on
发帖数: 199 | 1 There is a lot of articles in internet about low stomach acid problems. Some
claims most people suffer too low instead of too much stomach acid. On the
other hand I failed to find a reputable site and it appears to me the
mainstream view is that if one has a reflux issue an acid suppressor would
be prescribed..
Is the above observation correct? Any comments/thoughts? (I'm a a lay person
) | s********o
发帖数: 3319 | 2 胃的正常环境就应该是酸的，有些疾病能破坏胃正常的
酸度。这种时候病人就为了胃功能的低下而苦苦挣扎。
Reflux是指胃里的内容物和胃酸返流到食道里，食道因此而痛苦不堪，胃其实在隔岸观
火。给病人antacid可以让病人的胃少分泌点酸，这样就算胃内容物返流到食道下端，
食道也不会被折磨得那么痛苦。这么做的代价就是胃的功能被抑制了。 | on
发帖数: 199 | 3
Thanks. But this doesn't address the question which is: some claims low
stomach acid can lead to Reflux problems and thus PPI, etc to reduce acid
production is NOT the right solution. However, I don't see any reputable
site to make this argument, so wonder if this argument is in the same
category like vaccine/autsim, etc;
【在 s********o 的大作中提到】
: 胃的正常环境就应该是酸的，有些疾病能破坏胃正常的
: 酸度。这种时候病人就为了胃功能的低下而苦苦挣扎。
: Reflux是指胃里的内容物和胃酸返流到食道里，食道因此而痛苦不堪，胃其实在隔岸观
: 火。给病人antacid可以让病人的胃少分泌点酸，这样就算胃内容物返流到食道下端，
: 食道也不会被折磨得那么痛苦。这么做的代价就是胃的功能被抑制了。
| g*****d
发帖数: 991 | 4 GERD or acid reflux, not much to do with the stomach. It's the problem of
lower esophageal sphincter muscle. So, don't worry about the question you
have. | A*******s
发帖数: 9638 | 5 I remember GI used to say: No acid, no ulcer. Even with the finding of H.
Pylori, I still think it is valid. That is why antiacid treatment works for
ulcer.
GERD's symptoms are also related to the acid, it does not matter how much.
In addition, the acid secretion is dynamic, the average base line may be
low, but the peak could be high enough to cause symptoms.
【在 on 的大作中提到】
:
: Thanks. But this doesn't address the question which is: some claims low
: stomach acid can lead to Reflux problems and thus PPI, etc to reduce acid
: production is NOT the right solution. However, I don't see any reputable
: site to make this argument, so wonder if this argument is in the same
: category like vaccine/autsim, etc;
|
|
