由买买提看人间百态

boards

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档,一周内的贴子最多显示50字,超过一周显示500字 访问原贴
Faculty版 - 文章被拒的原因无非有: (转载)
相关主题
请问各位老师们,这个review结果rebut还有戏吗?Email提前通知preferred reviewers合适吗?
paper reviewproposal 的review意见很差怎么办?
Mathematical Reviews会议论文的rebuttal到底什么意思?
paper review结果-reject with resubmission invitation能同时申请一个学校不同的两个学院的position么?
这种文章怎么审?有关审稿
Paper过了Notification没有收到通知是什么原因?投稿问题, REFEREE 建议发表却被据
what comments do you put for AE after reviewing a paper?NSF status 和 PO 改变代表什么?
请问是不是major revision在review panel里的地位特别重要能和editor argue吗
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: editor话题: times话题: normally话题: should话题: only
进入Faculty版参与讨论
1 (共1页)
p******e
发帖数: 164
1
according to my over 30 times' reviewing and around 30 times'
submission experiences, there are only four reasons for rejecting or being
rejected.
(1) you aim too high;
(2) your research has some serious flaws;
(3) your writing is bad;
(4) the reviewer is a nerd and the editor agrees with him.
You should take the responsibility for the first three.
only the fourth one should make you upset.
but you can still argue with the editor if you strongly think you are right.
Normally you don't have to pu
1 (共1页)
进入Faculty版参与讨论
相关主题
能和editor argue吗这种文章怎么审?
关于REVIEW PAPER的问题..谢了..Paper过了Notification没有收到通知是什么原因?
最近在写一篇review,发现自己远不如以前能扯了what comments do you put for AE after reviewing a paper?
有人一个interview都没有的吗???举个手吧。。。。。。。。。。。。。请问是不是major revision在review panel里的地位特别重要
请问各位老师们,这个review结果rebut还有戏吗?Email提前通知preferred reviewers合适吗?
paper reviewproposal 的review意见很差怎么办?
Mathematical Reviews会议论文的rebuttal到底什么意思?
paper review结果-reject with resubmission invitation能同时申请一个学校不同的两个学院的position么?
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: editor话题: times话题: normally话题: should话题: only