b******o
发帖数: 87 | 1 what is the charater of the current international political system?
how do the democratic peace theory, institutionalism chanllege the structural realsim?
how does the strutral realism explain why there does not exist balance of power
after the cold war? | a********e
发帖数: 10 | 2 哇
这些问题够回答一个学期的了
抛砖引玉一下
1. 这个似乎仁者见仁吧
2. 这几个ism都是并存的并且也相互渗透，简单的说就是democratic
peace认为democratic system is conducive to peace, 代表作品Russett "Grasping
the democratic peace"
institutionalism强调the regulating power of int'l institutions, and the
resulting peace among nations，我的感觉是这里的人大多也做IPE，Keohane, Nye之类
的；
Structural realism认为the anarchic int'l structure is the reason for states to
commit to realism，具体参见Waltz的大作啦
这些都强调international structure，或者是political system，不像traditional
realism (也许算上Mearshimer在内）
【在 b******o 的大作中提到】
: what is the charater of the current international political system?
: how do the democratic peace theory, institutionalism chanllege the structural realsim?
: how does the strutral realism explain why there does not exist balance of power
: after the cold war?
| b******o
发帖数: 87 | 3 can the democracy peace theory and institutionalims change the charater
of the current international system?
according to structrual realism, the balance of power will occur because the
anarnic and self-help international system. if the anarnic international
system can not be changed, the balance of power will exist. so I am wandering
does the democracy peace theory or instituionalism can change the anarchic and
self-help system? if they can, how?
【在 a********e 的大作中提到】
: 哇
: 这些问题够回答一个学期的了
: 抛砖引玉一下
: 1. 这个似乎仁者见仁吧
: 2. 这几个ism都是并存的并且也相互渗透，简单的说就是democratic
: peace认为democratic system is conducive to peace, 代表作品Russett "Grasping
: the democratic peace"
: institutionalism强调the regulating power of int'l institutions, and the
: resulting peace among nations，我的感觉是这里的人大多也做IPE，Keohane, Nye之类
: 的；
| a********e
发帖数: 10 | 4 那些realism, liberalism, neoreal, neoliberal,以及constructivism等等诸如此类，
应该都只是关于认识int'l system的一些理论，所以这个问题的提法其实是：理论A和B能
否改变理论C认识的世界？所以这个……咋说捏
当然了，作为一个有点倾向于post-positivism的人，我是认为这些理论，思潮，文化等
等是可以改变社会的客观存在的——具体分析见一大堆constructivism的作品。
Structural realism其实我不是很喜欢，所以也没什么研究，只能估计他们的response要
么是现在属于power
structure重组阶段，要么是说本质上一直也没什么改变，毕竟neo-realism应该还是IR的
主流吧，因为确实也相当合理的
不过这里啥时候变成IR theory的讨论区了？好久没说过这些，忘的已经差不多了……救
命啊
wandering
and
"Grasping
Nye之类
states to
家都
，大
of
【在 b******o 的大作中提到】
: can the democracy peace theory and institutionalims change the charater
: of the current international system?
: according to structrual realism, the balance of power will occur because the
: anarnic and self-help international system. if the anarnic international
: system can not be changed, the balance of power will exist. so I am wandering
: does the democracy peace theory or instituionalism can change the anarchic and
: self-help system? if they can, how?
|
|
