也很郁闷, 他其他的分都给的不错, 全是1,2,就是clearance给了个3,说英语
读得费劲, 一堆语病,然后居然根据这个给了个overall的3, 这是怎么回事呢?
your
他
【在 O******Y 的大作中提到】
: He gave a "3". Then it was not very negative. You should be fine, unless your
: paper is in a very competitive topic.
:
: 读
: sense
|
e******y
发帖数: 15 | 77 有的reviewer很不nice,
有的area里面的人都不nice,互相杀paper,特别狠,这样的area基本都是那种funding特
难找的,生怕别人搞出牛东西影响自己.
【在 p*****s 的大作中提到】
: 我也不知道我们是不是very competitive topic, 你说的是recognition这种领域? 那倒
: 不是.
: 今天我们实验室的博士后说, 233还不如224, 说只有50%的可能性, :(
: 发现现在大家意见很不统一的说.
: rebuttal基本写完了,就等老板润色寄走了.
: reviewer 2 也很郁闷, 他其他的分都给的不错, 全是1,2,就是clearance给了个3,说英语
: 读得费劲, 一堆语病,然后居然根据这个给了个overall的3, 这是怎么回事呢?
:
: your
: 他
|
r*****y
发帖数: 507 | 78 according to majority voting, I feel 233 is worse than 224, 125, or even 225.
【在 p*****s 的大作中提到】
: 我也不知道我们是不是very competitive topic, 你说的是recognition这种领域? 那倒
: 不是.
: 今天我们实验室的博士后说, 233还不如224, 说只有50%的可能性, :(
: 发现现在大家意见很不统一的说.
: rebuttal基本写完了,就等老板润色寄走了.
: reviewer 2 也很郁闷, 他其他的分都给的不错, 全是1,2,就是clearance给了个3,说英语
: 读得费劲, 一堆语病,然后居然根据这个给了个overall的3, 这是怎么回事呢?
:
: your
: 他
|
O******Y
发帖数: 88 | 79 The submission number is big. But most of them got pretty low scores though.
As we know, people would not like to show the scores if they are very low.
your
【在 e******y 的大作中提到】
: 今年ICCV尤其难,前面有人说submission 1500多, 所以...
|
T**********n
发帖数: 480 | 80 这是哪个area啊？举个例子？赫赫
【在 e******y 的大作中提到】
: 有的reviewer很不nice,
: 有的area里面的人都不nice,互相杀paper,特别狠,这样的area基本都是那种funding特
: 难找的,生怕别人搞出牛东西影响自己.
|
|
|
e******y
发帖数: 15 | 81 具体不说啦, 一次别人聊天时候说的,还举了例子
说为啥某个牛会上这两年某个topic文章很少.
【在 T**********n 的大作中提到】
: 这是哪个area啊？举个例子？赫赫
|
O******Y
发帖数: 88 | 82 A "5" will kill a paper most likely, as a chair told me before. I feel without
negative score like "4" or "5" is better than with them. I myself had a 114
paper that was rejected several years ago.
225.
那倒
英语
【在 r*****y 的大作中提到】
: according to majority voting, I feel 233 is worse than 224, 125, or even 225.
|
T**********n
发帖数: 480 | 83 在这说说没啥吧？赫赫，谁知道谁是谁啊
【在 e******y 的大作中提到】
: 具体不说啦, 一次别人聊天时候说的,还举了例子
: 说为啥某个牛会上这两年某个topic文章很少.
|
O******Y
发帖数: 88 | 84 that is very true. detection/recognition seems a good area though.
有的area里面的人都不nice,互相杀paper,特别狠,这样的area基本都是那种funding特
【在 e******y 的大作中提到】
: 具体不说啦, 一次别人聊天时候说的,还举了例子
: 说为啥某个牛会上这两年某个topic文章很少.
|
e******y
发帖数: 15 | 85 Graphics方面的,说了你也不感兴趣, 不说拉,
反正个人觉得acdemic够厚黑,够世俗.
【在 T**********n 的大作中提到】
: 在这说说没啥吧？赫赫，谁知道谁是谁啊
|
O******Y
发帖数: 88 | 86 Hehe...
"acdemic够厚黑,够世俗" It is so true. When people publish papers for living,
they have to play 厚黑 and 世俗.
【在 e******y 的大作中提到】
: Graphics方面的,说了你也不感兴趣, 不说拉,
: 反正个人觉得acdemic够厚黑,够世俗.
|
T**********n
发帖数: 480 | 87 graphics主要阵地在siggraph吧，赫赫，也来这趟浑水啊，已经够乱了
再说其实哪里不世俗，哪里不厚黑呢，赫赫
【在 e******y 的大作中提到】
: Graphics方面的,说了你也不感兴趣, 不说拉,
: 反正个人觉得acdemic够厚黑,够世俗.
|
r*****y
发帖数: 507 | 88 graphics?
I also heard some intersting comments:
some graphics conferences or topics are hijacked. :(
【在 e******y 的大作中提到】
: Graphics方面的,说了你也不感兴趣, 不说拉,
: 反正个人觉得acdemic够厚黑,够世俗.
|
e******y
发帖数: 15 | 89 为了提供更多给人糊口的position,
现在专门有个sub-area, vision for graphics,
就像俩难兄难弟一样.
【在 T**********n 的大作中提到】
: graphics主要阵地在siggraph吧，赫赫，也来这趟浑水啊，已经够乱了
: 再说其实哪里不世俗，哪里不厚黑呢，赫赫
|
O******Y
发帖数: 88 | 90 Since IBR, there are more and more vision guys involved into graphics. Now
video editing etc. seems a notable area in siggraph.
【在 e******y 的大作中提到】
: 为了提供更多给人糊口的position,
: 现在专门有个sub-area, vision for graphics,
: 就像俩难兄难弟一样.
|
|
|
e******y
发帖数: 15 | 91 114被锯太可惜了.
【在 O******Y 的大作中提到】
: A "5" will kill a paper most likely, as a chair told me before. I feel without
: negative score like "4" or "5" is better than with them. I myself had a 114
: paper that was rejected several years ago.
:
: 225.
: 那倒
: 英语
|
r*****y
发帖数: 507 | 92 I think it can be called "bad luck". it is not normal.
【在 e******y 的大作中提到】
: 114被锯太可惜了.
|
O******Y
发帖数: 88 | 93 That was not normal. However, I have never heard any accepted papers in cvpr
or iccv got a "5".
without
114
【在 r*****y 的大作中提到】
: I think it can be called "bad luck". it is not normal.
|
r*****y
发帖数: 507 | 94 only 3 reviewers, each has 1/3 weight, a "5" is too heavy.
【在 O******Y 的大作中提到】
: That was not normal. However, I have never heard any accepted papers in cvpr
: or iccv got a "5".
:
: without
: 114
|
S*********r
发帖数: 4729 | 95 Not necessary, our group memeber had an oral in last year's ICCV,
His score is 1 2 4.
without
全是1,2,就是clearance给了个3,说
unless
【在 O******Y 的大作中提到】
: A "5" will kill a paper most likely, as a chair told me before. I feel without
: negative score like "4" or "5" is better than with them. I myself had a 114
: paper that was rejected several years ago.
:
: 225.
: 那倒
: 英语
|
O******Y
发帖数: 88 | 96 That is very true. Too many submissions for vision conferences. So it is too
difficult to increase the number of reviewers...
cvpr
【在 r*****y 的大作中提到】
: only 3 reviewers, each has 1/3 weight, a "5" is too heavy.
|
S*********r
发帖数: 4729 | 97 My paper this time got a 5, really don't understand what that guy is
expecting to see from vision research. Our nice idea was then killed without
mercy.
cvpr
【在 r*****y 的大作中提到】
: only 3 reviewers, each has 1/3 weight, a "5" is too heavy.
|
T**********n
发帖数: 480 | 98 剩下的两个reviewer给了什么？
或者是不是你老板和人结过梁子？
【在 S*********r 的大作中提到】
: My paper this time got a 5, really don't understand what that guy is
: expecting to see from vision research. Our nice idea was then killed without
: mercy.
:
: cvpr
|
O******Y
发帖数: 88 | 99 That is called "good luck". It is not normal too.
114
域?
【在 S*********r 的大作中提到】
: My paper this time got a 5, really don't understand what that guy is
: expecting to see from vision research. Our nice idea was then killed without
: mercy.
:
: cvpr
|
O******Y
发帖数: 88 | 100 That happens, especially in an area like vision. On the other side, it is a
little greedy to publish every nice idea in iccv by only one trial. If the
idea is good, you can eventually publish it in top conferences.
【在 S*********r 的大作中提到】
: My paper this time got a 5, really don't understand what that guy is
: expecting to see from vision research. Our nice idea was then killed without
: mercy.
:
: cvpr
|
|
|
S*********r
发帖数: 4729 | 101 Just wrote the rebuttal, hope they don't feel our tone is too strong. We
only hope it is in next CVPR anyway.
without
in
【在 O******Y 的大作中提到】
: That happens, especially in an area like vision. On the other side, it is a
: little greedy to publish every nice idea in iccv by only one trial. If the
: idea is good, you can eventually publish it in top conferences.
|
O******Y
发帖数: 88 | 102 According to my experience, it is not helpful to have a strong tone. For last
CVPR, the comments from the area chair clearly said he did not like the strong
tone in our rebuttal and so the rebuttal was not taken into account. So be
careful.
a
【在 S*********r 的大作中提到】
: Just wrote the rebuttal, hope they don't feel our tone is too strong. We
: only hope it is in next CVPR anyway.
:
: without
: in
|
T**********n
发帖数: 480 | 103 这年头发个paper都得卑躬屈膝察言观色的，没劲，没前途呀
【在 O******Y 的大作中提到】
: According to my experience, it is not helpful to have a strong tone. For last
: CVPR, the comments from the area chair clearly said he did not like the strong
: tone in our rebuttal and so the rebuttal was not taken into account. So be
: careful.
:
: a
|
S*********r
发帖数: 4729 | 104 I was saying "I hope they don't feel...", because we give a rebuttal in a
very confident way. :( But I thank for your reminding again.
last
strong
is
the
papers
【在 O******Y 的大作中提到】
: According to my experience, it is not helpful to have a strong tone. For last
: CVPR, the comments from the area chair clearly said he did not like the strong
: tone in our rebuttal and so the rebuttal was not taken into account. So be
: careful.
:
: a
|
O******Y
发帖数: 88 | 105 sigh. life is not easy.
last
strong
We
【在 T**********n 的大作中提到】
: 这年头发个paper都得卑躬屈膝察言观色的，没劲，没前途呀
|
T**********n
发帖数: 480 | 106 不发了不发了，回家种田鼠都比这样有气魄
【在 O******Y 的大作中提到】
: sigh. life is not easy.
:
: last
: strong
: We
|
O******Y
发帖数: 88 | 107 hehe. first bitter, then sweet...
【在 T**********n 的大作中提到】
: 不发了不发了，回家种田鼠都比这样有气魄
|
v******d
发帖数: 1322 | 108 发paper混饭吃还不如去编程，编程至少编得好就是好，
没有什么reviewer
【在 O******Y 的大作中提到】
: hehe. first bitter, then sweet...
|
r*****y
发帖数: 507 | 109 customers are reviewers,
managers/directors are reviewers.
【在 v******d 的大作中提到】
: 发paper混饭吃还不如去编程，编程至少编得好就是好，
: 没有什么reviewer
|
w***f
发帖数: 75 | 110 正经公司把 Source code check in 到 main source tree 前都是要过一道
code reviewer 的。
【在 v******d 的大作中提到】
: 发paper混饭吃还不如去编程，编程至少编得好就是好，
: 没有什么reviewer
|
|
|
ie
发帖数: 1350 | 111 sign, same here
mine is also 2,3,3, keep finger corssed
【在 p*****s 的大作中提到】
: 那象2,3,3这种分数呢?
: 倒是没有一个人说probably reject , 一个给3的说clearance方面英文太差,让他读的费
: 劲, 其他方面都给的1, 2.
: 另一个给3的也没有狠批,就觉得文章创新性还不是非常的强,其他也还好.
: 所以的reviewer都觉得实验很好, 全是1, 2.
: 哪位给分析分析?
|
v******d
发帖数: 1322 | 112 这种review不会很BT吧，应该是有比较客观的标准，
不会有价值评判
【在 p*********e 的大作中提到】
: How do you know this information about other people's ICCV papers?
:
: 豪
: 理
: 高
: still
|
ie
发帖数: 1350 | 113 u got it
he is in MSRAsia right now
and his group has around 17 papers in ICCV2005, 9 of them have his name |
p*****s
发帖数: 8 | 114 Oh my goodness !!!
paper factory...
【在 ie 的大作中提到】
: u got it
: he is in MSRAsia right now
: and his group has around 17 papers in ICCV2005, 9 of them have his name
|
a***r
发帖数: 35 | 115
yes
I think they are more demanding
【在 r*****y 的大作中提到】
: customers are reviewers,
: managers/directors are reviewers.
|
a***r
发帖数: 35 | 116 ft..
【在 X*****r 的大作中提到】
: I am only publish on Joke Board
|
v******d
发帖数: 1322 | 117 demanding,but not rejection,only improving
【在 a***r 的大作中提到】
: ft..
|
