w******8
发帖数: 115 | 1 1: 第一个(一天审完):The manuscript is well written and structured, and the
problem the
authors address is certainly interesting. However, due to the mainly
experimental/empirical work and the lack even of a semiquantitative
model for interpreting the experiments, my feeling is that PRL is not
the appropriate journal to publish this research. The manuscript could
perhaps be published in Physical Review E, provided that a convenient
model to explain the experimental findings can be added.
2:第二个指出一些问题,但都是我门可以回答的.
请问长问反驳有希望吗?应该怎样回答.我们的确没有自己推导的模型. |
N***m
发帖数: 4460 | 2 你哪个方向的？
【在 w******8 的大作中提到】
: 1: 第一个(一天审完):The manuscript is well written and structured, and the
: problem the
: authors address is certainly interesting. However, due to the mainly
: experimental/empirical work and the lack even of a semiquantitative
: model for interpreting the experiments, my feeling is that PRL is not
: the appropriate journal to publish this research. The manuscript could
: perhaps be published in Physical Review E, provided that a convenient
: model to explain the experimental findings can be added.
: 2:第二个指出一些问题,但都是我门可以回答的.
: 请问长问反驳有希望吗?应该怎样回答.我们的确没有自己推导的模型.
|
l****u
发帖数: 3449 | 3 最恨的就是这种意见，没有具体指出问题，而是说不适合啊，不interesting啊，这种
就很难argue，因为这是很主观的感受
【在 w******8 的大作中提到】
: 1: 第一个(一天审完):The manuscript is well written and structured, and the
: problem the
: authors address is certainly interesting. However, due to the mainly
: experimental/empirical work and the lack even of a semiquantitative
: model for interpreting the experiments, my feeling is that PRL is not
: the appropriate journal to publish this research. The manuscript could
: perhaps be published in Physical Review E, provided that a convenient
: model to explain the experimental findings can be added.
: 2:第二个指出一些问题,但都是我门可以回答的.
: 请问长问反驳有希望吗?应该怎样回答.我们的确没有自己推导的模型.
|
j******i
发帖数: 244 | 4 可以找个理论的合作者啊
【在 w******8 的大作中提到】
: 1: 第一个(一天审完):The manuscript is well written and structured, and the
: problem the
: authors address is certainly interesting. However, due to the mainly
: experimental/empirical work and the lack even of a semiquantitative
: model for interpreting the experiments, my feeling is that PRL is not
: the appropriate journal to publish this research. The manuscript could
: perhaps be published in Physical Review E, provided that a convenient
: model to explain the experimental findings can be added.
: 2:第二个指出一些问题,但都是我门可以回答的.
: 请问长问反驳有希望吗?应该怎样回答.我们的确没有自己推导的模型.
|
w******8
发帖数: 115 | 5 状态还是with editors...
The resulting reports include a critique which is sufficiently adverse
that we cannot accept your paper on the basis of material now at hand.
We append pertinent comments.
If you feel that you can overcome or refute the criticism, you may
resubmit to Physical Review Letters. With any resubmittal, please
include a summary of changes made and a brief response to all
recommendations and criticisms
上面这句话的意思是编辑表示我们还可以继续更改对吗？是不是所有的拒信都这样？
【在 j******i 的大作中提到】
: 可以找个理论的合作者啊
|
N***m
发帖数: 4460 | 6 你不能忽视第一个审稿人的意见
【在 w******8 的大作中提到】
: 状态还是with editors...
: The resulting reports include a critique which is sufficiently adverse
: that we cannot accept your paper on the basis of material now at hand.
: We append pertinent comments.
: If you feel that you can overcome or refute the criticism, you may
: resubmit to Physical Review Letters. With any resubmittal, please
: include a summary of changes made and a brief response to all
: recommendations and criticisms
: 上面这句话的意思是编辑表示我们还可以继续更改对吗？是不是所有的拒信都这样？
|
h********2
发帖数: 43 | 7 不定量对PRL来说算是硬伤，这点比Nature都严格
不过整个半定量的模型也不能吧，修改一下看第一个人的态度。
【在 w******8 的大作中提到】
: 1: 第一个(一天审完):The manuscript is well written and structured, and the
: problem the
: authors address is certainly interesting. However, due to the mainly
: experimental/empirical work and the lack even of a semiquantitative
: model for interpreting the experiments, my feeling is that PRL is not
: the appropriate journal to publish this research. The manuscript could
: perhaps be published in Physical Review E, provided that a convenient
: model to explain the experimental findings can be added.
: 2:第二个指出一些问题,但都是我门可以回答的.
: 请问长问反驳有希望吗?应该怎样回答.我们的确没有自己推导的模型.
|
d******g
发帖数: 346 | 8 Sure. Never stop trying. But it is also important to make some improvement
of your paper. |
t****a
发帖数: 3544 | 9 老板是大牛吗？ 是的话一定要试
不是的话，appeal成功几乎不可能 不过可以用来增加经验值 |
w******8
发帖数: 115 | 10 老板是刚刚AP不久的.，编辑说可以resubmit,是不是不算Appeal?
好像我们这个不算Appeal,【 在 tayama (电饭煲上校挖坑专员) 的大作中提到: 】 |
|
|
w******8
发帖数: 115 | 11 既然第一个说可以去投E, 编辑让我们重投，是不是说编辑对我们的工作还有点兴趣？
【在 N***m 的大作中提到】
: 你不能忽视第一个审稿人的意见
|
w******8
发帖数: 115 | 12 还是整个半定量模型把
【在 h********2 的大作中提到】
: 不定量对PRL来说算是硬伤，这点比Nature都严格
: 不过整个半定量的模型也不能吧，修改一下看第一个人的态度。
|
w******8
发帖数: 115 | 13 1: 第一个(一天审完):The manuscript is well written and structured, and the
problem the
authors address is certainly interesting. However, due to the mainly
experimental/empirical work and the lack even of a semiquantitative
model for interpreting the experiments, my feeling is that PRL is not
the appropriate journal to publish this research. The manuscript could
perhaps be published in Physical Review E, provided that a convenient
model to explain the experimental findings can be added.
2:第二个指出一些问题,但都是我门可以回答的.
请问长问反驳有希望吗?应该怎样回答.我们的确没有自己推导的模型. |
N***m
发帖数: 4460 | 14 你哪个方向的？
【在 w******8 的大作中提到】
: 1: 第一个(一天审完):The manuscript is well written and structured, and the
: problem the
: authors address is certainly interesting. However, due to the mainly
: experimental/empirical work and the lack even of a semiquantitative
: model for interpreting the experiments, my feeling is that PRL is not
: the appropriate journal to publish this research. The manuscript could
: perhaps be published in Physical Review E, provided that a convenient
: model to explain the experimental findings can be added.
: 2:第二个指出一些问题,但都是我门可以回答的.
: 请问长问反驳有希望吗?应该怎样回答.我们的确没有自己推导的模型.
|
l****u
发帖数: 3449 | 15 最恨的就是这种意见，没有具体指出问题，而是说不适合啊，不interesting啊，这种
就很难argue，因为这是很主观的感受
【在 w******8 的大作中提到】
: 1: 第一个(一天审完):The manuscript is well written and structured, and the
: problem the
: authors address is certainly interesting. However, due to the mainly
: experimental/empirical work and the lack even of a semiquantitative
: model for interpreting the experiments, my feeling is that PRL is not
: the appropriate journal to publish this research. The manuscript could
: perhaps be published in Physical Review E, provided that a convenient
: model to explain the experimental findings can be added.
: 2:第二个指出一些问题,但都是我门可以回答的.
: 请问长问反驳有希望吗?应该怎样回答.我们的确没有自己推导的模型.
|
j******i
发帖数: 244 | 16 可以找个理论的合作者啊
【在 w******8 的大作中提到】
: 1: 第一个(一天审完):The manuscript is well written and structured, and the
: problem the
: authors address is certainly interesting. However, due to the mainly
: experimental/empirical work and the lack even of a semiquantitative
: model for interpreting the experiments, my feeling is that PRL is not
: the appropriate journal to publish this research. The manuscript could
: perhaps be published in Physical Review E, provided that a convenient
: model to explain the experimental findings can be added.
: 2:第二个指出一些问题,但都是我门可以回答的.
: 请问长问反驳有希望吗?应该怎样回答.我们的确没有自己推导的模型.
|
w******8
发帖数: 115 | 17 状态还是with editors...
The resulting reports include a critique which is sufficiently adverse
that we cannot accept your paper on the basis of material now at hand.
We append pertinent comments.
If you feel that you can overcome or refute the criticism, you may
resubmit to Physical Review Letters. With any resubmittal, please
include a summary of changes made and a brief response to all
recommendations and criticisms
上面这句话的意思是编辑表示我们还可以继续更改对吗？是不是所有的拒信都这样？
【在 j******i 的大作中提到】
: 可以找个理论的合作者啊
|
N***m
发帖数: 4460 | 18 你不能忽视第一个审稿人的意见
【在 w******8 的大作中提到】
: 状态还是with editors...
: The resulting reports include a critique which is sufficiently adverse
: that we cannot accept your paper on the basis of material now at hand.
: We append pertinent comments.
: If you feel that you can overcome or refute the criticism, you may
: resubmit to Physical Review Letters. With any resubmittal, please
: include a summary of changes made and a brief response to all
: recommendations and criticisms
: 上面这句话的意思是编辑表示我们还可以继续更改对吗？是不是所有的拒信都这样？
|
h********2
发帖数: 43 | 19 不定量对PRL来说算是硬伤，这点比Nature都严格
不过整个半定量的模型也不能吧，修改一下看第一个人的态度。
【在 w******8 的大作中提到】
: 1: 第一个(一天审完):The manuscript is well written and structured, and the
: problem the
: authors address is certainly interesting. However, due to the mainly
: experimental/empirical work and the lack even of a semiquantitative
: model for interpreting the experiments, my feeling is that PRL is not
: the appropriate journal to publish this research. The manuscript could
: perhaps be published in Physical Review E, provided that a convenient
: model to explain the experimental findings can be added.
: 2:第二个指出一些问题,但都是我门可以回答的.
: 请问长问反驳有希望吗?应该怎样回答.我们的确没有自己推导的模型.
|
d******g
发帖数: 346 | 20 Sure. Never stop trying. But it is also important to make some improvement
of your paper. |
|
|
t****a
发帖数: 3544 | 21 老板是大牛吗？ 是的话一定要试
不是的话，appeal成功几乎不可能 不过可以用来增加经验值 |
w******8
发帖数: 115 | 22 老板是刚刚AP不久的.，编辑说可以resubmit,是不是不算Appeal?
好像我们这个不算Appeal,【 在 tayama (电饭煲上校挖坑专员) 的大作中提到: 】 |
w******8
发帖数: 115 | 23 既然第一个说可以去投E, 编辑让我们重投，是不是说编辑对我们的工作还有点兴趣？
【在 N***m 的大作中提到】
: 你不能忽视第一个审稿人的意见
|
w******8
发帖数: 115 | 24 还是整个半定量模型把
【在 h********2 的大作中提到】
: 不定量对PRL来说算是硬伤，这点比Nature都严格
: 不过整个半定量的模型也不能吧，修改一下看第一个人的态度。
|
w******8
发帖数: 115 | 25 反馈一下：文章接受了，谢谢大家。
【在 w******8 的大作中提到】
: 1: 第一个(一天审完):The manuscript is well written and structured, and the
: problem the
: authors address is certainly interesting. However, due to the mainly
: experimental/empirical work and the lack even of a semiquantitative
: model for interpreting the experiments, my feeling is that PRL is not
: the appropriate journal to publish this research. The manuscript could
: perhaps be published in Physical Review E, provided that a convenient
: model to explain the experimental findings can be added.
: 2:第二个指出一些问题,但都是我门可以回答的.
: 请问长问反驳有希望吗?应该怎样回答.我们的确没有自己推导的模型.
|
l********n
发帖数: 804 | 26 怎么appeal的
说说经验
【在 w******8 的大作中提到】
: 反馈一下：文章接受了，谢谢大家。
|
w******8
发帖数: 115 | 27 没有appeal.编辑说resubmission..然后我们就努力修改，第二关的时候第一轮据绝我
们的那个不审了，找了另外一个也没审。后来进入第三关，修改之后就接受了。
【在 l********n 的大作中提到】
: 怎么appeal的
: 说说经验
|
